Published on · Last updated
A cargo damage lawyer advises on claims against a carrier. Under the CMR, the carrier is liable for loss, damage and delay (Article 17(1) CMR). Compensation for loss is capped at 8.33 SDR per kilogram of gross weight short (Article 23(3)), and claims are in principle time-barred after one year, or three years for wilful misconduct (Article 32(1)).
This page is for shippers, consignees, traders and their insurers with a cargo damage claim against a carrier in or through the Netherlands. It explains which rules apply (the CMR Convention for international road transport, Book 8 of the Dutch Civil Code (DCC) for road transport under Dutch law), when the carrier is liable, how much you can claim, what to do on delivery and which deadlines apply. For the wider picture, see our pages on Dutch transportation and freight law and transportation lawyers in the Netherlands.
Which rules apply to a cargo damage claim in the Netherlands?
The CMR applies to contracts for the carriage of goods by road for reward in vehicles when the place of taking over the goods and the place designated for delivery are situated in two different countries, of which at least one is a contracting country, irrespective of the place of residence and the nationality of the parties (Article 1(1) CMR). Book 8 DCC contains the rules on the contract for the carriage of goods by road (Article 8:1090 DCC). Sea, inland waterway and air carriage have their own rules.
Both regimes have the same basic structure: the carrier is liable, but it has defences and its liability is limited. The outcome depends on evidence of the condition of the goods on taking over and on delivery.
When is the carrier liable for cargo damage?
Under the CMR, the carrier is liable for loss, damage and delay, but it is relieved of liability if the loss, damage or delay was caused by the wrongful act or neglect of the claimant, by the claimant’s instructions not resulting from the carrier’s own wrongful act or neglect, by an inherent vice of the goods, or by circumstances which the carrier could not avoid and the consequences of which it could not prevent (Article 17(1)-(2) and Article 18(1) CMR). A defect in the vehicle is no defence (Article 17(3)).
The carrier is also relieved of liability for loss or damage arising from the special risks listed in Article 17(4) CMR, such as the agreed use of open vehicles, defective packing, handling, loading or unloading by the sender or consignee, and the nature of certain goods. If the carrier establishes that the loss or damage could be attributed to such a risk, it is presumed that it was so caused, but the claimant may prove otherwise (Article 18(2) CMR). Under Book 8 DCC, the carrier must deliver the goods in the condition in which it received them (Article 8:1095) and is not liable for damage insofar as it was caused by a circumstance that a careful carrier could not have avoided and whose consequences such a carrier could not have prevented (Article 8:1098(1)); special risks similar to those of the CMR are listed in Article 8:1099.
The consignment note is prima facie evidence of the making of the contract of carriage, its conditions and the receipt of the goods by the carrier (Article 9(1) CMR). Without specific reservations of the carrier on the consignment note, it is presumed that the goods and their packaging were in apparently good condition when the carrier took them over (Article 9(2)). The absence of a consignment note does not affect the existence or validity of the contract (Article 4). Collect the consignment note, photos of the damage on delivery, a surveyor’s report, invoices showing the value of the goods and the correspondence with the carrier.
How much compensation can you claim for cargo damage?
- CMR, loss: compensation is calculated by reference to the value of the goods at the place and time at which they were accepted for carriage, but may not exceed 8.33 units of account (Special Drawing Rights, SDR) per kilogram of gross weight short (Article 23(1) and (3) CMR). The carriage charges, customs duties and other charges incurred in respect of the carriage are refunded, in full in case of complete loss and in proportion in case of partial loss, but no further damages are payable (Article 23(4)).
- CMR, higher compensation: only if a value of the goods (Article 24) or a special interest in delivery (Article 26) was declared in the consignment note against an agreed surcharge (Article 23(6)).
- CMR, wilful misconduct: the carrier cannot rely on the provisions of this chapter that exclude or limit its liability or shift the burden of proof if the damage was caused by its wilful misconduct, or by default which, under the law of the court seised, is considered equivalent to wilful misconduct; the same applies to its servants and the persons it uses (Article 29 CMR).
