Published on · Last updated
On 16 November 2026 the Netherlands Food and Consumer Product Safety Authority (NVWA) reported that 19 of 30 toys for children under 3 from web shops outside the EU were unsafe. As a rule, an operator established in the EU must answer for each toy sold into the EU. This page explains who that is.
In short
- Toys that do not meet the Warenwetbesluit speelgoed 2011, which applies the EU Toy Safety Directive, may not be manufactured or traded in the Netherlands.
- Whether you act as importer, authorised representative or fulfilment service provider for a non-EU toy depends on your contract and mandate; check your role before a shipment is stopped.
- A ‘not suitable for children under 3’ warning cannot be used where it conflicts with the toy’s intended use.
- Involve a lawyer when the NVWA, customs, a platform or an injured party holds you to account.
What did the NVWA find?
The NVWA found unsafe toys in 19 of the 30 products it examined, offered through Temu, AliExpress, Wish and Shein. The platforms had to take the unsafe products offline, and the results were shared with other EU Member States and reported to the European Commission.
The toys were meant for children under 3. According to the NVWA news release, laboratory tests showed small parts coming loose, cords that were too long, and small balls or toy figures, which create a choking hazard. The products included wooden toys, magnetic toys and play sets.
The NVWA is also open about the limits of its supervision. It writes that it cannot act effectively against suppliers from outside the EU, that platforms are often only an intermediary for suppliers that are hard to trace, and that products often name no manufacturer. NOS reports that twelve products carried the warning ‘not suitable for children under 3 years’ although they were meant for young children, and that three products contained magnets that were too strong. According to NOS, the NVWA suggests suppliers may use the warning to avoid additional tests.
Which rules currently apply to toys in the Netherlands?
Toys that do not meet the Warenwetbesluit speelgoed 2011 may not be manufactured or traded in the Netherlands. The decree applies the Toy Safety Directive 2009/48/EC, which sets the substantive requirements.
Article 2(1) of the Warenwetbesluit speelgoed 2011 prohibits manufacturing or trading toys that do not meet the decree’s requirements. Article 2(3) prohibits bringing toys into Dutch territory other than in accordance with those requirements. Instructions, safety information and warnings must in any case be in Dutch (Articles 3(2), 5(2) and 7(2)).
The substantive requirements are in the Toy Safety Directive. Toys may not jeopardise the safety or health of users or third parties when used as intended or in a foreseeable way, bearing in mind the behaviour of children (Article 10(2)). For toys clearly intended for children under 36 months, the toy, its component parts and any detachable parts must be of such dimensions that they cannot be swallowed or inhaled (Annex II, Part I, point 4(d)), and toys may not present a risk of strangulation (point 4(a)). These requirements cover the hazards the NVWA describes: small parts coming loose, long cords and small balls or figures.
Who is responsible: manufacturer, importer, distributor or platform?
Every link in the chain has its own obligations under the Toy Safety Directive. The manufacturer has the most extensive obligations, but the importer places only compliant toys on the market and the distributor verifies marking and documents before making a toy available.
| Role | Core obligation | Legal basis |
|---|---|---|
| Manufacturer | Safe design, technical documentation, conformity assessment, CE marking, name and contact address on the toy | Art. 4 Toy Safety Directive |
| Importer | Place only compliant toys on the market, check the manufacturer’s work, state its own name and address | Art. 6 Toy Safety Directive |
| Distributor | Act with due care and verify marking, documents and language of the instructions before making the toy available | Art. 7 Toy Safety Directive |
| Importer or distributor under its own name | Is considered a manufacturer and bound by the manufacturer’s obligations | Art. 8 Toy Safety Directive |
| Fulfilment service provider | Responsible EU operator where no manufacturer, importer or authorised representative is established in the EU | Art. 4(2)(d) Regulation (EU) 2019/1020 |
| Online marketplace | Contact points, handling of orders and notices, trader information in the listing | Art. 22 Regulation (EU) 2023/988 |
For toys from outside the EU, one rule is decisive in practice. Under Article 4 of Regulation (EU) 2019/1020, which covers products under the Toy Safety Directive (Article 4(5)), such a product may be placed on the market only if an economic operator established in the Union is responsible for set tasks: keeping the declaration of conformity and technical documentation available, informing the authorities of risks and cooperating on corrective action. That operator is the manufacturer if established in the EU, otherwise the importer, an authorised representative with a written mandate or, where none of them is established in the EU, a fulfilment service provider (Article 4(2)). Its name and contact details must appear on the product, packaging, parcel or an accompanying document (Article 4(4)).
