Written Warning from a Dutch Regulator: What to Do

Share this article

WhatsAppLinkedIn

Published on

A written warning from a Dutch regulator states that you have broken a rule. Whether you can object to it depends on whether it is a decision under Article 1:3 of the General Administrative Law Act (Awb), and in a 2019 case about the NVWA it was not. MAAK Advocaten N.V. in Amsterdam helps foreign businesses respond to Dutch regulators, before and after a warning.

In short

  • A warning from a Dutch regulator is open to objection only if it is a decision, meaning it is aimed at a legal effect (Article 1:3 Awb).
  • In 2019 the Trade and Industry Appeals Tribunal held that an NVWA warning based on enforcement policy was not a decision, so the objection was inadmissible.
  • A warning can be raised against a later enforcement decision, and the regulator may act even without a prior warning, the tribunal noted.
  • Have a Dutch regulatory lawyer review the warning before you reply, particularly if a notice of intent, penalty order or fine may follow.

This page is part of our work on regulatory litigation in the Netherlands.

What is a written warning from a Dutch regulator?

A written warning is a letter in which a regulator says you have breached a rule. It is not an order or a fine. In the NVWA case below it rested on enforcement policy, so it was no decision (Article 1:3 Awb).

That case (CBb 22 January 2019, ECLI:NL:CBB:2019:30) concerned injuries to chickens during catching and loading, found at a slaughterhouse. The Trade and Industry Appeals Tribunal (College van Beroep voor het bedrijfsleven, CBb) described the warning as no more than the finding that a rule had been breached, with the announcement that further steps may follow if it happens again (paras 5.3 and 5.4).

Do not confuse the warning with the sanctions that can follow. A penalty order (last onder dwangsom) is a remedial sanction: an order to remedy a violation, combined with a sum payable if you do not comply (Article 5:31d Awb). Our page on administrative penalty orders under Dutch law explains it. An administrative fine is a punitive sanction (Article 5:2 Awb); see our page on the procedure for a penalty from a Dutch regulator.

Neither is a civil penalty payment, which a court imposes in a dispute between businesses. For those, see civil penalty payments under Dutch law, the legal basis for civil penalty payments and penalty payments imposed by a court.

Whether a warning is just a letter or carries legal weight depends on its basis, its wording and what the regulator links to it.

Can you object to a warning from a Dutch regulator?

In general only if it is a decision, a written ruling of an administrative body with a legal effect (Articles 1:3, 7:1 and 8:1 Awb). The tribunal held in 2019 that the NVWA warning was not one.

The tribunal relied on three features. The warning had no statutory basis and followed from policy rules. It was not a condition for imposing other sanctions. And it was no more than a finding that a rule had been breached. It imposed no binding obligation, took away no right and did not otherwise affect the legal position of the business (para. 5.3). The objection was therefore inadmissible.

The tribunal added that this does not leave you without legal protection. If the regulator later takes an enforcement decision that relies on the warning, you can still argue in that procedure that the warning was not justified. If you already suffer harm from the warning, the civil court remains open (para. 5.4).

Other warnings can look different. A warning with a statutory basis, or one to which the law or the regulator attaches consequences, was not before the tribunal. Whether yours is a decision depends on those features, which we assess from the document itself. If it is a decision, the objection period is six weeks from the day after it was notified (Articles 6:7 and 6:8 Awb).

Important: Suppose a regulator’s letter calls itself a warning but sets a deadline to remedy and announces a follow-up inspection. Whether it is a mere letter or a decision under Article 1:3 Awb decides if the six-week objection period of Articles 6:7 and 6:8 runs. Have a Dutch regulatory lawyer review the letter in the first days, before that period could expire.

What should you do when a regulator warns you?

Take it seriously even if you cannot object. Read the findings line by line, check which facts are correct and record what you remedy. Answer what is wrong briefly, with documents, and keep cooperating with inspectors (Article 5:20 Awb).

  • Check the findings against your own records, test reports and correspondence.
  • Remedy what is correct without delay, and record what you did and when.
  • Reply in writing to what is incorrect: short, factual, with evidence.
  • Keep cooperating with the inspectors: Article 5:20(1) Awb requires everyone to give a supervisor the cooperation that can reasonably be demanded, but not statements about the violation if you are questioned with a view to a fine (Article 5:10a Awb).
  • Note every deadline in the letter and who in your organisation owns it.

For conduct during the inspection itself, see what to do during an NVWA inspection.

A common gap is a remedy that is carried out but not documented. Your reply and your records are what the regulator, and later a court, will read if enforcement follows. Which facts to concede and which to contest depends on your role in the supply chain and on your contract with your supplier or buyer. We assess that per file.

Has a Dutch regulator sent you a warning, a notice of intent or an order? Put your situation to our litigation team through the page of our litigation attorney in the Netherlands, before you reply.

What can follow a warning from a Dutch regulator?

That depends on the breach and your response. If it continues, a notice of intent for a penalty order or a fine can follow. Before a decision you did not ask for, you may be entitled to submit your views first (Article 4:8).

Article 4:8(1) Awb applies where the regulator would rely on facts and interests concerning you that you did not supply yourself, and you are expected to object. The Dutch term for your input is zienswijze (your views). It does not apply if you failed to meet a statutory duty to provide information (Article 4:8(2) Awb).

A warning does not have to come first. The tribunal noted that the NVWA was empowered to take further steps even without an earlier warning (para. 5.4). Each route has its own deadlines and remedies, described on the pages linked above. For the NVWA specifically, see enforcement and administrative fines by the NVWA.

