Published on · Last updated
A recall gets back a product consumers already have; a withdrawal stops one still in the supply chain. Under the General Product Safety Regulation (EU) 2023/988 (GPSR), a manufacturer of a product outside Union harmonisation legislation that has reason to believe its product is dangerous must immediately take corrective measures, inform consumers and notify the authorities (Article 9(8) GPSR).
In short
- Food falls under Regulation (EC) 178/2002 (Article 19); other consumer products fall under the GPSR, unless harmonisation legislation applies (Article 2 GPSR).
- The GPSR sets no fixed hours: act and inform the authorities immediately (Article 9(8)); a recall notice must meet Article 36.
- Consumers are entitled to an effective, cost-free remedy, normally a choice between at least two of repair, replacement and refund (Article 37).
- Involve a Dutch lawyer when notification, remedies or recovery from a supplier or insurer is disputed.
A product recall under Dutch law involves decisions on communication, notification to the Netherlands Food and Consumer Product Safety Authority (NVWA) and contact with trading partners, and it touches product liability, insurance and contractual recourse. For manufacturers, importers and distributors in the Netherlands, both national and EU rules on product safety apply. On enforcement, see our page on penalty from a Dutch regulatory authority.
What Constitutes a Product Recall Under Dutch Law?
The GPSR definitions apply directly in the Netherlands. A withdrawal prevents a product in the supply chain from being made available on the market; a recall aims at the return of a product that has already been made available to the consumer (Article 3(25) and (26) GPSR). Economic operators may place or make available only safe products (Article 5 GPSR; see our page on the GPSR). A manufacturer that has reason to believe its product is dangerous must immediately take corrective measures, including a withdrawal or recall where appropriate (Article 9(8) GPSR).
A recall carried out without a public announcement is sometimes called a silent recall. The GPSR has no such category: where a recall reaches consumers, all identifiable affected consumers must be notified directly (Article 35(1)) and a recall notice published where not all can be reached (Article 35(4)). The duty to inform the market surveillance authorities applies either way (Article 9(8)(c)).
The GPSR places obligations on each economic operator: manufacturers (Article 9), importers (Article 11) and distributors (Article 12). Civil liability for damage is a separate matter. Under Dutch product liability law (productaansprakelijkheid), the producer is liable for damage caused by a defect in its product without proof of fault, subject to the defences in Article 6:185(1) Dutch Civil Code. Anyone who imports the product into the European Economic Area to sell, lease or otherwise supply it in the course of commercial activities is treated as the producer (Article 6:187(3)). If the producer cannot be identified, each supplier is treated as the producer, unless it names the producer, or the person who supplied it, to the injured person within a reasonable time (Article 6:187(4)).
The trigger is a dangerous product: any product that is not a safe product (Article 3(3) GPSR). Risk is the combination of the probability that a hazard causes harm and the severity of that harm (Article 3(4)). Whether a withdrawal is enough or a recall is needed depends on whether the product has already reached consumers and on the risk. The duty to act applies immediately (Article 9(8)).
Which Products Fall Under Recall Obligations in the Netherlands?
The law distinguishes between food and non-food products. Food is excluded from the GPSR (Article 2(2)(b) GPSR) and falls under the General Food Law Regulation (EC) 178/2002. Under Article 19(1), a food business operator that has reason to believe that food it has imported, produced, processed, manufactured or distributed does not meet food safety requirements must immediately start procedures to withdraw it from the market where it has left the operator’s immediate control, and inform the competent authorities. If the food may have reached the consumer, the operator must inform consumers and, if necessary, recall the products when other measures are not sufficient. It must also immediately inform the competent authorities if it has reason to believe that food it has placed on the market may be injurious to human health (Article 19(3)).