- Book 8 DCC: compensation is based on the value the goods would have had at the time and place of delivery, or at which they should have been delivered (Article 8:1103). The carrier’s liability is limited to amounts set by order in council (Article 8:1105), unless a higher value (Article 8:1106) or a special interest (Article 8:1107) was declared with its consent and against payment.
- Book 8 DCC, intent or recklessness: the carrier cannot rely on a limitation of liability insofar as the damage results from its own act or omission, done with the intent to cause that damage or recklessly and with the knowledge that such damage would probably result (Article 8:1108(1)).
What must you do when the goods are delivered damaged?
To avoid the presumption of Article 30(1) CMR, check the condition of the goods with the carrier on delivery, or send the carrier reservations giving a general indication of the loss or damage: for apparent loss or damage not later than the time of delivery, and for loss or damage that is not apparent in writing within seven days of delivery, Sundays and public holidays excepted (Article 30(1) CMR). Without reservations, the consignee is deemed, unless it proves otherwise, to have received the goods in the condition described in the consignment note.
If the condition of the goods was checked jointly with the carrier, evidence contradicting the result is not admitted, unless the loss or damage is not apparent and written reservations were sent within seven days of the check (Article 30(2)). The day of delivery or of the check is not counted (Article 30(4)). Carrier and consignee must give each other all reasonable facilities for the necessary investigations (Article 30(5)), so invite the carrier to a joint survey.
Can you claim damages for late delivery?
Yes, if you prove that the delay caused damage. Compensation for delay under the CMR may not exceed the carriage charges (Article 23(5) CMR), and compensation is payable only if a written reservation has been sent to the carrier within 21 days from the time the goods were placed at the consignee’s disposal (Article 30(3)). There is delay when the goods are not delivered within the agreed time-limit or, without an agreed time-limit, when the actual duration of the carriage exceeds what a diligent carrier can reasonably be allowed (Article 19 CMR). A special interest in delivery can be declared in the consignment note against a surcharge (Article 26).
Who is liable: the carrier, the freight forwarder or a subcontractor?
The carrier is liable for the acts and omissions of its servants and of all other persons it uses for the carriage, when they act in the exercise of their functions, as if they were its own (Article 3 CMR). A freight forwarder, who undertakes to conclude contracts of carriage for its principal (Article 8:60 DCC), is treated as the carrier insofar as it performs the carriage itself (Article 8:61(1)).
If the goods are not delivered without delay in the condition in which they were made available, and the forwarder did not perform the carriage itself, it must immediately tell its principal which contracts of carriage it concluded and provide the documents and data that can serve to recover the damage (Article 8:63(1)). The principal can then exercise the rights against the carrier (Article 8:63(2)). If the forwarder fails to do so, it must compensate the resulting damage and pay a compensation equal to what the principal could have obtained from it had it performed the carriage itself, reduced by what the principal may have obtained from the carrier (Article 8:63(3)). A forwarder that performed the carriage itself must tell its principal so immediately, on pain of the consequences of Article 8:62.
If one contract of carriage is performed by successive road carriers, each of them becomes responsible for the whole operation (Article 34 CMR). A carrier that has paid compensation has a right of recourse against the carriers that took part in the performance, as provided in Article 37; the one-year period of Article 32 also applies to that recourse claim, but it starts on the date of the final judicial decision fixing the compensation or, without such a decision, on the date of payment (Article 39(4)).
Which deadlines apply to a cargo damage claim?
A claim under the CMR is time-barred after one year, or three years in case of wilful misconduct or equivalent default (Article 32(1) CMR). The period runs from the date of delivery in case of partial loss, damage or delay; in case of complete loss from the thirtieth day after the agreed time-limit or, without one, from the sixtieth day after the carrier took over the goods; and in all other cases from three months after the contract was made. A written claim suspends the period until the carrier rejects the claim in writing and returns the documents; further claims with the same object do not suspend it (Article 32(2)). A time-barred claim cannot be invoked by way of counterclaim or set-off (Article 32(4)). For road transport under Book 8 DCC, a claim based on a contract of carriage is time-barred after one year, subject to Articles 8:1712 and 8:1720 (Article 8:1711). Send a written claim to the carrier as soon as possible, keep proof that it was received, and start proceedings before the period runs out.
