Liability Law in the Netherlands

Published on · Last updated

Under Dutch law, a business must compensate damage it causes when it fails to perform a contract and the failure is attributable to it (Article 6:74 Dutch Civil Code), and when it commits an unlawful act that can be attributed to it (Article 6:162). A few strict liabilities, such as for employees and defective products, apply without personal fault.

In short

  • Contract route: damages are due for an attributable failure to perform, as a rule after a notice of default (Articles 6:74, 6:82).
  • Tort route: you need an unlawful act, attribution, damage, causation and a norm that protects against that damage (Articles 6:162, 6:163).
  • A liability clause can be set aside if relying on it is unacceptable; as a rule claims are time-barred five years after awareness (Articles 6:248(2), 3:310(1)).
  • For a substantial claim, have a Dutch lawyer check the applicable law, the clause, the notice of default and limitation.

Dutch liability law is part of the Dutch law of obligations, which you will find in Book 6 of the Dutch Civil Code (Burgerlijk Wetboek). Its damages rules compensate the loss suffered (Article 6:95) and it does not rely on common-law concepts such as consideration. For the wider framework, see our overview of the law of obligations in the Netherlands. This page covers liability between businesses; personal injury claims of private individuals are outside its scope.

When is a contracting party liable under Dutch law?

A contracting party is liable when it fails to perform an obligation (tekortkoming, often called wanprestatie) and the failure can be attributed to it. Every failure to perform obliges the debtor to compensate the resulting damage, unless the failure cannot be attributed to the debtor (Article 6:74(1) Dutch Civil Code).

A failure is not attributable if it is not the debtor’s fault and is not for its account by law, by a juridical act or by generally accepted views (Article 6:75 Dutch Civil Code). This is the Dutch concept of overmacht (force majeure). A debtor who uses other people to perform the contract, such as subcontractors or suppliers, is liable for their conduct as if it were its own (Article 6:76 Dutch Civil Code). See also our page on what constitutes a contract breach under Dutch law.

Do you need to send a notice of default before claiming damages?

Usually yes. If performance is not yet permanently impossible, damages are only due once the debtor is in default (verzuim) (Article 6:74(2) Dutch Civil Code). Default arises when you send a written notice giving a reasonable period for performance and the debtor still does not perform within that period (Article 6:82(1) Dutch Civil Code).

No notice is needed in three situations: when a fixed deadline for performance passes without performance, unless the deadline has another purpose; when the obligation arises from a tort or is an obligation to pay damages and is not performed immediately; and when the creditor must conclude from a statement of the debtor that it will not perform (Article 6:83 Dutch Civil Code). A carefully worded notice of default matters, because it determines when default arises. Read more about default under Dutch law.

Besides damages, you can demand performance or terminate the contract for breach (ontbinding). Every failure to perform entitles the other party to terminate the contract in whole or in part, unless the failure, given its special nature or minor importance, does not justify termination (Article 6:265(1) Dutch Civil Code). Where performance is still possible, the right to terminate only arises once the debtor is in default (Article 6:265(2)).

What does Article 6:162 of the Dutch Civil Code require for tort liability?

Article 6:162 of the Dutch Civil Code makes a person who commits an unlawful act against another, which can be attributed to him, liable to compensate the resulting damage. Outside a contract, this is the central basis for liability under Dutch law, both between businesses and towards third parties.

A claim under Article 6:162 requires five elements:

  1. An unlawful act. This is an infringement of a right, an act or omission in breach of a statutory duty, or conduct contrary to what is socially acceptable according to unwritten law, unless there is a ground of justification (Article 6:162(2)).
  2. Attribution. The act can be attributed to the person who committed it if it is due to his fault or to a cause for which he is accountable by law or by generally accepted views (Article 6:162(3)).
  3. Damage suffered by the claimant.
  4. Causation between the act and the damage, assessed under Article 6:98 Dutch Civil Code (see below).
  5. Relativity: there is no liability if the violated norm does not serve to protect against the damage as suffered by the injured party (Article 6:163 Dutch Civil Code).

If persons acting as a group cause damage unlawfully through one of them, and the risk of damage should have deterred them from acting as a group, they can be jointly and severally liable (Article 6:166(1) Dutch Civil Code).

The open standard of “what is socially acceptable” means that pure financial loss can also be recoverable in tort, depending on the circumstances. A typical business example is a competitor who knowingly uses another company’s confidential information, or a party that breaks off negotiations where doing so is unacceptable in view of the other party’s justified reliance (HR 12 August 2005, ECLI:NL:HR:2005:AT7337, para. 3.6). Our page on tort under Dutch law discusses these situations in more detail.

