Published on
EU food labelling rests on Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011 on food information to consumers. Under Article 8, the operator under whose name the food is marketed answers for the label or, if that operator is outside the EU, the importer. Exporting to the EU? Settle who that is before the first order. MAAK Advocaten N.V., a law firm in Amsterdam, explains the roles for exporters and EU customers.
In short
- Responsibility follows whose name the food is marketed under and where that operator is established; the importer answers only if that operator is outside the EU (Article 8(1)).
- A label is more than the pack: accompanying material counts as food information (Article 2(2)(a)), and the misleading-information rules cover advertising (Article 7(4)).
- In prepacked food, allergens are emphasised in the ingredients list (Article 21(1)); check a home-country label against Article 9(1).
- Have a Dutch product law lawyer review the roles and contract before you agree to be named, sign an indemnity or answer the NVWA.
Part of our overview of sector-specific product rules in the EU and of product compliance in the Netherlands. The focus is EU law: the Dutch rules are in Dutch food labelling, withdrawals in food traceability and recall.
Who is responsible for a food label under EU law?
The food business operator under whose name or business name the food is marketed or, if that operator is not established in the Union, the importer into the Union market (Article 8(1) of Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011).
That operator ensures the presence and accuracy of the food information under food information law and the relevant national provisions (Article 8(2)). Its name or business name and address are themselves a mandatory particular on the label (Article 9(1)(h)).
The regulation has no separate importer regime; the importer is responsible for the food information only through Article 8(1). Who that is in your chain depends on whose name is on the pack and where that business is established; your contract only decides how cost and recourse are shared.
This is the moment many businesses do not realise that they carry the label themselves. If your name or business name is on the product and you are established in the Union, you are responsible for the information on the label, even when someone else makes the product; if you are outside the Union, your importer is. Either way, before the first order make sure that whoever is responsible can check your producer’s composition and the label, and that the contract makes the producer tell you at once when something changes.
Is your home-country label enough for the EU?
No, not automatically: check it against the EU list. Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011 is directly applicable in all Member States (Article 55).
Article 9(1) lists 12 mandatory particulars, among them allergens and the name and address of the operator of Article 8(1). “Label” is wider than the sticker: food information is information concerning a food that is made available to the final consumer by label, other accompanying material or any other means (Article 2(2)(a)), and the rules against misleading information also cover advertising and presentation (Article 7(4)).
What businesses outside the EU often get wrong is the assumption that a label that works in their own country also works in the EU. The European system has its own list of 14 allergen groups and a mandatory statement of the responsible operator with name and address. If the operator under whose name the product is sold is not established in the Union, the responsibility for the information lies with the importer. My advice: decide before the first shipment who that is, record in the contract with that importer who drafts the label and who supplies the data, and agree the label in advance.
How must allergens be shown on an EU food label?
An ingredient or processing aid listed in Annex II, or derived from a substance listed there, that was used in manufacture and is still present in the finished product, even in altered form, must be declared (Article 9(1)(c)). In prepacked food it appears in the ingredients list, emphasised through a typeset that clearly distinguishes it from the rest of the list, for example by font, style or background colour (Article 21(1)).
Without an ingredients list, the word “contains” precedes the name; the declaration is not required where the name of the food clearly refers to the substance (Article 21(1)). For food offered without prepackaging, and for food packed at the consumer’s request or prepacked for direct sale, allergen information is mandatory (Article 44(1)).
Information on the possible and unintentional presence of allergens (“may contain”) is voluntary; Article 36(3)(a) names it as a subject for implementing acts. It must not be misleading, ambiguous or confusing (Article 36(2)).
One 2023 ruling of the Rotterdam District Court (first instance) shows how this can go wrong: part of a producer’s packs carried another product’s label, so wheat was not declared. The fine rested on the duty of an operator who has reason to believe that a food does not meet the food safety requirements to start withdrawal procedures at once and inform the competent authority (Article 19(1) of Regulation (EC) No 178/2002; ECLI:NL:RBROT:2023:5025, 19 June 2023), covered in food traceability and recall.
When something is wrong with a label, the message usually comes from a customer or a supermarket: “this batch has the wrong label” or “an allergen is missing”. Then it matters that you act calmly and quickly. My first step is practical: establish which batches are concerned, to whom they were delivered and what exactly is on the label next to the recipe. Then I look at who is named on the label and so who is responsible.
What does your EU customer need from you in the chain?
Enough information to meet its own duties. If you supply food that is not intended for the final consumer or for mass caterers, you must ensure that the receiving operator is provided with sufficient information to enable it, where appropriate, to meet its obligations under Article 8(2) (Article 8(8)).
For prepacked food intended for the final consumer but traded at an earlier stage, the mandatory particulars appear on the prepackaging or the label attached to it or, where it can be guaranteed that they accompany the food or are sent before or at the same time as delivery, on commercial documents; those of Article 9(1)(a), (f), (g) and (h) also appear on the external packaging (Article 8(7)). A retailer or importer will ask for the product specification and a label check, which raises three questions: whose name is on the label (Article 8(1)), who supplies the data and who bears the cost of a mistake. Responsibility for the food information stays with the responsible operator under Article 8(1) and (2); the cost split between you and your partner is contract law, and the wording of an indemnity decides what you can recover from your producer.
In your contract with supplier and customer, record who supplies the composition, who lays out and checks the label, how fast you inform each other of a change in the composition and who bears the cost of a rejected batch. My advice: align the split with who determines or changes the information; a full transfer to the supplier rarely works and costs you a relationship you need.
Put your chain to our product law partner in the Netherlands, with your customer’s request and the label.
What happens in the Netherlands if the label is wrong?
