Conflict of Interest in a Dutch Company

Share this article

WhatsAppLinkedIn

Published on · Last updated

Under Dutch law, a director of a BV or NV has a conflict of interest (tegenstrijdig belang) if he or she has a direct or indirect personal interest that conflicts with the interest of the company and its business. That director may not take part in the board’s deliberations and decision-making (Article 2:239(6) Dutch Civil Code for the BV; Article 2:129(6) for the NV). Our team also advises on Corporate law in the Netherlands.

If, as a result, the board cannot adopt a resolution, the supervisory board (raad van commissarissen) decides. If there is no supervisory board, the general meeting decides, unless the articles of association provide otherwise. Since 1 January 2013 the rule only concerns internal decision-making: the former rules under which commissioners represented the company in case of a conflict (former Articles 2:146 and 2:256 DCC) were repealed. A director who ignores the rule may be liable towards the company if he or she can be seriously blamed (Article 2:9 DCC).

The same rule applies to supervisory directors (Article 2:250(5) DCC for the BV; Article 2:140(5) for the NV): if the supervisory board cannot adopt a resolution as a result, the general meeting decides, unless the articles provide otherwise. Handling conflicts properly matters, because it affects both the validity of resolutions and your personal liability as a director.

What are the key takeaways?

  • Dutch Civil Code regulates conflicts of interest: Rules prioritize company interests over directors’ personal benefits.
  • Directors with a conflicting personal interest may not take part in deliberations and decision-making on that matter (Article 2:239(6) DCC).
  • Collective responsibility for ethical standards: Uphold ethical standards to protect company and director interests.
  • Breach can make the board resolution voidable (Article 2:15 DCC) and can lead to liability towards the company if the director can be seriously blamed (Article 2:9 DCC).
  • Disclosure: the Civil Code has no explicit disclosure duty, but a conflicted director should inform the board so that the rule can be applied; the articles or board regulations may require this.

How does Dutch law regulate conflicting interests?

The Dutch Civil Code regulates conflicts of interest for directors of both private limited companies (BVs) and public limited companies (NVs). The rule protects the duty of every director to act in the interest of the company and its business (Article 2:239(5) DCC; Article 2:129(5) for the NV), rather than for personal benefits.

This is an essential provision, as directors hold significant decision-making power and can impact the company’s success.

When a director has a direct or indirect personal interest that conflicts with the interest of the company and its business, he or she must abstain from participating in the board’s deliberations and decision-making on that matter. The other directors then decide without him or her.

If no board resolution can be adopted as a result, for example because the company has a sole director or all directors are conflicted, the Supervisory Board decides. Without a supervisory board, the General Meeting decides, unless the articles of association provide otherwise (Article 2:239(6) DCC).

When directors fail to abide by these rules, there can be serious legal consequences. A resolution adopted in breach of the rule can be annulled by the court as a breach of a statutory provision on how resolutions are adopted (Article 2:15(1)(a) DCC). The right to claim annulment lapses one year after the resolution was sufficiently made known or the interested party became aware of it (Article 2:15(5)). A director may also be liable towards the company for improper performance of duties, but only if he or she can be seriously blamed (Article 2:9 DCC; HR 10 January 1997, ECLI:NL:HR:1997:ZC2243, r.o. 3.3.1).

Ensuring compliance with these regulations is vital to maintaining the integrity and credibility of your company.

How do you manage a personal conflict of interest?

Managing Conflicting Personal Interests

To manage conflicting personal interests effectively, you must be able to identify and address any potential conflicts of interest swiftly and transparently. As a director in a Dutch company, understanding when your personal interests conflict with the company’s is vital to guarantee impartial decision-making. Personal interests can create conflicts, so it is essential to recognize these interests to safeguard the company’s best interests.

Decision Making with Conflicts of Interest

ScenarioConsequence
Director has conflicting personal interestDirector must abstain from decision-making
No board resolution can be adopted (e.g. sole director or all directors conflicted)Supervisory board decides; without one, the general meeting, unless the articles provide otherwise
Resolution adopted in breach of the ruleResolution voidable (Art. 2:15 DCC); director liable towards the company only if seriously to blame (Art. 2:9 DCC)

In a Dutch BV, the management board represents the company (Dutch Civil Code, Article 2:240). That power of representation is unlimited and unconditional, except where the law provides otherwise (Article 2:240(3); Article 2:130(3) for the NV), and a conflict of interest does not take it away. The conflicted director must, however, stay out of the internal decision. Breaching the rule does not as such make the director liable for the company’s debts; liability towards the company requires serious blame (Article 2:9 DCC).

When does a conflict of interest arise?

When conflicts of interest do arise, identifying and addressing them swiftly is essential to protect both the company and directors from potential legal and reputational consequences.

As a director in a Dutch company, you have a vital role in ensuring that your personal interests don’t interfere with those of the company. Under Article 2:239(6) of the Dutch Civil Code, you have a conflict of interest if you have a direct or indirect personal interest that conflicts with the interest of the company and its business. The statute does not define this further. Under the former rule, the Dutch Supreme Court held that the director must be able to protect the company’s interest as may be expected of an honest and impartial director. It is not required that the company is actually harmed: it is enough that the director has such incompatible interests that it can reasonably be doubted whether he or she was guided solely by the interest of the company, judged on all circumstances of the case (HR 29 June 2007, ECLI:NL:HR:2007:BA0033, known as Bruil, r.o. 3.4).

