Notice and takedown on an EU marketplace: stop fakes

Share this article

WhatsAppLinkedIn

Published on · Last updated

Notice and takedown on an EU marketplace works through the notice and action mechanism of the Digital Services Act: you report each counterfeit listing with your trade mark and its URL, and the platform must decide. If not, a complaint or Dutch summary proceedings follow. As a Dutch IP lawyer at MAAK Advocaten in Amsterdam, I advise foreign brand owners on when to report and when to sue.

This article is part of our pages on intellectual property law in the Netherlands. It is for brand owners outside the Netherlands whose products are copied on Amazon, bol or another marketplace selling to EU customers. If you run a marketplace yourself, read our page on the Digital Services Act for platforms and sellers.

What is notice and takedown under the Digital Services Act?

In notice and takedown, you tell a platform about an illegal listing (the notice) and the platform removes it (the takedown). Since 17 February 2024, every hosting service offering services in the EU must have an electronic notice and action mechanism.

The obligation is in Article 16(1) of the Digital Services Act, Regulation (EU) 2022/2065 (DSA), adopted on 19 October 2022. It entered into force on 16 November 2022 and applies from 17 February 2024 (Article 93). It covers services offered to recipients in the Union, wherever the provider is established (Article 2(1)). A marketplace that stores listings of sellers is a hosting service (Article 3(g)(iii)). Because it shows them to the public, it is also an online platform (Article 3(i)). Illegal content includes information on the sale of products that breaches EU or national law, such as counterfeits of your brand (Article 3(h)).

The DSA does not decide when a product is counterfeit. Trade mark law does. The owner of an EU trade mark can stop the use of an identical sign for identical goods (Article 9(2)(a) EU Trade Mark Regulation). The Benelux rule is the same (Article 2.20(2)(a) BVIE, the Benelux Convention on Intellectual Property). The notice is the channel; your trade mark is the ground.

When must Amazon or bol remove counterfeit listings?

A marketplace that wants to keep its exemption from liability must act expeditiously once it has actual knowledge of a counterfeit listing. A precise, well-reasoned notice gives it that knowledge.

A hosting service is not liable for what sellers store while it has no actual knowledge of the illegal content. Once it knows, it keeps that exemption only if it acts expeditiously to remove the content or disable access to it (Article 6(1) DSA). A notice gives that knowledge when a diligent provider can identify the illegality without a detailed legal examination (Article 16(3)). The platform need not search for fakes itself; the DSA imposes no general obligation to monitor (Article 8).

That is where cases differ. A fake with your registered trade mark on it is easy for a platform to assess. Harder are a look-alike without your mark, genuine goods sold outside your network, or your own photos in another listing. Whether the platform must act then depends on your rights and on what the notice shows. For genuine goods from outside Europe, see parallel imports in the Netherlands.

Important: If you report look-alikes without your trade mark, the platform may be unable to see the infringement without a detailed legal examination (Article 16(3) DSA) and may reject the notice. If you frequently submit manifestly unfounded notices, the platform must stop processing them for a reasonable period after a warning (Article 23(2)). Have a Dutch IP lawyer assess such listings before you file a batch of notices.

Counterfeits of your brand on an EU marketplace? Send me the listings and your trade mark registration through my page as Dutch intellectual property lawyer, and I will tell you whether a notice is enough.

What should a notice of counterfeit goods contain?

A notice contains four elements. You explain why the listing is counterfeit and give its exact URL. You state your name and email address. And you confirm your good faith belief that the notice is accurate and complete.

The platform must make it easy to submit notices with these elements (Article 16(2) DSA):

  1. a sufficiently reasoned explanation of why the listing is illegal (point a);
  2. the exact electronic location, such as the exact URL or URLs (point b);
  3. your name and email address (point c);
  4. a statement of your bona fide belief that the information is accurate and complete (point d).

Fakes under your brand cost you sales, and the trust of customers who believe they bought your product. My advice is therefore: record first, then report. Take dated screenshots of each listing with its URL, note the name of the seller and, if in doubt, make a test purchase. Once a listing is gone, so is your evidence. Then report each listing separately, with your trade mark registration and a plain explanation of why it is a fake.