Non-food consumer products fall under the GPSR, which replaced the General Product Safety Directive 2001/95/EC from 13 December 2024 (Articles 50(1) and 52). Where specific EU product legislation covers certain risks, the GPSR only applies to the aspects and risks not covered by that legislation (Article 2(1)). For products under Union harmonisation legislation, Article 2(1) also switches off Chapter III, Section 1 of the GPSR (Articles 9 to 18), including the duty in Article 9(8). For products covered by the legislation listed in Article 4(5) of Regulation (EU) 2019/1020, such as toys under Directive 2009/48/EC, Article 4(3) of that Regulation requires the responsible economic operator to inform the market surveillance authorities when it has reason to believe the product presents a risk, and to ensure the necessary corrective action. Check which regime covers your product before you rely on the GPSR articles on this page.
Importers must ensure, before placing a product on the market, that it complies with the general safety requirement and that the manufacturer has met the requirements in Article 9(2), (5) and (6) (Article 11(1) GPSR). The GPSR also requires an economic operator established in the EU who is responsible for the product (Article 16(1)).
How Do You Organize an Effective Product Recall Under Dutch Law?
Start with a short written file that records the product identification, the risk analysis, the corrective measures and the communication to consumers and authorities. The legal duty is to act immediately once you have reason to believe the product is dangerous (Article 9(8) GPSR). Manufacturers must also keep an internal register of complaints, product recalls and corrective measures (Article 9(12)).
A written recall notice must be easy to understand, be available in the language(s) of the Member States where the product was sold, and carry the headline “Product safety recall” (Article 36(2) GPSR). It must include a picture, name and brand of the product, identification numbers such as batch or serial numbers, a clear description of the hazard, an instruction to stop using the product immediately, the available remedies and a free phone number or interactive online service. Avoid words that play down the risk, such as “voluntary” or “precautionary” (Article 36(2)(c)). The Commission sets out a template for the recall notice by implementing act (Article 36(3)).
What Solutions Must You Offer Consumers in the Netherlands?
The economic operator responsible for the recall must offer an effective, cost-free and timely remedy (Article 37(1) GPSR). As a rule, consumers must be able to choose between at least two of three options: repair, replacement with a safe product of the same type and at least the same value and quality, or a refund of at least the price paid (Article 37(2)). Consumers do not bear the costs of returning the product (Article 37(5)). Repair by consumers themselves only counts as an effective remedy if it can be done easily and safely and is provided for in the recall notice (Article 37(3)).
The consumer is always entitled to a refund if repair or replacement is not completed within a reasonable time and without significant inconvenience (Article 37(2) GPSR).
What Are Your Notification Obligations to the Netherlands Food and Consumer Product Safety Authority?
For products outside Union harmonisation legislation, a manufacturer or importer that has reason to believe a product it has placed on the market is dangerous must inform the market surveillance authorities of every Member State where the product was made available, through the EU Safety Business Gateway (Articles 9(8)(c) and 11(8)(d) GPSR); a distributor must ensure that those authorities are immediately informed, after immediately informing the manufacturer or importer (Article 12(4)(a) and (c)). In the Netherlands, the Netherlands Food and Consumer Product Safety Authority (Nederlandse Voedsel- en Warenautoriteit, NVWA) supervises the safety of consumer products, and the Commodities Act (Warenwet) contains the Minister’s enforcement powers.
The notification must give details of the risk to consumers, of the corrective measures already taken and, if available, of the quantity of products still circulating on the market per Member State (Article 9(8), second subparagraph, GPSR). If an economic operator fails to take appropriate measures, the Minister can order it to withdraw or recall the dangerous product (Article 32h(1) Warenwet); failing to carry out that order is an offence (Article 32h(2)). Article 21(1) Warenwet lets the Minister order a trader of goods outside the GPSR to inform holders of the danger without delay; for non-food goods, Article 21(2) also allows an order to stop trading or take the goods back. Article 21 does not apply to products covered by the GPSR (Article 21(4)).
What Deadlines Apply for Notifications Under Dutch Law?
The GPSR does not set a fixed number of hours. A manufacturer or importer that has reason to believe a product is dangerous must act and inform the authorities immediately (Articles 9(8) and 11(8) GPSR); a distributor must immediately inform the manufacturer or importer and ensure that the authorities are immediately informed (Article 12(4)). An accident caused by a product that resulted in death or serious adverse effects on a person’s health and safety must be notified by the manufacturer through the Safety Business Gateway, without undue delay, to the authorities of the Member State where it occurred (Article 20(1) and (2)). Importers and distributors who learn of such an accident must inform the manufacturer without undue delay (Article 20(3)).
