Published on · Last updated
Director liability in the Netherlands means that a director of a Dutch BV or NV pays a company debt or a loss from his own assets. The company is liable for its own debts; a director is personally liable only on a specific legal ground. If you face such a claim or want to bring one, have a Dutch lawyer assess the ground first: it decides your position and your defence.
What does Dutch law say about director’s liability?
Dutch law has three main routes to a director’s personal liability: a claim by the company for mismanagement, a creditor’s claim for a wrongful act, and the bankruptcy trustee’s claim for the shortfall in the estate, plus specific statutory rules for unpaid taxes and distributions.
Every director owes the company a proper performance of his duties, and each director is responsible for the general management of the company (Article 2:9 Dutch Civil Code). Not every mistake leads to liability. Towards the company, the director must be seriously blamed (Article 2:9). Towards third parties the threshold is high as well: primarily it is the company that acts, and the Supreme Court (Hoge Raad) does not want directors to let defensive considerations drive their decisions to an undesirable extent (HR 5 September 2014, ECLI:NL:HR:2014:2627, para. 4.2).
| Who claims | Legal basis | Test |
|---|---|---|
| The company (or the trustee on its behalf) | Article 2:9 Dutch Civil Code | The director can be seriously blamed for mismanagement |
| A creditor or other third party | Article 6:162 Dutch Civil Code (wrongful act) | The director can personally be seriously blamed |
| The bankruptcy trustee, for the estate | Article 2:248 (BV) or 2:138 (NV) Dutch Civil Code | Manifestly improper management, plausibly an important cause of the bankruptcy |
| The company (BV), after a distribution | Article 2:216(3) Dutch Civil Code | The director knew or should reasonably have foreseen that the BV could not keep paying its due debts |
| The tax collector | Article 36 Collection of State Taxes Act 1990 | Manifestly improper management attributable to the director |
When is a director internally liable?
Internal directors’ liability means that the company itself claims damages from its director. It requires improper performance of duties for which the director can be seriously blamed (in Dutch: ernstig verwijt), assessed in light of all circumstances of the case.
The basis is Article 2:9 Dutch Civil Code. Relevant circumstances include the nature of the company’s activities, the risks that generally follow from them, the division of tasks within the board, any guidelines for the board, the information the director had or should have had at the time of the decisions or conduct complained of, and the insight and care expected of a director who is equal to his task and performs it meticulously (HR 10 January 1997, ECLI:NL:HR:1997:ZC2243, para. 3.3.1).
Acting in breach of provisions of the articles of association that aim to protect the company is a weighty circumstance that in principle establishes liability. If the director puts forward facts showing that this does not amount to serious blame, the court must expressly consider them (HR 29 November 2002, ECLI:NL:HR:2002:AE7011, para. 3.4.5).
Liability is collective. Each director is liable for the whole damage, unless he cannot be seriously blamed, also in view of the duties assigned to others, and he was not negligent in taking measures to avert the consequences (Article 2:9(2)). If the company goes bankrupt, the trustee can bring this claim as well (Article 2:248(8)).
When can a creditor hold a director personally liable?
A creditor can hold a director of a Dutch company personally liable only if the director can personally be seriously blamed for the creditor’s loss. The starting point is that only the company is liable for its breach of contract or wrongful act.
The basis is a wrongful act (in Dutch: onrechtmatige daad, Article 6:162 Dutch Civil Code). The Supreme Court distinguishes two main situations (HR 8 December 2006, ECLI:NL:HR:2006:AZ0758, para. 3.5):
- Entering into an obligation. The director committed the company while he knew or should reasonably have understood that it could not perform and would offer no recourse. If the claim then remains unpaid and cannot be recovered, liability can be assumed, unless the director shows circumstances that rule out serious personal blame. This is the so-called Beklamel test: in essence, the director must have known or should reasonably have understood that the creditor would suffer damage as a result, and the mere fact that the company did not perform as agreed does not establish that (HR 5 September 2014, paras. 4.3–4.4).
- Causing or allowing a breach. The director caused or allowed the company not to perform its statutory or contractual obligations, and his conduct towards the creditor was so careless that he can personally be seriously blamed. Serious blame can in any event exist if he knew or should reasonably have understood that the company’s conduct would lead to it not performing and offering no recourse for the resulting damage. Other circumstances can also lead to serious personal blame.
The test applies to each director personally; there is no collective liability here. For a worked example, see our analysis of a case in which a supplier and its director were held jointly liable.
When is a director liable in bankruptcy?
In the bankruptcy of a BV, each director is jointly and severally liable to the estate for the shortfall if the board manifestly improperly performed its duties and this is plausibly an important cause of the bankruptcy. The bankruptcy itself is not a ground.
The rule is in Article 2:248(1) Dutch Civil Code; for the NV, Article 2:138 contains the same rules. Manifestly improper management (kennelijk onbehoorlijk bestuur) counts only in the three years before the bankruptcy (Article 2:248(6)). The trustee (curator) brings the claim for the estate, not an individual creditor.