Customs must suspend the release of a product for free circulation if those details are missing or not identifiable (Article 26(1)(d)). An online offer counts as making the product available on the market if it is targeted at end users in the Union, which is the case if the operator directs its activities, by any means, to a Member State (Article 6). The bottleneck the NVWA describes is therefore enforceability, not whether the rules apply.
Important: If you are the only EU-established party in a toy supply chain, you may be the operator the authorities look to, whether you are an importer, authorised representative or fulfilment service provider (Article 4(2) Regulation (EU) 2019/1020). Check your role, your mandate and the documents you can produce before a shipment is stopped. A product safety lawyer can review that position before customs or the NVWA ask.
Why may the warning ‘not suitable for children under 3 years’ not always be used?
A toy may not carry a specific Annex V warning where that warning conflicts with its intended use, determined by its function, dimensions and characteristics. A toddler toy remains a toddler toy, whatever the label says.
Article 11(1) of the Toy Safety Directive provides this. Recital 30 explains why: the rule is meant to prevent warnings being misused to circumvent the applicable safety requirements, in particular the warning that a toy is not suitable for children under 36 months. For importers and web shops, the supplier’s age indication is therefore not decisive; the toy itself is. Warnings that determine the decision to purchase, such as the minimum and maximum age, must appear on the consumer packaging or otherwise be clearly visible before purchase, including online (Article 11(2)).
What must online marketplaces do?
Providers of online marketplaces must have contact points for authorities and consumers, register with the Safety Gate Portal, act on a removal order within two working days and process product safety notices within three working days.
These obligations are in Article 22 of the General Product Safety Regulation: a removal order concerning a dangerous product must be acted on without undue delay and in any event within two working days of receipt (Article 22(4)), and notices within three working days (Article 22(8)). Article 22 is in a part of the Regulation that Article 2(1) leaves applicable to products under harmonisation legislation such as toys. The interface must let traders give, per product, the manufacturer’s details, the responsible person established in the EU where the manufacturer is not, product identification and warnings (Article 22(9)). Traders that frequently offer products that do not comply with that Regulation must be suspended, after a prior warning, for a reasonable period (Article 22(11)).
What changes with the new Toy Safety Regulation?
Regulation (EU) 2025/2509 repeals the Toy Safety Directive from 1 August 2030 and introduces a digital product passport. From then, offers of non-compliant toys on marketplaces count as illegal content under the Digital Services Act (Article 14(1)).
This page covers the NVWA findings and who answers for a toy today. The new regulation itself, including its chemical rules and transitional provisions, is explained on our page on the EU Toy Safety Regulation.
The Regulation was signed on 26 November 2025 and published in the Official Journal on 12 December 2025. Before placing a toy on the market, the manufacturer creates a digital product passport (Article 19(1)). It keeps the technical documentation and the passport for 10 years after the toy is placed on the market (Article 7(3)), and the passport must be available for that period (Article 19(2)(g)). Member States may not impede toys placed on the market in conformity with the Directive before 1 August 2030 (Article 57(1)).
| Date | What happens? |
|---|---|
| 1 January 2026 | Articles 28 to 44 and 49 to 55 of the Toy Safety Regulation apply |
| 9 December 2026 | Deadline for Member States to transpose the new Product Liability Directive |
| 1 August 2028 | Member States notify the Commission of their penalty rules for the Toy Safety Regulation |
| 1 August 2030 | Toy Safety Regulation applies in full; Toy Safety Directive repealed |
| 1 February 2031 | EC type-examination certificates issued under the Directive remain valid until then, unless they expire earlier |
Who is liable for damage caused by unsafe toys?
From 9 December 2026 the Directive requires Member States to hold the importer and authorised representative liable alongside a non-EU manufacturer, failing both the fulfilment service provider. If no EU operator can be identified, a distributor is liable unless it names one, or its supplier, within a month of the request.
Directive (EU) 2024/2853 repeals Directive 85/374/EEC with effect from 9 December 2026, which is also the transposition deadline (Articles 21 and 22). The old directive continues to apply to products placed on the market or put into service before that date. Article 8(1)(c) lists the liable operators. Where no liable operator established in the EU can be identified, each distributor is liable if it does not identify one, or its own supplier, within one month of the injured person’s request (Article 8(3)).
The Directive requires Member States to ensure that liability towards the injured person is not limited or excluded by a contractual provision or by national law (Article 15), and that an operator that has compensated the injured person can seek recourse from other liable operators in accordance with national law (Article 14). The limitation period is three years from the day the injured person knew or should reasonably have known of the damage, the defect and the liable operator (Article 16). As a rule the expiry period is 10 years from placing on the market, or 25 years for latent personal injury, unless the injured person has started proceedings in the meantime (Article 17). Purchase contracts with suppliers outside the EU should therefore deal with recourse, indemnification and access to technical documentation.