Which damage is recoverable under Dutch law?

Dutch law compensates financial loss (vermogensschade) and other harm, the latter only to the extent the law grants a right to it (Article 6:95(1) Dutch Civil Code). Financial loss covers both the loss suffered and the profit lost (Article 6:96(1) Dutch Civil Code).

Reasonable costs to prevent or limit damage, reasonable costs to assess damage and liability, and reasonable costs to obtain payment out of court can also be recovered (Article 6:96(2)). For extrajudicial collection costs under a commercial agreement as defined in Articles 6:119a and 6:119b, the compensation is at least 40 euros (Article 6:96(4)).

Only damage that is connected to the event in such a way that it can be attributed to the liable party as a consequence of that event is recoverable, also considering the nature of the liability and of the damage (Article 6:98 Dutch Civil Code). If circumstances attributable to the injured party contributed to the damage, the compensation is reduced in proportion to each party’s contribution, unless fairness requires a different division (Article 6:101(1) Dutch Civil Code). More on calculating a claim: claims for damages under Dutch law.

Non-pecuniary harm is compensated only where the law provides for it: for example where the liable person intended to cause it, or the injured party suffered bodily injury or harm to honour or reputation, in an amount set in fairness (Article 6:106(1) Dutch Civil Code). A court may moderate a statutory duty to compensate if full compensation would have manifestly unacceptable consequences, given the nature of the liability, the relationship between the parties and their ability to pay, but not below the amount the debtor has insured or had to insure (Article 6:109(1) and (2) Dutch Civil Code).

When is a business liable without fault?

Dutch law also has strict liabilities (risicoaansprakelijkheid), where a business is liable for a person or object without personal fault. Five are particularly relevant for companies:

  • Employees and other subordinates: the employer is liable for damage caused to third parties by a fault of a subordinate if the task increased the risk of that fault and the employer had control over the conduct concerned (Article 6:170(1) Dutch Civil Code).
  • Non-subordinates working for the business: if a non-subordinate who carries out work on another’s instruction for that other’s business is liable to a third party for a fault committed in that work, that other is also liable to the third party (Article 6:171 Dutch Civil Code).
  • Buildings and structures: the possessor of a building or structure that does not meet the requirements that may be set for it, and thereby creates a danger that materialises, is liable, unless it would not have been liable even if it had known of the danger when it arose (Article 6:174(1) Dutch Civil Code; for buildings used in a business, see also Article 6:181(1)).
  • Defective products: the producer is liable for damage caused by a defect in its product, subject to the defences in Article 6:185(1) Dutch Civil Code. See our page on product liability under Dutch law.
  • Movable things and animals: the possessor of a movable thing known to pose a special danger if it does not meet the requirements that may be set for it, or of an animal, can be liable (Articles 6:173 and 6:179); where they are used in a business, the business bears that liability (Article 6:181(1)).

Directors of a Dutch company can also be held personally liable in certain situations. That is a separate topic, covered on our page on directors’ liability under Dutch law.

Can you limit or exclude liability in a Dutch contract?

In principle yes. Dutch law allows businesses to limit or exclude liability by contract, but a court will set the clause aside if relying on it would be unacceptable according to standards of reasonableness and fairness (Article 6:248(2) Dutch Civil Code). According to the Dutch Supreme Court, this will generally be the case if the damage is due to intent or deliberate recklessness of the debtor or of persons in charge of its business (HR 12 December 1997, ECLI:NL:HR:1997:ZC2524, para. 3.6.1).

A clause that conflicts with public order or good morals is void (Article 3:40 Dutch Civil Code). For a foreign company, one point matters: the Dutch rules on unreasonably onerous clauses in general terms and conditions do not apply to a contract between businesses that are not both established in the Netherlands, whatever law governs the contract (Article 6:247(2) Dutch Civil Code). The test is then reasonableness and fairness. See limitation of liability under Dutch law and exclusion of liability for indirect damage.

How long do you have to bring a liability claim in the Netherlands?

A claim for damages becomes time-barred five years after the day following the day on which the injured party became aware of both the damage and the liable person, and in any event twenty years after the event that caused the damage (Article 3:310(1) Dutch Civil Code). Other periods apply to some claims, for example for pollution or personal injury (Article 3:310(2) and (5)). Special rules apply to sales. Under the Dutch Civil Code, a buyer loses its rights if it does not notify the seller of a defect within a reasonable time after discovering it, or after it reasonably should have discovered it (Article 7:23(1) Dutch Civil Code). In an international sale of goods the CISG usually applies instead: notice must be given within a reasonable time and in any event within two years after the goods were actually handed over, unless a contractual guarantee period provides otherwise (Article 39 CISG).