After your notice, the platform sends a confirmation of receipt without undue delay. It decides in a timely, diligent, non-arbitrary and objective manner and then tells you its decision and the possibilities for redress (Article 16(4) to (6)). Use the reporting form that the marketplace itself offers.

The platform rejected your notice or the seller is back: what now?

If the platform rejects your notice, you lodge a complaint through its internal complaint-handling system, and you can turn to a certified out-of-court body. If the same seller keeps posting fakes, the platform must suspend it after a warning.

An online platform must give notifiers a free, electronic internal complaint-handling system for at least six months after the decision (Article 20(1) and (2) DSA). You may also choose a certified out-of-court dispute settlement body (Article 21(1)). It decides within 90 days, or 180 days in highly complex disputes (Article 21(4)). Its decision is not binding (Article 21(2)), and you can still go to court.

A seller that frequently provides manifestly illegal content must be suspended for a reasonable period after a prior warning (Article 23(1)). Platforms that are micro or small enterprises do not have these duties, unless they are very large online platforms (Article 19).

At that point I stop relying on notices alone. I file the complaint on your behalf. At the same time I write to the seller, because the seller is the source. If it reappears after removal, I remind the platform of its duty to suspend. If that does not help, I ask a Dutch court for an injunction against the seller.

A marketplace that lets consumers buy from traders must obtain the trader’s details first (Article 30(1)). It must show the trader’s name, address, telephone number and email address on the product page (Article 30(7)). Other details, such as an identity document or payment account, it gives to third parties only where the law requires it, for example under an order (Article 30(6)).

Important: If the same seller returns under a new shop name, you need evidence that it is the same seller and the same batch of fakes. A Dutch court can order the infringer to disclose the origin and distribution channels (Article 2.22(4) BVIE). Have a Dutch IP lawyer secure that evidence before you report again, so that it does not disappear with the listing.

Can you take the marketplace itself to a Dutch court?

Yes, though usually not as the infringer. The marketplace is an intermediary. A court can still order it to end an infringement by its sellers and to prevent further infringements of that kind, even if it is not liable itself.

The hosting exemption leaves intact the power of a court to require the provider to terminate or prevent an infringement (Article 6(4) DSA). For Benelux trade marks, the court can order an intermediary whose services are used to infringe to stop those services (Article 2.22(6) BVIE). In summary proceedings, this can be a provisional order (Article 2.22(3)).

According to the Court of Justice, national courts must be able to order a marketplace operator to take measures against infringements by its users (Court of Justice 12 July 2011, C-324/09, L’Oréal v eBay, paragraph 144, on Article 11 of Directive 2004/48). Such measures help end infringements and prevent new ones of that kind. They must be effective, proportionate and dissuasive, without barriers to legitimate trade.

My order is: the seller first, with a cease-and-desist letter and, if needed, summary proceedings. I ask for an order against the marketplace when the seller cannot be reached or returns after every ban. Then only the platform can actually stop the listings.

Important: An order that makes the platform check all its listings sits badly with Article 8 DSA, which rules out a general monitoring obligation. The more precisely your claim describes the seller, the product and the sign, the easier it is for the court to assess it. Have a Dutch IP lawyer draft the claim before you summon the marketplace.

How do you act against the seller in the Netherlands?

Against the seller you start with a cease-and-desist letter: stop, hand over the stock and disclose the source. If the seller does not comply, you ask a Dutch court in summary proceedings (kort geding) for an injunction backed by a penalty.

In urgent cases, the preliminary relief judge (voorzieningenrechter) can grant immediate relief (Article 254 Dutch Code of Civil Procedure). For a Benelux trade mark, a provisional injunction can carry a penalty payment (dwangsom) (Article 2.22(3) BVIE), and the court can also order recall or destruction of the goods and disclosure of their origin (Article 2.22(1) and (4)). On request, the loser pays the winner’s reasonable and proportionate legal costs, unless fairness dictates otherwise (Article 1019h Dutch Code of Civil Procedure).

As claimant, you can only bring summary proceedings through a Dutch lawyer: Article 79(2) Dutch Code of Civil Procedure requires one, and Article 255(1) only exempts the defendant. A trader based in the Netherlands can be sued before a Dutch court: for an EU trade mark under Article 125(1) EU Trade Mark Regulation, for a Benelux trade mark under Article 4(1) Brussels I bis Regulation.