To discuss a cargo claim, contact Remko Roosjen.
Where can you bring a CMR cargo claim?
Besides the courts of a contracting country designated by the parties, you can sue in the courts of the country where the defendant is ordinarily resident, has its principal place of business or the branch or agency through which the contract was made, or where the goods were taken over or the place designated for delivery is situated, and not in other courts (Article 31(1) CMR). A judgment that has become enforceable in one contracting country becomes enforceable in the others once the local formalities are complied with, without re-examination of the merits (Article 31(3)). Security for costs cannot be required from nationals of contracting countries who are resident or have their place of business in one of those countries (Article 31(5)). The contract may contain an arbitration clause, provided that the tribunal applies the CMR (Article 33); see arbitration in the Netherlands. How Dutch proceedings against a foreign party work is explained on our page on Dutch proceedings in international disputes.
How can shippers limit the risk of uncompensated cargo damage?
The CMR limit can be lower than the value of the goods. If that matters, declare the value of the goods or a special interest in delivery in the consignment note against a surcharge (Articles 24 and 26 CMR), or insure the cargo. Further points:
- Pack the goods properly: the carrier is relieved of liability for loss or damage arising from defective packing of goods that need packing (Article 17(4)(b) CMR).
- Check the consignment note on loading: without specific reservations of the carrier, the goods and their packaging are presumed to have been in apparently good condition (Article 9(2) CMR).
- Agree delivery times in writing, and give special instructions, for example for temperature-controlled transport, before the carriage starts.
- Under Book 8 DCC, a higher value or a special interest can also be declared in the consignment note, with the carrier’s consent and against payment (Articles 8:1106 and 8:1107).
Frequently asked questions about cargo damage claims
What does a cargo damage lawyer do?
A cargo damage lawyer determines which regime applies (CMR or Book 8 DCC), secures the evidence, sends the reservations and the written claim to the carrier, protects the limitation period and, if needed, brings proceedings against the carrier, the freight forwarder or a subcarrier before the competent court (Articles 30 to 32 CMR).
How much is a carrier liable for under the CMR?
For loss, compensation is calculated on the value of the goods at the place and time of taking over, and may not exceed 8.33 SDR per kilogram of gross weight short (Article 23(1) and (3) CMR). For damage, it is the reduction in that value (Article 25(1)). For delay, it may not exceed the carriage charges (Article 23(5)).
How long do you have to file a cargo claim?
To avoid the presumption in Article 30(1) CMR, reservations are made at delivery for apparent damage and in writing within seven days of delivery (Sundays and public holidays excepted) for damage that is not apparent. The claim itself is time-barred after one year, or three years for wilful misconduct or equivalent default (Article 32(1)).
Can the CMR limit be broken?
The carrier cannot rely on the provisions that exclude or limit its liability or shift the burden of proof if the damage was caused by its wilful misconduct, or by default which the law of the court seised considers equivalent to it; the same applies to its servants and the persons it uses (Article 29 CMR).
Is a freight forwarder liable for cargo damage in the Netherlands?
It depends on the role. A forwarder that performs the carriage itself is treated as the carrier (Article 8:61(1) DCC). Otherwise, if the goods are not delivered without delay in the condition made available, it has to tell its principal immediately which contracts of carriage it concluded, failing which it owes compensation (Article 8:63(1) and (3) DCC).
Cargo claim topics
Legal framework and sources
- Convention on the Contract for the International Carriage of Goods by Road (CMR), Geneva, 19 May 1956: Articles 1, 3, 4, 9, 17, 18, 19, 23, 24, 25, 26, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 37, 39
- Dutch Civil Code, Book 8 (Burgerlijk Wetboek Boek 8): Articles 8:60, 8:61, 8:62, 8:63, 8:1090, 8:1095, 8:1098, 8:1099, 8:1103, 8:1105, 8:1106, 8:1107, 8:1108, 8:1711
Speak to a cargo damage lawyer
To discuss a cargo claim or your transport terms, contact Remko Roosjen.