Enforcement Measures, Fines, and Prosecution by the Netherlands Food and Consumer Product Safety Authority

Share this article

WhatsAppLinkedIn

Published on · Last updated

The NVWA (Nederlandse Voedsel- en Warenautoriteit, Netherlands Food and Consumer Product Safety Authority) supervises food safety and consumer product safety. If you break the Commodities Act (Warenwet), it can issue a warning, an order for administrative enforcement or an order subject to a penalty, or impose an administrative fine (Sections 32 and 32a; Article 5:32 Awb).

In short

  • The NVWA classes violations as serious, medium or minor; the class indicates whether feedback, a warning or a fine can follow.
  • Warenwet fines are fixed per violation in an annex, with a higher column for businesses with more than 50 employees.
  • You can object to a fine within six weeks after the day on which the decision was announced, and then appeal to the district court.
  • Prosecution is for the Public Prosecution Service, not the NVWA; take legal advice when a report or an intended fine arrives.

Which rules does the NVWA enforce?

The NVWA enforces the Warenwet and the EU rules it implements: officials designated under Section 25 supervise compliance, and the NVWA carries out this supervision. EU food law makes food business operators responsible for ensuring that their food satisfies the food law requirements relevant to their activities and for verifying this; Member States must enforce food law and lay down effective, proportionate and dissuasive measures and penalties (Regulation (EC) No 178/2002, Article 17(1) and (2)). For consumer products, Regulation (EU) 2023/988 (General Product Safety Regulation) applies from 13 December 2024 (Article 52), and Section 21(1)-(3) of the Warenwet does not apply to products covered by it (Section 21(4)). Questions about a product: Martin Krüger, product law attorney at MAAK Advocaten.

How does an inspection proceed?

NVWA inspectors are supervisory officials (toezichthouders) designated under Section 25 Commodities Act. They may enter any place except a dwelling without the occupant’s consent, demand information, inspect and copy business records and take samples, and you must give the cooperation they can reasonably demand within the reasonable period they set, except to the extent a duty of confidentiality prevents it (Articles 5:15–5:20 Awb). They may use these powers as far as reasonably necessary (Article 5:13 Awb). If they find a violation, they may also give you information to help you comply (nalevingshulp, article 5.2). See also the page on Dutch government inspections for businesses and the NVWA inspection page.

Since 13 January 2024, the NVWA applies a policy rule that classifies violations as serious, medium or minor (article 4.1 Algemeen interventiebeleid NVWA 2024). For a minor violation, the intervention can be oral or written feedback; a repeated minor violation can be handled as a medium one (article 4.4). For a medium violation, the NVWA can give an official warning, which states the violation and the interventions you can expect if you repeat it (article 5.3). A serious violation can lead to a punitive sanction, such as an administrative fine.

To end a violation or prevent it from happening again, the NVWA can impose an order for administrative enforcement (last onder bestuursdwang): an order to remedy the violation, which the authority may carry out itself if you do not comply in time (Section 32 Commodities Act; Article 5:21 Awb). The costs are as a rule for you (Article 5:25 Awb). Instead, the NVWA can impose an order subject to a penalty (last onder dwangsom): you forfeit a sum of money if you do not comply in time (Articles 5:31d and 5:32(1) Awb). An order that aims to undo or prevent a violation gives you a period in which you can comply without forfeiting the penalty (Article 5:32a(2) Awb).

Which administrative fines can be imposed?

The minister (through the NVWA) can impose an administrative fine (bestuurlijke boete) for violations of the provisions listed in Section 32a(1) Commodities Act. A fine is a punitive sanction: an unconditional obligation to pay a sum of money (Article 5:40(1) Awb). No fine is imposed to the extent that the violation cannot be blamed on you (Article 5:41 Awb). The violation cannot be settled with a fine if an intentional or reckless violation causes a direct danger to human health or safety, or if the economic gain from the violation considerably exceeds the fine in the annex (Section 32a(3)).

The amount is fixed per violation in the annex to the Commodities Act Fines Decree (Warenwetbesluit bestuurlijke boeten). Column I applies to a business with 50 or fewer employees on the day of the violation and column II to a larger business (article 3(1) and (2)). For some violations, a business with a turnover of at least EUR 10 million in the preceding financial year can receive a turnover-related fine: 1% of annual turnover for intent and 0.5% for gross negligence, up to the sixth fine category of the Criminal Code (article 2(2) and article 3(3)). The fine can be increased if the violator was fined before for a similar violation, less than two years have passed since that fine became final, and the seriousness of the violation, the extent to which it can be blamed on you or the circumstances give reason to do so (article 3(4)). A fine per violation may not exceed the sixth category (Section 32a(2) Commodities Act). If you make it plausible that the fixed amount is too high because of special circumstances, the NVWA imposes a lower fine (Article 5:46(3) Awb).