Whether summary proceedings make sense depends on the seller. A Dutch trader with stock here is easy to reach; a seller outside the EU points to the route via the platform. If the fakes arrive by sea or air, see counterfeit goods at Dutch customs.

Practical example: a UK cycling brand on a Dutch marketplace

Suppose a UK maker of cycling clothing with a Benelux trade mark finds counterfeit jerseys under its mark on a marketplace that sells to Dutch and Belgian customers. The seller is a trader in the Netherlands. This is an illustration, not a real case.

The brand records the listings and reports each one with its trade mark registration. The platform removes them. Two weeks later the jerseys return in a new shop. The trader details on the product page (Article 30(7)) show the address of the first seller. The brand sends a cease-and-desist letter and gets no answer. It then asks the preliminary relief judge for an injunction with a penalty and an order to name its supplier.

When do you need a Dutch lawyer?

Have a Dutch IP lawyer assess the case once a notice is rejected, the seller returns or you doubt whether you may report; clear fakes with your registered mark you can report yourself. A court order requires a lawyer (Article 79(2) Dutch Code of Civil Procedure).

Brand owners from the United States often expect a procedure like the DMCA, with fixed deadlines and a formal counter-notice. The DSA works differently: the platform must decide in a timely, diligent and objective manner, but the regulation sets no fixed period (Article 16(6) DSA).

The document that makes the biggest difference is your trade mark registration: a mark for exactly the goods offered, valid in the EU or the Benelux. So I first check whether your mark covers the right goods and the right territory. My advice: register your mark in the EU or the Benelux before you start reporting. If you work with distributors, agree who reports on your behalf, so that three parties do not work past each other.

How does MAAK Advocaten handle counterfeit listings on marketplaces?

In the first days we record the listings and the seller and assess your trade mark rights. We then draft the notice or the complaint so that the platform can decide without a long legal examination.

Next, we send the seller a cease-and-desist letter. If needed, I bring summary proceedings or proceedings on the merits against the seller. As a last step, I act against the marketplace, at first instance and on appeal. We work in English. You know your product and your market; we take the legal route off your hands.

Frequently asked questions

How fast must an EU marketplace remove a counterfeit listing?

The Digital Services Act sets no fixed deadline. A platform must handle notices in a timely, diligent, non-arbitrary and objective manner (Article 16(6) DSA). If it does not act expeditiously once it knows of the counterfeit, it loses its exemption from liability (Article 6(1)). A complete notice speeds up the decision.

Is notice and takedown under the DSA the same as a DMCA takedown?

No. The DMCA is a US procedure. The DSA is an EU regulation that covers all illegal content, including counterfeit goods. It requires a notice and action mechanism (Article 16 DSA), a statement of reasons to the seller (Article 17) and a complaint system (Article 20), and sets no fixed number of days for the platform’s decision (Article 16(6)).

Can I report counterfeits if my trade mark is only registered in the US?

You can report, but a US registration gives no exclusive right in the EU. That right arises from registering an EU trade mark (Article 9(1) EU Trade Mark Regulation) or a Benelux trade mark (Article 2.20(1) BVIE). Without one, your notice must rest on another right, which a platform may not be able to assess without a detailed legal examination (Article 16(3) DSA).

What is a trusted flagger?

A trusted flagger is an entity whose notices online platforms must handle with priority (Article 22(1) DSA). The status is awarded by the Digital Services Coordinator of the Member State where the applicant is established (Article 22(2)), so only an entity based in the EU can apply. In the Netherlands that is the ACM (Article 2.1 Dutch DSA Implementation Act). An ordinary notice does not need it.

Do I need a Dutch lawyer to act against a marketplace seller?

Not for a notice or a complaint to the platform. For summary proceedings in the Netherlands you do: as claimant you can only litigate through a lawyer (Articles 79(2) and 255(1) Dutch Code of Civil Procedure). MAAK Advocaten in Amsterdam acts for foreign brand owners in these cases, in English, and first assesses whether a notice will do.

Primary sources

Are counterfeits of your product listed on Amazon, bol or another EU marketplace? Put your situation to me: call +31 20 210 31 38 or send your question through my page as Dutch intellectual property lawyer. — Arnout Gieske

News & Insights
Which topics would you like to receive updates on?
Who are you?
Which industry or sector do you operate in? (Optional)