Late or missing notification exposes you to enforcement by the NVWA. The GPSR leaves penalties to the Member States, which must make them effective, proportionate and dissuasive (Article 44 GPSR).
Important: The GPSR sets no fixed number of hours: manufacturers, importers and distributors must act and inform the authorities immediately once they have reason to believe a product is dangerous. For products under Union harmonisation legislation, other provisions apply (Article 2(1) GPSR), so first establish which regime covers the product. A Dutch lawyer should check the regime and the content of the notification before you inform consumers or authorities.
Also notify your insurer. Under Dutch insurance law, the policyholder must report the occurrence of the insured risk as soon as reasonably possible (Article 7:941(1) Dutch Civil Code); the policy may contain more specific terms. If you fail to do so, the insurer can reduce the payment by the damage it suffers as a result (Article 7:941(3)). Document all notifications with date and time for possible later evidence.
International supply chains complicate notification. If products have been distributed in several Member States, you inform the authorities of each of them through the Safety Business Gateway (Article 9(8)(c) GPSR). Member States then notify corrective measures concerning dangerous products presenting a serious risk through the Safety Gate Rapid Alert System (Articles 25 and 26(1)).
How Do You Communicate the Recall to Consumers in the Netherlands?
All affected consumers who can be identified must be notified directly and without undue delay, and businesses that collect their customers’ personal data must use it for recalls (Article 35(1) GPSR).
Can you not reach all affected consumers directly? Then you must publish a clear and visible recall notice through other appropriate channels with the widest possible reach, such as your website, social media, newsletters and retail outlets and, where appropriate, mass media (Article 35(4) GPSR).
Which Communication Channels Work Best Under Dutch Law?
Article 35(4) GPSR names the company’s website, social media channels, newsletters and retail outlets and, as appropriate, mass media. Choose the channels that reach the buyers of the product concerned.
What Are the Legal and Financial Consequences in Dutch Law?
A product recall involves costs for recall logistics, repair, replacement or refunds, communication and legal assistance; the remedy must be cost-free for the consumer (Article 37(1) GPSR). Further losses can follow from lost sales, reputational damage and contractual penalties from retailers and suppliers. How large these are depends on the number of products involved and the complexity of the recall.
Can I Recover Damages from My Supplier Under Dutch Law?
You can claim damages from your supplier if the defect results from a failure in its performance that can be attributed to it (Articles 6:74 and 6:75 Dutch Civil Code). Contractual indemnities and general terms and conditions often determine the precise recovery rights.
The party that claims damages generally has to prove the failure and the loss. Document all specifications, quality inspections and supplier guarantees, and keep batch and production tracing records, because they show which batch the defect comes from.
Watch the deadlines. If you bought the products and Dutch sales law applies, you must notify the seller of the defect within a reasonable time after you discovered it or should have discovered it, or you lose the right to rely on the non-conformity (Article 7:23(1) Dutch Civil Code). Claims based on the non-conformity then become time-barred two years after that notification (Article 7:23(2)). Other damages claims generally become time-barred five years after you became aware of both the damage and the liable person, and in any case twenty years after the event that caused the damage (Article 3:310(1) Dutch Civil Code).
Important: The notice of the defect to the seller and the limitation periods run separately from the recall itself, so they are easy to overlook while you handle the recall. A Dutch lawyer should check the dates and the contract terms (indemnities, general terms and conditions, choice of law) before you settle with the supplier or the insurer.
What Role Does Product Liability Insurance Play in the Netherlands?
Whether recall costs are covered depends on your policy. Some product liability policies may include recall costs, possibly up to a sublimit; others cover them only under a separate recall extension.
Policies may contain exclusions, for example for deliberately taken risks or non-compliance with safety standards, so discuss with your insurer beforehand which costs are covered.
