Amazon Listing Removed for Product Safety: Your Options

Share this article

WhatsAppLinkedIn

Published on

If your Amazon listing is removed for product safety on a European marketplace, the route depends on who decided: a notifier, the marketplace itself or an authority. Under Regulation (EU) 2022/2065 (DSA) and Regulation (EU) 2023/988 (GPSR) the marketplace owes its users reasons and a complaint route. MAAK Advocaten N.V., a law firm in Amsterdam, advises sellers on that route.

In short

  • A notice, the marketplace’s own investigation or an authority’s order can each lead to removal, with different rules (DSA Article 16; GPSR Article 22).
  • With your contact details, and unless an Article 9 order removed it, the marketplace owes reasons; larger platforms also owe an internal complaint route (DSA Articles 17, 19 and 20).
  • After an authority’s order, the marketplace has two working days to act, and your answer may be aimed at the authority (GPSR Article 22(4)).
  • Have your reply, the authority’s order or any supplier indemnity reviewed by a lawyer before you commit to a position.

This article is part of our overview of product compliance in the Netherlands. It is written for sellers outside the EU, and for EU sellers, on marketplaces such as Amazon.de, Amazon.nl or bol. It does not cover counterfeit notices (see notice and takedown on marketplaces) or advice under non-EU law.

What should you do first when a marketplace removes your listing for product safety?

Find out who took the decision, on the day you notice. Keep the marketplace’s message, ask for the statement of reasons, which the marketplace owes you if the DSA applies to you, it has your electronic contact details and the removal is not an order under Article 9 (DSA Article 17(1), (2) and (5)), and collect your product documents.

A listing for a product that breaches a Union rule can count as illegal content: the DSA’s definition covers information relating to the sale of products that does not comply with Union law (Article 3(h)).

You can do these steps yourself or with an adviser:

  • save the message and a screenshot of the removed listing;
  • gather the product file, test reports and the manufacturer’s details;
  • check that the listing shows what the GPSR asks: manufacturer, a responsible person in the Union where the manufacturer is outside it, product identification, warnings and safety information (Articles 19 and 22(9)).

What you then say to the marketplace depends on facts you cannot always weigh yourself: your role in the chain, your supplier contract and what the product file shows.

Important: The marketplace asks you to confirm or explain the safety problem within days. What you write counts later. A marketplace that actually knows a product is dangerous must also inform the authorities (GPSR Article 22(12)(d)). Have a Dutch product law lawyer review your reply before you send it.

Is your listing offline and the statement of reasons vague or missing? Put your situation to Martin Krüger, our product law partner in the Netherlands, before you reply.

Who decided: a notifier, the marketplace or an authority?

Three sources can lead to a removal, and each has its own rules. The GPSR calls the platform a provider of an online marketplace (Article 3(14)).

SourceWhat the text saysWhat it means for you
Notice from a third partyThe marketplace runs a notice and action mechanism (DSA Article 16); product safety notices are handled within three working days (GPSR Article 22(8)); trusted flaggers get priority (DSA Article 22(1)).The marketplace must decide in a timely, diligent, non-arbitrary and objective manner (Article 16(6)).
The marketplace’s own initiativeVoluntary own-initiative investigations (DSA Article 17(3)(b)) and voluntary measures (GPSR Article 22(6)); the marketplace also checks official databases at random, using at least the Safety Gate Portal (DSA Article 31(3); GPSR Article 22(7)).The marketplace’s message may say it acted on its own initiative.
An authority’s orderMarket surveillance authorities can order removal; the marketplace acts within two working days of receipt (GPSR Article 22(4)).The marketplace is carrying out the order, so the question moves to the authority.

Where the marketplace gives a statement of reasons, it must contain at least the measure and the facts relied on, including, where relevant, whether the decision followed a notice or the marketplace’s own investigation, and, for allegedly illegal content, the legal ground with an explanation (DSA Article 17(3)). Article 17 does not apply to orders under Article 9 (Article 17(5)), so for an authority’s order there may be no such statement. If the message is vague, who decided is the first question. The marketplace must also inform the relevant economic operator, which may be you, of its decision to remove content that refers to an offer of a dangerous product (GPSR Article 22(12)(b)).

The route differs per source. If you treat an authority’s order as a platform error, you complain to the wrong party.