The regulation contains no sanctions and names no supervisor; Member States enforce it and may impose administrative sanctions (Court of Justice, C-438/23, operative part, point 2). In the Netherlands the NVWA (Nederlandse Voedsel- en Warenautoriteit) supervises and can use the Warenwet: an order subject to administrative coercion (Article 32) or an administrative fine (Article 32a). For the Dutch rules, see Dutch food labelling; see also NVWA enforcement and fines and disputes with the NVWA.
Acceptance elsewhere in Europe does not protect you here. A Dutch distributor sold a dairy product also sold in several European countries and was fined for misleading food information (Article 7(1)(a)). The College van Beroep voor het bedrijfsleven (CBb) held that the same labelling causing no problem elsewhere did not help: the Netherlands has its own enforcement power, and the cost of changing the labelling is for the operator (ECLI:NL:CBB:2023:629, 14 November 2023, grounds 6 and 7).
When the NVWA asks questions, I first read calmly what exactly is asked, which batch and product it concerns and within what period. Then you put the documents together: the label, your supplier’s specification, the delivery dates and your agreements with your customer. I respond for the company with the documents that exist and say what we are still investigating; a late or incomplete response often costs more than an honest one with a clear plan. If a fine or an order follows, we prepare the written view (zienswijze) together.
Example: a US sauce maker and a Dutch importer
A US sauce maker ships pallets to a Rotterdam importer with labels showing only its US address. The importer’s customer asks who the responsible operator is.
If the sauce is sold under the maker’s own name, that operator is not established in the Union, so the importer is responsible (Article 8(1)). If the importer sells it under its own name, it is responsible as that operator. Either way the label must carry that operator’s name and address (Article 9(1)(h)); in the first case the importer’s, so a label with only the US address does not fit.
This is a hypothetical example for illustration, not a description of an actual case.
When do you need a Dutch lawyer for EU food labelling?
When the question is who is named on the label, what you warrant to your customer or what you show an authority (Article 8(1)).
| Your situation | What is at stake | Why a lawyer, not only a consultant or label agency | What MAAK does in the first days |
|---|---|---|---|
| Your EU importer queries the label or asks who bears the risk | The responsible operator is the one whose name is on the food or, if that operator is not established in the Union, the importer (Art. 8(1)-(2)) | The label agency fixes layout; who is named on the label follows from Art. 8(1), and recourse between you and your partner is a matter of contract law | Establish who is named on the label; review the supply contract |
| Your customer asks for a warranty or indemnity on the label | Contractual liability for the accuracy of the label; responsibility for the food information stays with the operator under Art. 8(1)-(2) | The wording decides what you can recover from your producer | Review and align indemnity and supply terms |
| The NVWA or your customer asks for evidence | A possible later order or fine under the Warenwet (Arts. 32, 32a) | What you provide may later be considered in a measure; objection and appeal have deadlines | Assess the request, organise the documents, contact the authority |
| An allergen error on a delivered batch | Arts. 9(1)(c) and 21(1); withdrawal duties are covered in our recall article | Statements to the importer and authority carry consequences | Order the facts, contact importer and authority, decide on stock |
Drawing up labels and checking recipe and allergens is work for your quality department or a food adviser. You need a lawyer the moment it is about risk, contract or the authority: when your customer asks for a warranty or indemnity, when the NVWA asks questions or announces a measure, or when a label error lies between you and your supplier and you do not know who bears the loss. Do not wait until there is a letter.
How does MAAK Advocaten work on EU food labelling?
We act for food producers outside the EU and their Dutch and EU customers: role analysis, supply and indemnity terms under Dutch law, contact with the NVWA and, if a measure follows, objection and appeal.
Frequently asked questions about EU food labelling
Who is responsible for a food label in the EU?
The operator under whose name or business name the food is marketed or, if that operator is not established in the Union, the importer into the Union market (Article 8(1) of Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011). That operator ensures the presence and accuracy of the food information (Article 8(2)).
Is the exporter or the importer responsible for the label?
It depends on whose name the food is marketed under and where that business is established. Under Article 8(1), if the operator under whose name the food is marketed is not established in the Union, the importer into the Union is responsible. Who that is in your chain, we assess per case.
How must allergens be shown on an EU food label?
In prepacked food, an Annex II substance used in manufacture and still present appears in the ingredients list, clearly emphasised, for example by font, style or background colour (Article 21(1)). Without a list the word “contains” precedes the name; it is not required where the food’s name clearly refers to the substance. For food offered without prepackaging, and for food packed at the consumer’s request or prepacked for direct sale, allergen information is mandatory (Article 44(1)).
Must I state “may contain traces” on the label?
Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011 treats information on the possible and unintentional presence of allergens as voluntary. Article 36(3)(a) lists it as a subject for implementing acts. Voluntary information must not be misleading, ambiguous or confusing (Article 36(2)).
When should an exporter call a Dutch lawyer about EU food labelling?
When your importer asks who is named on the label, when a customer wants a warranty or indemnity, when the NVWA asks for the label or when an allergen error is reported. MAAK Advocaten reviews the roles and the contract before the next shipment.
Primary sources
- Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011 (food information to consumers), consolidated version of 1 April 2025 (non-binding consolidation): Articles 2, 7, 8, 9, 21, 36, 44 and 55
- Regulation (EU) No 1169/2011, text as adopted
- Court of Justice, C-438/23 (Protéines France, 4 October 2024)
- Rotterdam District Court (first instance), 19 June 2023, ECLI:NL:RBROT:2023:5025
- CBb, 14 November 2023, ECLI:NL:CBB:2023:629
- Warenwet, Articles 32 and 32a
Does your EU importer ask who answers for the label of your food product? Put your situation to me through my profile page, ideally with the label and your customer’s request. — Martin Krüger