Important: Suppose a few weeks after the warning you receive a notice of intent for a penalty order, with a deadline to submit your views. Your views under Article 4:8 Awb are your chance to influence the decision before it is taken, and what you write there stays in the file for any objection or appeal. Have a Dutch regulatory lawyer review the notice before you submit your views.

Do EU product rules give you extra rights before a regulator acts?

Sometimes. If a Dutch market surveillance authority acts under EU harmonisation legislation, Article 18 of Regulation (EU) 2019/1020 requires reasons, information on remedies and, in principle, a hearing of at least 10 working days beforehand.

Article 18 applies to a “measure, decision or order”. Whether a plain warning is one is a question we assess on the document itself. A requirement to take corrective action within a set period (Article 16(2)) is a measure within the scope of Article 18. A hearing may follow afterwards only where urgency based on health, safety or another public interest makes a prior hearing impossible, and the measure must then be reviewed promptly (Article 18(3)).

Practical example: a foreign importer receives a warning

Suppose a German importer of electric kitchen appliances receives a letter from a Dutch market surveillance authority. It records that the technical documentation was incomplete and calls the letter a warning. The importer checks the findings against its files, supplies the missing document, records the date it did so, and corrects one finding that is wrong, with evidence.

Months later an inspection finds the same gap on another model, and the regulator sends a notice of intent. The importer’s documented reply and remedy are already in the file when it submits its views. The example is illustrative and not based on a specific case.

When do you need a Dutch lawyer after a warning?

Involve a Dutch lawyer when the legal effect of the letter is unclear, when a notice of intent, penalty order or fine follows, or when a product or contract is at stake. The objection period for a decision is six weeks (Article 6:7).

SituationWhat is at stakeWhy a lawyerWhat we do first
A letter calls itself a warning but sets deadlines or announces consequencesWhether it is a decision (Article 1:3 Awb) decides if a six-week objection period runs (Articles 6:7 and 6:8)Qualifying the letter is a legal assessment of its basis and effect, not a compliance questionWe read the letter and the file, set the deadlines and advise whether to reply, object or wait
A notice of intent follows the warningA chance to submit your views before the decision (Article 4:8 Awb)What you write frames any later objection or appealWe review the notice, secure the deadline and prepare your views, and ask for a meeting with the regulator where that helps
The regulator acts under EU product rulesReasons, information on remedies and a hearing of at least 10 working days (Article 18 of Regulation (EU) 2019/1020)Whether the hearing right was respected is assessed against the decision and the Dutch procedureWe check the grounds and the hearing, and advise on objection and interim relief
The warning touches your product or contract positionLiability and recourse in the supply chain depend on your contract and the applicable lawA dispute with a supplier or buyer may followContract review, recourse and, if needed, civil proceedings in first instance and on appeal

How does MAAK Advocaten act in warning cases?

We act for foreign and Dutch businesses in disputes with Dutch regulators, from the reply to a warning to objection, interim relief (voorlopige voorziening) and appeals before the administrative courts. We also act in the related civil disputes with suppliers and buyers.

In the first days we read the letter and the file, set out all deadlines, agree who carries out the remedy and how it is documented, and advise on the reply.

We do not promise outcomes. What a case costs depends on the number of steps, the urgency and whether a hearing is needed.

Related: sales bans, seizure and other regulator measures · ILT enforcement and supervision

Frequently asked questions about warnings from Dutch regulators

Is a warning from a Dutch regulator a fine?

No. A fine is a punitive sanction (Article 5:2 Awb). In the 2019 NVWA case the tribunal found that the warning imposed no binding obligation and was not a punitive sanction, because no consequences were attached to it (ECLI:NL:CBB:2019:30, paras 5.3 and 5.4).

Can I object to a warning from a Dutch regulator?

Only if it is a decision, a written ruling aimed at a legal effect (Article 1:3 Awb). An NVWA warning based on enforcement policy was not (CBb 22 January 2019, ECLI:NL:CBB:2019:30). If it is a decision, the objection period is six weeks (Articles 6:7 and 6:8 Awb).

Does a warning have to come before a penalty order or a fine?

Not on the strength of this ruling: the tribunal noted that the NVWA was empowered to take further steps without an earlier warning (para. 5.4). Whether another statute requires a warning first depends on that statute, which we check per case.

Do I have to cooperate with a Dutch inspector after a warning?

Yes, as a rule. Article 5:20 Awb requires everyone to give a supervisor the cooperation that can reasonably be demanded, within the reasonable period set. People bound by professional secrecy may refuse in so far as their duty of secrecy requires (Article 5:20(2) Awb).

Which rights apply if the regulator relies on EU product rules?

Under Article 18 of Regulation (EU) 2019/1020, a measure, decision or order must state its exact grounds, inform you of the remedies and time limits, and in principle follow a hearing of at least 10 working days. Whether a warning counts as such a measure depends on the document.

When should I contact a Dutch lawyer about a warning?

As soon as the letter arrives if its legal effect is unclear, and in any event when a notice of intent, penalty order or fine follows. At MAAK Advocaten in Amsterdam we review the letter, set the deadlines and prepare your reply or views. The objection period for a decision is six weeks (Article 6:7 Awb).

Primary sources

Dutch statutes are only officially available in Dutch, on wetten.overheid.nl. Judgments can be found on rechtspraak.nl by their ECLI number.

Has a Dutch regulator warned you, or sent a notice of intent or an order? Put your situation to Remko Roosjen through his page as litigation attorney in the Netherlands.

News & Insights
Which topics would you like to receive updates on?
Who are you?
Which industry or sector do you operate in? (Optional)