Important: The marketplace’s message says an authority ordered the removal. The marketplace must act within two working days of receiving such an order (GPSR Article 22(4)), so your answer may now be directed at the authority as well as the marketplace. Which authority acted and which remedies exist, we read from the order. Have a Dutch product law lawyer read the order before you answer either of them.

What must the marketplace tell you, and how do you complain?

Where the marketplace restricts your content on the ground that it is illegal or breaches its terms, it must give a clear and specific statement of reasons, provided it has your electronic contact details (DSA Article 17(1) and (2)). An online platform must also offer an internal complaint-handling system that stays open for at least six months after its decision (Article 20(1)).

The complaint is electronic and free. The marketplace handles it in a timely, non-discriminatory, diligent and non-arbitrary manner and reverses its decision without undue delay if the complaint warrants it (Article 20(4)).

Two points decide how far this helps you. The duty to give reasons applies only where the marketplace knows your contact details, and not to “deceptive high-volume commercial content” (Article 17(2)). And the complaint, settlement, trusted-flagger, suspension, traceability, random-check and information rules of Articles 20 to 23 and 30 to 32 do not apply to platforms that are micro or small enterprises, unless they are very large platforms (Articles 19 and 29). Whether your marketplace falls under that exclusion is a question of fact. These rights belong to recipients of the service who are established or located in the Union (DSA Article 2(1)); whether they cover a seller outside the EU, we assess per file.

In the Netherlands, the Authority for Consumers and Markets (ACM) is the digital services coordinator and supervises parts of Articles 16, 17 and 20 to 23 of the DSA, among others (Uitvoeringswet digitaledienstenverordening, Articles 2.1 and 2.2).

What if the marketplace rejects your complaint?

You have routes besides the court: out-of-court dispute settlement, a complaint to a digital services coordinator and a claim for damages. The right to go to court stays open at any stage (DSA Article 21(1)).

RouteWhat the text says
Out-of-court dispute settlementA certified body; both sides take part in good faith; the body cannot impose a binding solution; decision within 90 calendar days, extendable to 180; if you win, the marketplace bears the body’s fees and reimburses your reasonable expenses (Article 21(2), (4), (5)).
Complaint to the coordinatorA complaint alleging an infringement of the DSA, with the digital services coordinator of the Member State where you are located or established; whether this route is open to you depends on that (Article 53).
DamagesCompensation for loss caused by a DSA infringement, under Union and national law (Article 54).

Which route fits depends on what you want. If you need the listing back quickly, a well-founded complaint plus a letter is often faster than a procedure. If you want a binding ruling or damages, you go to court. Settlement can take up to 90 days, or 180 in very complex disputes, and the body cannot impose a binding solution, so we say that plainly before a client chooses it. Where a court case runs, and on what ground, depends on the marketplace and your contract; we assess that per file.

What happens to your account and your customers?

After a prior warning, a marketplace suspends for a reasonable period its services to traders that frequently offer products that do not comply with the GPSR (Article 22(11)) and to recipients that frequently provide manifestly illegal content (DSA Article 23(1)). Repeated removals can prompt such a warning.

The difference between one listing and a pattern is the legal question behind the warning, and what you write in reply counts.

Customers can be told, too. When an online platform becomes aware that an illegal product was offered, it informs, as far as it has their contact details, consumers who bought it in the six months before it became aware of the illegality, stating that the product is illegal, who the trader is and what redress exists (DSA Article 32(1)). If it does not have the contact details of all the consumers concerned, it publishes this on its interface (Article 32(2)). Your name can therefore reach your customers.

What can you arrange yourself, and where does your supply chain come in?

You can gather the product file, order tests and complete the listing information yourself or with an adviser.

The rules reach sellers outside the EU. An online offer counts as made available on the Union market if it targets consumers in the Union (GPSR Article 4), and a product needs an economic operator established in the Union for the responsible person’s tasks (Article 16(1)). A seller also certifies to the marketplace that it offers only products that comply with Union law (DSA Article 30(1)(e)). For that role, see EU authorised representative in the Netherlands and our overview of the GPSR.