Dutch insurance law requires you to report the insured event as soon as reasonably possible; late notification allows the insurer to reduce the payment by the damage it suffers as a result (Article 7:941(1) and (3) Dutch Civil Code).
How Do You Prevent a Product Recall According to Dutch Legislation?
Prevention starts with duties the GPSR already sets: an internal risk analysis and technical documentation before the product is placed on the market (Article 9(2)), procedures that keep series production in conformity (Article 9(4)), and the handling of complaints and accidents (Article 9(11) and (12)). Certification schemes such as ISO 9001 are voluntary and are not required by the GPSR.
What Documentation Is Essential Under Dutch Law?
Maintain complete product traceability through batch numbers, supplier information and distribution records. Manufacturers and importers must keep the technical documentation available to the market surveillance authorities for ten years after the product was placed on the market (Articles 9(3) and 11(6) GPSR).
Personal data also matter. Businesses that collect customer data must use it to contact consumers in a recall (Article 35(1) GPSR). If you run a product registration system or loyalty programme, you must offer customers the option to provide separate contact details used only for safety purposes (Article 35(2)). Protect these data with appropriate security measures (Article 32 GDPR).
What does a recall look like in practice (an illustrative example)?
In this illustrative example, a Dutch importer brings 25,000 folding stools from a manufacturer outside the EU onto the market. After six weeks, a consumer reports that a stool frame collapsed and caused injury. The importer starts an internal investigation and finds a welding defect in three specific production batches. Because the injury is a serious adverse effect on health, the importer, as the economic operator responsible for the product, ensures that the accident is notified through the Safety Business Gateway without undue delay (Article 20(3) and (4) GPSR), and informs the manufacturer (Article 11(8)(a)).
The importer drafts a recall notice with the elements of Article 36(2) GPSR, informs the authorities and notifies identifiable buyers directly, and retailers receive instructions to remove the affected stools from shelves. Consumers are offered at least two remedies unless Article 37(2) allows one, and do not bear the return costs.
Recovery from the manufacturer depends on the supply contract. Unclear quality specifications, a missing indemnity clause and a foreign jurisdiction clause all make recovery harder, and a foreign judgment must still be enforced where the manufacturer has its assets.
What Changes in European Regulation Affect Dutch Businesses?
The new Product Liability Directive (Directive (EU) 2024/2853) repeals the 1985 directive on which Articles 6:185 to 6:193 Dutch Civil Code are based. Software is expressly a product under the new directive (Article 4(1)), which matters for connected devices. Member States must transpose it by 9 December 2026, and it applies to products placed on the market or put into service after 9 December 2026 (Articles 2(1), 21 and 22(1)).
The GPSR has applied since 13 December 2024. Providers of online marketplaces must, among other things, designate single points of contact for authorities and consumers and have internal product safety processes (Article 22(1) to (3) GPSR). A product may only be placed on the market if there is an economic operator established in the EU that is responsible for it (Article 16(1)).
How Do You Prepare for New Legislation in the Netherlands?
Traceability and direct consumer notification are already required by Articles 9(5) and 35 GPSR, so check existing systems against those provisions before the new Product Liability Directive applies.
What should you consider in a cross-border recall?
Recalls often cross national borders when products circulate within the European internal market. Coordination between authorities takes place through the Safety Gate Rapid Alert System (Article 25 GPSR).
Some requirements depend on the Member State where the product is sold, such as the language of the instructions and safety information (Article 9(7) GPSR).
What Role Does Applicable Law Play in the Netherlands?
In cross-border product liability, the Rome II Regulation (Article 5) is the starting point in the courts of most Member States, but Article 28(1) leaves international conventions in place. The Netherlands is party to the 1973 Hague Convention on the Law Applicable to Products Liability, which a Dutch court applies within its scope. Which rules decide therefore depends on the forum, so have a Dutch lawyer check this before you assume that Dutch or foreign law governs.
Under Article 5(1) Rome II, and without prejudice to Article 4(2), the applicable law is the law of the injured person’s habitual residence, then the law of the country where the product was acquired, then the law of the country where the damage occurred, each time provided that the product was marketed in that country. The law of the defendant’s habitual residence applies if it could not reasonably foresee the marketing of the product, or a product of the same type, in that country, and a manifestly closer connection with another country can lead to the law of that country (Article 5(2) Rome II).