Important: The Product Liability Directive must be transposed by 9 December 2026, and which regime applies depends on when a product was placed on the market. Check how the Directive is implemented in Dutch law. A lawyer should look at purchase contracts before a claim arrives, because recourse clauses are hard to put right afterwards.
What does this mean for your business?
For businesses in the toy chain, supervision and liability meet on three points: traceability, documentation and age classification. Which obligations apply depends on the role your organisation legally has.
An illustration. Suppose a web shop established in the Netherlands buys wooden toy trains from a manufacturer in Asia and sells them under its own brand. The box says ‘not suitable for children under 3 years’, but by function, dimensions and characteristics the train is clearly meant for toddlers. The shop would then be treated as the manufacturer, the warning would conflict with the intended use, and the requirements on detachable parts would apply. If a wheel comes loose in a test, the shop is the party the authority can address.
Do you want to know which role your organisation has and which documents you must be able to produce? Read more about product liability and product safety advice in the Netherlands.
Frequently asked questions about toy safety and non-EU web shops
Can I sell a toy that says ‘not suitable for children under 3’?
Not if the warning conflicts with the toy’s intended use, as determined by its function, dimensions and characteristics (Article 11(1) Toy Safety Directive). A toy clearly meant for toddlers stays subject to the strict requirements, including those on detachable parts and strangulation risks.
Who is responsible if the manufacturer is outside the EU?
As a rule an economic operator established in the Union must be responsible: the importer, an authorised representative with a written mandate or, where neither exists, a fulfilment service provider (Article 4(2) Regulation (EU) 2019/1020). Its name and contact details belong on the product, packaging, parcel or an accompanying document.
When does the new Toy Safety Regulation apply?
It applies from 1 August 2030, when the Toy Safety Directive is repealed, although Articles 28 to 44 and 49 to 55 apply since 1 January 2026 (Article 59). Toys placed on the market in conformity with the Directive before 1 August 2030 may continue to be made available (Article 57(1)).
What happens if the EU operator’s details are missing from my toys?
Customs must suspend release for free circulation where the name and contact details of the responsible operator are not indicated or identifiable (Article 26(1)(d) Regulation (EU) 2019/1020). Before a market surveillance authority orders a measure, you are as a rule heard within at least 10 working days, unless urgency prevents it (Article 18(3)).
When should you engage a product safety lawyer?
Engage a product safety lawyer as soon as a regulator, customs, a platform or an injured party holds your business to account for the safety of a product. Time limits can be short.
- The NVWA announces a measure or decision. As a rule you are given an opportunity to be heard within an appropriate period of at least 10 working days, unless urgency prevents it (Article 18(3) Regulation (EU) 2019/1020).
- Customs detains a shipment of toys because documents, marking or contact details are missing.
- A platform removes your offer or suspends your account after an order or notice about product safety.
- You discover a safety risk yourself. A manufacturer or importer that has reason to believe a toy it has placed on the market is not in conformity must immediately take the corrective measures necessary, such as bringing it into conformity, withdrawing it or recalling it, and, if the toy presents a risk, inform the competent authorities (Articles 4(8) and 6(7) Toy Safety Directive).
- A customer or consumer holds you liable, or you want recourse against your supplier.
- You conclude or revise contracts with manufacturers, distributors, agents or fulfilment partners.
Have you received a letter from the NVWA, or do you want your product range and purchase contracts reviewed? Contact Max Schwillens.
Legal framework and sources
- NVWA, news release of 16 November 2026, NVWA: ruim de helft van onderzocht speelgoed van buitenlandse webshops niet veilig (in Dutch).
- NOS, NVWA ziet ernstige veiligheidsrisico’s bij speelgoed van webshops buiten EU (in Dutch; source for the warning and magnet figures).
- Warenwetbesluit speelgoed 2011, Articles 2, 3, 5 and 7 (in Dutch).
- Directive 2009/48/EC on the safety of toys, Articles 4, 6, 7, 8, 10 and 11, recital 30, Annex II Part I point 4.
- Regulation (EU) 2019/1020 on market surveillance and compliance of products, Articles 4, 6, 18 and 26.
- Regulation (EU) 2023/988 on general product safety, Articles 2 and 22.
- Regulation (EU) 2025/2509 on the safety of toys, Articles 7, 14, 19, 55, 56, 57 and 59.
- Directive (EU) 2024/2853 on liability for defective products, Articles 8, 14, 15, 16, 17, 21 and 22.