The limitation period can be interrupted, for example by a written notice in which the creditor unequivocally reserves its right (Article 3:317 Dutch Civil Code). Keep proof of sending. For more, see limitation periods under Dutch law.

What should you do when you receive a liability claim from a Dutch party?

A Dutch liability claim calls for a prompt response, and an admission of liability is best avoided before the claim has been assessed. Notify your liability insurer and check the notification deadline in your policy. Then collect the contract, general terms and conditions, correspondence and delivery documents.

Check four things first: whether Dutch law applies to the relationship, whether the contract limits or excludes liability, whether the claimant sent a valid notice of default, and whether the claim may be time-barred. If the claimant threatens summary proceedings (kort geding), deadlines can be very short.

Important: A notice of default fixes when default starts, and a limitation period can run out while you assess the claim. Have a Dutch lawyer review the contract, the clause and the timeline before you send a notice of default or answer a claim.

Example: a maintenance error at a Dutch warehouse

Suppose (illustration) a Belgian trading company without any establishment in the Netherlands has its goods stored by a Dutch logistics company in Rotterdam and engages a Dutch installer to maintain the cooling system there. As a rule, without a choice of law, the maintenance contract is governed by the law of the service provider, here Dutch law (Article 4(1)(b) Rome I). After a maintenance visit, the system fails over a weekend and a stock of fresh products spoils. The installer’s general terms exclude liability for consequential loss and cap liability at the invoice amount.

Under Dutch law, the questions are whether the failure is attributable to the installer (Articles 6:74 and 6:75), whether a notice of default was needed or the damage was already final, which loss is attributable under Article 6:98, and whether relying on the exclusion and the cap is unacceptable under Article 6:248(2). Because the Belgian company is not established in the Netherlands, the Dutch rules on unreasonably onerous clauses in general terms do not apply (Article 6:247(2)); the outcome turns on reasonableness and fairness and the facts, such as how serious the installer’s error was.

When should you involve a Dutch liability lawyer?

Involve a Dutch lawyer as soon as a substantial claim is made or threatened, before you send a notice of default yourself, and before a limitation period runs out. The wording of the first letters often determines the evidence, the default and the interest that will be at stake later.

Remko Roosjen and our Dutch liability lawyers and commercial litigation lawyers can assess the claim, check the deadlines and the contract terms, and prepare the notice or the response.

Blogs

Frequently asked questions about Dutch liability law

What is Article 6:162 of the Dutch Civil Code?

Article 6:162 of the Dutch Civil Code is the general rule on tort (onrechtmatige daad). A person who commits an unlawful act against another that can be attributed to him must compensate the damage. The claimant must also show damage, causation and that the violated norm protects against that damage (Article 6:163).

What is the difference between breach of contract and tort under Dutch law?

Breach of contract (wanprestatie) is a failure to perform a contractual obligation, governed by Article 6:74 Dutch Civil Code. Tort is an unlawful act outside or alongside a contract, governed by Article 6:162. The requirements differ: for breach of contract, a notice of default is often needed first.

Can a Dutch company exclude all liability in its general terms?

A Dutch company can limit or exclude liability, but not without limits. A court sets the clause aside where relying on it is unacceptable under reasonableness and fairness (Article 6:248(2)), which will generally be the case for damage caused by intent or deliberate recklessness of the company or its management.

How long do you have to bring a liability claim under Dutch law?

A claim for damages is time-barred five years after the injured party became aware of both the damage and the liable person, and in any event twenty years after the event that caused the damage, with exceptions (Article 3:310(1) Dutch Civil Code). A written notice reserving the right can interrupt the period.

Does Dutch law award punitive damages?

As a rule no. Dutch liability law compensates loss actually suffered: financial loss, including lost profit, and other harm only where the law allows it (Articles 6:95 and 6:96 Dutch Civil Code). Compensation can be reduced if the injured party contributed to the damage (Article 6:101).

Primary sources

Dutch statutes are only officially available in Dutch, on wetten.overheid.nl. Judgments can be found on rechtspraak.nl by their ECLI number.

News & Insights
Which topics would you like to receive updates on?
Who are you?
Which industry or sector do you operate in? (Optional)