Where you can be sued depends on the basis of the claim. A consumer who bought from you under a consumer contract covered by Article 17 may sue in the courts of his own domicile (Article 18(1) Brussels Ia Regulation). For a tort claim, such as a product liability claim, the claimant may sue in the courts for the place where the harmful event occurred (Article 7(2)). This can mean defending proceedings abroad.
A contractual choice of law in B2B relationships offers some certainty, within the limits of the Rome I Regulation. An arbitration clause with its seat in the Netherlands can keep disputes between businesses out of foreign courts. Towards consumers, an arbitration clause in general terms and conditions is deemed unreasonably onerous unless it gives the consumer at least one month, after the trader invokes the clause in writing, to choose the competent court (Article 6:236(n) Dutch Civil Code).
When should you involve a Dutch lawyer?
Ideally before you notify the authorities or inform consumers, because the choice between withdrawal and recall, the regime that applies to the product and the content of the notification all follow from the facts of the case. A Dutch lawyer should also look at the matter when an authority issues an order under Article 32h or Article 21 Warenwet, when a supplier or insurer disputes liability, or when a claim from an injured person arrives.
Facing a possible product recall? Contact Martin Krüger for a first assessment, or our contract attorneys if the main question is recovery from a supplier.
Frequently asked questions about product recalls in the Netherlands
Do I always have to organise a public recall?
No. If the product has not yet reached consumers, a withdrawal from the supply chain may be enough (Article 3(26) GPSR). Once a dangerous product has been made available to consumers, the corrective measures may include a recall, and identifiable consumers must be notified directly (Articles 9(8) and 35(1) GPSR).
Who pays for a recall caused by a supplier’s defect?
The economic operator responsible for the recall must offer consumers a cost-free remedy (Article 37(1) GPSR) and therefore bears the costs first. You can then claim damages from your supplier for an attributable failure in performance (Article 6:74 Dutch Civil Code), provided you notified the defect in time (Article 7:23 Dutch Civil Code).
How quickly must I notify the authorities?
Immediately. Manufacturers, importers and distributors of products outside Union harmonisation legislation that have reason to believe a product is dangerous must inform the authorities through the Safety Business Gateway (Articles 9(8), 11(8) and 12(4) GPSR). For products under that legislation, Article 4(3) of Regulation (EU) 2019/1020 applies instead. Serious accidents must be notified without undue delay (Article 20 GPSR).
What happens if I do not take action?
The Minister can order you to withdraw or recall a dangerous product (Article 32h(1) Warenwet). The producer is also liable without proof of fault for damage from a defective product, within the limits of Articles 6:185 and 6:190 Dutch Civil Code.
How long can an injured person claim under Dutch product liability law?
The claim becomes time-barred three years after the injured person became aware, or should have become aware, of the damage, the defect and the identity of the producer. In any event, the right lapses ten years after the producer put the product into circulation (Article 6:191 Dutch Civil Code).
Primary sources
- Regulation (EU) 2023/988 (General Product Safety Regulation), Articles 2, 3, 5, 9, 11, 12, 16, 20, 22, 25, 26, 35, 36, 37, 44, 50 and 52
- Regulation (EC) No 178/2002 (General Food Law), Article 19
- Regulation (EU) 2019/1020 (market surveillance), Article 4
- Dutch Civil Code: Articles 3:310, 6:74, 6:75, 6:185, 6:187, 6:190, 6:191, 6:192, 6:236, 7:23 and 7:941
- Commodities Act (Warenwet): Article 21 and Article 32h
- Directive (EU) 2024/2853 (Product Liability Directive), Articles 2, 4, 21 and 22
- Regulation (EC) No 864/2007 (Rome II), Article 5
- Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012 (Brussels Ia), Articles 7, 17 and 18
- Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (GDPR), Article 32
Dealing with a recall or a recovery claim? Our litigation lawyers can assess the next steps with you.