Sellers outside the EU often assume that a removed listing concerns only them and the marketplace, and that a complaint in their home country helps. The marketplace applies EU rules, and the removal can come from an EU authority’s order. Whether you can also invoke the rights of the DSA (reasons, complaint, settlement, complaint to a coordinator) depends on where you are established or located (Articles 2(1) and 53); we assess that per file.

In the supply chain, four points matter: who supplies the manufacturer and safety data, who is the responsible person in the Union, how fast a marketplace question gets an answer, and who bears the loss of an offline listing. How the contract fixes them decides whether you have recourse against your supplier; we do that per file.

Important: Your foreign supplier denies the problem, or your importer asks you to accept the responsible person role in the Union together with an indemnity (GPSR Article 16(1)). The wording of that indemnity decides who pays for the product and for the loss from a removal. Ask a Dutch product law lawyer to read it before you sign.

Example: three listings offline in one week

Say a seller outside the EU sees three listings of the same product disappear in one week, with a message that the product does not meet EU safety rules, and then a warning that the account may be suspended. First the seller establishes who decided and asks for the statement of reasons, if one is owed, before replying to the warning (GPSR Article 22(11)). This is a fictional example, not a case from our practice.

When do you need a Dutch lawyer for a removed listing?

You need one when reasons are missing, a complaint is rejected, an authority has ordered removal, the marketplace warns of suspension or a supplier refuses to cooperate. What you write counts.

Your situationWhy a lawyer, not only a test labWhat we do in the first days
Reasons missing or vague (DSA Article 17)A test lab reports on the product; a lawyer establishes whether the marketplace acted on a notice, on its own or on an orderRequest and review the reasons; prepare the complaint under Article 20
Complaint rejected (Articles 21, 53, 54)Choosing between settlement, coordinator and court is strategyChoose and prepare the route
Authority’s order (GPSR Article 22(4))The response is aimed at the authority, and what you write there countsReview the order, contact the authority, assess which remedies exist
Warning of suspension (GPSR Article 22(11); DSA Article 23(1))What you write in reply countsReply to the warning

How does MAAK Advocaten work on removed listings?

We act for sellers, including manufacturers and importers, against marketplaces and authorities: reviewing reasons, preparing the complaint, choosing the route, contacting the authority, assessing the remedies, reviewing supplier and importer contracts, and court proceedings in the Netherlands in first instance and on appeal. Testing and the product file stay with you or your adviser.

Frequently asked questions about a listing removed for product safety

Who can have my listing removed for product safety?

A third party through the notice and action mechanism (DSA Article 16), the marketplace itself on its own initiative (DSA Article 17(3)(b); GPSR Article 22(6)) or a market surveillance authority by order (GPSR Article 22(4)). A statement of reasons can show which one applies; for orders under Article 9 DSA none is owed (Article 17(5)).

How quickly must a marketplace act on a product safety notice or order?

Without delay and within three working days of receiving a product safety notice (GPSR Article 22(8)), and without delay and within two working days of receiving an authority’s removal order (GPSR Article 22(4)). The marketplace must also report the effect of an order.

Must the marketplace give me reasons and an appeal route?

Yes, if the DSA applies to you as a recipient established or located in the Union and the marketplace has your electronic contact details: a clear and specific statement of reasons for a restriction on the ground that content is illegal or breaches its terms (DSA Article 17(1) and (2); none for orders under Article 9, Article 17(5)) and an internal complaint-handling system open for at least six months after the decision (Article 20), unless the platform is a micro or small enterprise (Article 19).

Can I go to court or to a regulator instead of waiting?

Yes. Out-of-court settlement under DSA Article 21 cannot be imposed in a binding way, and the right to go to court stays open at any stage. You can also complain to the digital services coordinator of the Member State where you are located or established (Article 53), if the DSA applies to you, and claim damages under Union and national law (Article 54).

When should I contact a Dutch lawyer about a removed listing?

When the reasons are vague, your complaint is rejected, an authority has ordered the removal, the marketplace warns of suspension or your supplier refuses to cooperate. MAAK Advocaten reviews the decision, the route and the contract chain.

Primary sources

Has a marketplace removed your listing for product safety and is it unclear who decided and what you can do? Put your situation to Martin Krüger, our product law partner in the Netherlands.

News & Insights
Which topics would you like to receive updates on?
Who are you?
Which industry or sector do you operate in? (Optional)