If the board did not keep proper accounts (Article 2:10) or did not publish the annual accounts (Article 2:394), it performed its duties improperly, and it is presumed that this was an important cause of the bankruptcy. An insignificant omission is disregarded (Article 2:248(2)). The annual accounts must be published within eight days after their adoption, and in any case no later than twelve months after the end of the financial year (Article 2:394(1) and (3)).
A director escapes liability if he proves that the improper performance is not attributable to him and that he was not negligent in taking measures to avert its consequences (Article 2:248(3)). The court can reduce an excessive amount, also for a director in view of his time in office (Article 2:248(4)). A discharge does not block the trustee’s claim (Article 2:248(6)).
When is a director liable for tax debts?
Each director of a company subject to Dutch corporate income tax, such as a BV or NV, can be jointly and severally liable for its unpaid wage tax, VAT and certain other taxes. Much depends on a timely notice of inability to pay.
The company must notify the tax collector in writing without delay once it cannot pay these taxes (Article 36(2) Collection of State Taxes Act 1990, Invorderingswet 1990). With a correct notice, a director is liable only if the non-payment plausibly results from manifestly improper management attributable to him in the three years before the notice (Article 36(3)). Without a correct notice, it is presumed that the non-payment is attributable to him, and the three-year period starts when the company is in default. He can rebut that presumption only by making it plausible that the failure to notify is not attributable to him (Article 36(4)); this restriction does not apply to a former director (Article 36(6)). The rule also covers former directors for tax debts that arose during their term, de facto directors and, for a corporate director, each of its directors (Article 36(5)).
Does Dutch law apply to a foreign director or parent company?
Under Dutch private international law, Dutch law governs the liability of directors of a Dutch BV or NV towards the company, whatever their nationality or residence. A foreign parent company that acts as director, or runs the Dutch company in fact, can be liable too.
Under Article 10:118 Dutch Civil Code, a BV or NV with its registered seat in the Netherlands is governed by Dutch law. Before a Dutch court, that law also covers the liability of directors towards the company and the question who, because of a position such as director or shareholder, is liable alongside the company for acts that bind the company (Article 10:119(d) and (e)). Which law applies to a creditor’s claim for a wrongful act is a separate question; it depends on the facts and should be checked at the start. Which court can hear the claim is another question: according to the Court of Justice of the EU, a trustee’s claim that derives directly from the insolvency proceedings belongs before the courts of the Member State where they were opened, also against a director domiciled in a Lugano Convention State (CJEU 4 December 2014, C-295/13, H v H.K.).
Three rules matter for a foreign group:
- Corporate director. A foreign company that acts as director of the Dutch BV is liable as a director under Dutch law, because Dutch law governs the company it manages (HR 18 March 2011, ECLI:NL:HR:2011:BP1408, para. 4.1.3). Article 2:11 Dutch Civil Code passes that liability on to the corporate director’s own directors only if it is itself a Dutch legal entity (HR 21 June 2013, ECLI:NL:HR:2013:CA3958, para. 3.4). For a foreign corporate director, the law of that company decides. Its directors can still be liable in bankruptcy in their own right if they determined the policy of the Dutch BV as if they were director (Article 2:248(7)).
- De facto director. A person who determined or co-determined the policy of the company as if he were a director is treated as a director for bankruptcy liability (Article 2:248(7)) and for liability for distributions (Article 2:216(4)).
- Distributions. If a BV cannot keep paying its due debts after a distribution, the directors who knew or should reasonably have foreseen this when it was made are jointly and severally liable to the company for the shortfall, with statutory interest, unless a director proves that the distribution is not attributable to him and that he was not negligent in taking measures to avert its consequences (Article 2:216(3)). A shareholder who received it while he knew or should reasonably have foreseen this must repay the shortfall, up to the amount received, with statutory interest.
Have you received a letter from a Dutch trustee or creditor? Send it to me and I will tell you which ground is invoked and what your first step should be.
What should you do when you are held liable as a director?
Do not respond on the substance straight away. First establish the legal ground, the limitation position and the documents you need, then decide on a strategy. Each ground has its own test, and a hasty reply can weaken your defence.
Take these steps first:
- Identify the ground. Article 2:9, 6:162, 2:248 or Article 36 Collection of State Taxes Act 1990: the test, the burden of proof and the defences differ per ground.
- Check limitation. A claim for damages is time-barred five years after the claimant became aware of the damage and the liable person, and in any case twenty years after the event (Article 3:310(1)). Between a company and its directors, a limitation period that would expire during the directorship, or within six months after it ends, continues until six months after it ends (Article 3:320 and 3:321(1)(d)).
- Secure the records. Board minutes, accounts and correspondence: your defence rests on what you knew at the time, not on hindsight.
- Check any discharge. In a BV, adopting the annual accounts is not in itself a discharge (Article 2:210(3)), unless all shareholders are also directors and the accounts are adopted by being signed by all directors and supervisory directors (Article 2:210(5)). A discharge does not cover information that did not appear from the annual accounts and was not otherwise disclosed to the general meeting before it adopted the accounts (HR 10 January 1997, para. 3.4.1).