If a fine of more than EUR 340 can be imposed, a report of the violation (rapport van bevindingen) is drawn up and you are invited to give your views on the intended fine, unless a statute provides otherwise (Article 5:53 Awb). You receive the report with that invitation (Article 5:50(1) Awb). If you are interviewed with a view to a fine, you do not have to make statements about the violation, and you must be told so beforehand (Article 5:10a Awb). The NVWA decides within thirteen weeks after the date of the report; that period is suspended while the conduct is with the Public Prosecution Service (Article 5:51 Awb).

If you disagree with the fine, you can file an objection (bezwaar) with the authority that imposed the fine, as the decision states, within six weeks, starting the day after the decision was announced (Articles 6:7 and 6:8 Awb). The authority then reconsiders its decision. Against the decision on the objection, you can appeal to the district court of Rotterdam and then to the Trade and Industry Appeals Tribunal (College van Beroep voor het bedrijfsleven) (Administrative Jurisdiction Division Regulation, Bevoegdheidsregeling bestuursrechtspraak, Annex 2 to the Awb, articles 7 and 11). If the matter is urgent, you can ask the court for interim relief once you have objected (Article 8:81 Awb).

Important: The six-week objection period runs from the day after the decision is announced, and your chance to give views comes before the fine is set. Missing a period can cost you the chance to contest the decision. Have a Dutch lawyer review the report and the intended fine as soon as they arrive, before you respond.

Depending on the applicable rules, the NVWA can enforce under administrative law or under criminal law (article 5.1 Algemeen interventiebeleid NVWA 2024). If conduct is also a criminal offence, the authority submits it to the public prosecutor, unless a statute or an agreement with the Public Prosecution Service provides otherwise (Article 5:44(2) Awb). The authority may impose a fine for such conduct only if the prosecutor has said not to prosecute, or if no response comes within thirteen weeks (Article 5:44(3)). No fine can follow if, for the same conduct, the trial hearing has begun or a penalty order has been issued (Article 5:44(1)). The Public Prosecution Service decides whether to prosecute (Article 167 Code of Criminal Procedure).

A company can be prosecuted, and so can those who ordered the offence or actually directed the prohibited conduct, or both (Article 51 Criminal Code). For a criminal case, consult a criminal defence lawyer.

Frequently asked questions about NVWA enforcement measures, fines and prosecution

What is the NVWA in the Netherlands?

The NVWA (Nederlandse Voedsel- en Warenautoriteit) is the Netherlands Food and Consumer Product Safety Authority. Its policy rule lists the public interests it protects: food safety, animal health, animal welfare, nature and environment, plant health, product safety, and discouraging tobacco and alcohol use (article 2.1 Algemeen interventiebeleid NVWA 2024).

What powers do NVWA inspectors have?

They may enter any place except a dwelling without consent, demand information, inspect and copy business records, take samples (Articles 5:15-5:18 Awb); under the Warenwet they may also enter business rooms inside a dwelling (Section 29 Commodities Act). You must give the cooperation they can reasonably demand within the period they set, unless confidentiality duties prevent it (Article 5:20(1)-(2) Awb).

How high can an NVWA fine be?

For Warenwet violations, the amount is fixed per violation in the annex to the Fines Decree, with a higher column for businesses with more than 50 employees. Some violations allow a turnover-related fine of 1% (intent) or 0.5% (gross negligence) of annual turnover. A fine per violation may not exceed the sixth category (Section 32a(2)).

If you fail to comply with food legislation, who can be prosecuted?

A company can be prosecuted, and so can those who ordered the offence or actually directed the prohibited conduct, or both (Article 51 Criminal Code). The Public Prosecution Service decides whether to prosecute.

How can you challenge an NVWA fine?

Before the fine, you can give your views on the intended fine (Article 5:53(3) Awb). After the fine, you can object within six weeks, starting the day after the decision was announced (Articles 6:7 and 6:8 Awb). Then you can appeal to the district court of Rotterdam and, on further appeal, to the Trade and Industry Appeals Tribunal.

Primary sources

When should you engage a lawyer for NVWA enforcement?

Consider legal advice as soon as you receive a report of findings, an intention to impose a fine, or an order for administrative enforcement or subject to a penalty: the periods for giving your views and for objecting are short. Remko Roosjen, lawyer at MAAK Advocaten, can look at your position.

News & Insights
Which topics would you like to receive updates on?
Who are you?
Which industry or sector do you operate in? (Optional)