How can a director limit personal liability?
A director limits personal liability mainly by keeping the accounts and filings in order, by checking solvency before committing the company or approving a distribution, and by recording objections and the measures he takes.
- Before committing the company to a significant obligation, check whether it can perform and pay (HR 5 September 2014, para. 4.3). Before approving a distribution, check whether the BV can keep paying its due debts afterwards; the board may refuse approval only on that ground (Article 2:216(2)).
- If the company cannot pay wage tax or VAT, send the notice of inability to pay to the tax collector without delay (Article 36(2) Collection of State Taxes Act 1990).
- If you disagree with the board, record your objection and take measures: under Article 2:9(2) and 2:248(3), disagreeing alone does not exculpate you. Also observe the rules on a conflict of interest in a Dutch company.
Supervisory directors have their own regime. See our page on director and supervisory board liability in the Netherlands.
Practical example: a foreign parent and a trustee’s letter
Suppose a US group owns a Dutch distribution BV. The group’s European finance director is the BV’s only statutory director. The BV goes bankrupt, and the trustee writes that the annual accounts were filed late. He holds the director, and the parent as de facto director, liable for the shortfall under Article 2:248.
In a case like this, I would first check the dates: was the filing late under Article 2:394 (eight days after adoption, at the latest twelve months after the financial year) within the three-year period, and was the delay more than insignificant? Next come the facts that rebut the presumed causal link, and for the parent whether it really determined the BV’s policy as if it were director (Article 2:248(7)).
When do you need a Dutch lawyer for director liability?
You need a Dutch lawyer as soon as a trustee, creditor, the company or the tax collector holds you personally liable, or when you want to hold a director liable yourself. The first reply can fix the positions for the rest of the case.
How do we handle a director liability case?
We can assist directors, foreign parent companies and creditors. First I review the claim, the legal ground and limitation, and tell you which documents to secure. Then follows a substantiated reply to the trustee or creditor, aimed at a settlement where that serves you, and if needed proceedings before the Dutch courts in first instance and on appeal.
More on our Dutch corporate law attorneys and on corporate litigation in the Netherlands.
Are you held liable as a director of a Dutch company, or do you want to hold a director liable? Put your situation to me and I will tell you which ground applies and what the next step should be.
Frequently asked questions about director liability in the Netherlands
Is a director personally liable for the debts of a Dutch BV?
Not as such. A director is personally liable only on a specific ground: serious blame towards the company (Article 2:9 Dutch Civil Code), serious personal blame towards a creditor (Article 6:162), manifestly improper management in bankruptcy (Article 2:248), a distribution after which the BV cannot pay its due debts (Article 2:216(3)), or certain unpaid taxes (Article 36 Collection of State Taxes Act 1990).
What is internal directors’ liability?
It is the liability of a director towards the company itself. The company, or in bankruptcy the trustee, claims under Article 2:9 Dutch Civil Code; the director must be seriously blamed for improper performance of his duties.
Are shareholders liable for the debts of a Dutch company?
In principle not. A shareholder of a BV or NV is not personally liable for what is done in the name of the company (Articles 2:175(1) and 2:64(1) Dutch Civil Code). Exceptions include receiving a distribution while knowing, or when one should reasonably have foreseen, that the BV could no longer pay its due debts (Article 2:216(3)), acting as a de facto director (Article 2:248(7)) and committing a wrongful act himself.
Does resigning as a director end your liability?
Not for what happened while you were in office. In bankruptcy, the trustee can rely on improper management in the three years before the bankruptcy (Article 2:248(6) Dutch Civil Code), and a former director remains liable for tax debts that arose while he was in office (Article 36(5)(a) Collection of State Taxes Act 1990).
When should I contact a Dutch lawyer about director liability?
When you receive a liability letter from a trustee, creditor or the tax collector, before you reply on the substance. MAAK Advocaten in Amsterdam can assist directors, foreign parent companies and creditors, in negotiations and in proceedings.
Primary sources
- Dutch Civil Code Book 2: Article 2:9, Article 2:10, Article 2:11, Article 2:64, Article 2:138, Article 2:175, Article 2:210, Article 2:216, Article 2:248 and Article 2:394
- Dutch Civil Code Book 3: Article 3:310, Article 3:320 and Article 3:321
- Dutch Civil Code Book 6: Article 6:162
- Dutch Civil Code Book 10: Article 10:118 and Article 10:119
- Collection of State Taxes Act 1990 (Invorderingswet 1990), Article 36
- HR 10 January 1997, ECLI:NL:HR:1997:ZC2243
- HR 29 November 2002, ECLI:NL:HR:2002:AE7011
- HR 8 December 2006, ECLI:NL:HR:2006:AZ0758 (Ontvanger/Roelofsen)
- HR 18 March 2011, ECLI:NL:HR:2011:BP1408
- HR 21 June 2013, ECLI:NL:HR:2013:CA3958
- HR 5 September 2014, ECLI:NL:HR:2014:2627
- CJEU 4 December 2014, C-295/13, H v H.K. (ECLI:EU:C:2014:2410)