When a conflict arises, the director must not take part in deliberations and decision-making (Article 2:239(6) DCC). The Bruil test only answers whether a conflict exists; the consequence follows from the statute. If no board resolution can then be adopted, the supervisory board decides or, without one, the general meeting, unless the articles provide otherwise.

Here are key points to keep in mind:

  • Identifying conflicts: Be aware of any personal interest that may clash with the company’s interests.
  • Reporting conflicts: the Civil Code contains no explicit duty to report a conflict, but you should inform your co-directors (and, where relevant, the supervisory board) so that the rule can be applied. The articles of association or board regulations may contain a reporting duty.
  • Abstention and escalation: If a conflict exists, the conflicted board member must refrain from deliberations and decision-making, and the decision may be passed to the supervisory board or General Meeting.
  • Consequences of violation: a resolution adopted in breach of the rule is voidable (Article 2:15 DCC), and a director who can be seriously blamed may be liable towards the company (Article 2:9 DCC).
  • Conflicting roles: holding a position at the other party (for example as director or shareholder of the counterparty) can create a conflict, but not automatically. The statute requires a personal interest, and whether a conflict exists depends on all circumstances of the case (Bruil, r.o. 3.4-3.5).

What is the internal effect of the rule?

The internal decision-making processes are greatly influenced by conflict management within the company. This regulation enhances the importance of ethical standards that directors must uphold, ensuring that the interests of the company override personal interests.

If a conflict arises, it’s essential for directors to disclose this information to the management board. This transparency guarantees that the company acts with integrity and prevents decisions that could be harmful to its interests.

Dutch law also provides mechanisms to handle conflicts of interest. If the board cannot decide because of a conflict, the decision moves to the supervisory board or, without one, to the general meeting, unless the articles provide otherwise. A resolution adopted in breach of the rule is voidable (Article 2:15(1)(a) DCC). Whether the company is bound towards a third party is a separate question: the board’s power to represent the company is unlimited unless the law provides otherwise (Article 2:240(3) DCC).

The internal impact of conflict management can’t be overstated. It highlights that upholding ethical standards is a collective responsibility within the company, and any failure to do so can have significant consequences.

As a director, it’s vital to prioritize transparency and disclosure to maintain the trust and integrity of your organization.

What are the consequences of a breach?

Violating conflict of interest regulations can trigger significant legal consequences, potentially exposing directors to liability and undermining the integrity of decision-making processes.

If you, as a director in a Dutch company, violate conflict of interest regulations, you may face severe legal repercussions. Here are the potential consequences:

  • Annulment of resolutions: a board resolution adopted in breach of the rule is voidable. The court annuls it on a claim that must be brought within one year (Article 2:15(3) and (5) DCC).
  • Directors’ liability: you can be liable towards the company for improper performance of duties if you can be seriously blamed (Article 2:9 DCC). Taking part in a decision despite a conflict is one of the circumstances in that assessment.
  • Shareholders: liability under Article 2:9 DCC is owed to the company, not to individual shareholders. Where there is no supervisory board, the general meeting takes the decision that the board could not take, unless the articles provide otherwise.
  • Supervisory board: if, as a result of a conflict, no board resolution can be adopted, the supervisory board decides; without one, the general meeting, unless the articles provide otherwise.
  • Transparency: the Civil Code does not prescribe disclosure to the general meeting. Recording the conflict and the abstention in the board minutes helps to show that the rule was observed.

These legal consequences emphasize the need for diligence in managing conflicts of interest and ensuring ethical decision-making practices in Dutch companies.

Which disclosure and abstention duties apply?

The Civil Code contains no explicit duty for a Dutch company director to disclose a conflict of interest. In practice, however, the board can only apply the abstention rule if the conflicted director reports the conflict. The articles of association, board regulations or a corporate governance code that applies to the company may impose a duty of disclosure.

Disclose direct or indirect personal interests promptly. Failing to do so can contribute to a finding of improper performance of duties (Article 2:9 DCC).

If the conflict exists, abstention from decision-making processes on that matter is mandatory (Article 2:239(6) DCC; Article 2:129(6) for the NV). Supervisory directors must likewise abstain (Articles 2:250(5) and 2:140(5) DCC).

Conclusion

In a Dutch company, you must take conflict of interest seriously. The law demands you prioritize the company’s interests over personal benefits. Failure to comply can lead to serious legal consequences.

Remember to identify and address conflicts promptly, abstain from decision-making when conflicts arise, and leave the decision to the Supervisory Board or General Meeting if the board cannot decide without you.

Frequently asked questions about conflicts of interest in a Dutch company

What does conflict of interest mean under Dutch company law?

A director has a conflict of interest (tegenstrijdig belang) if he or she has a direct or indirect personal interest that conflicts with the interest of the company and its business (Article 2:239(6) DCC for the BV; Article 2:129(6) for the NV). Under the Supreme Court’s Bruil test, it is enough that it can reasonably be doubted whether the director was guided solely by the company’s interest.

What does Article 2:239(6) of the Dutch Civil Code say?

A BV director does not take part in the deliberations and decision-making if he or she has a conflicting direct or indirect personal interest. If, as a result, no board resolution can be adopted, the supervisory board decides; without a supervisory board, the general meeting decides, unless the articles provide otherwise. Article 2:129(6) contains the same rule for the NV.

What are examples of a director’s conflict of interest?

Typical examples are a contract between the company and the director personally, or between the company and another company in which the director has a significant stake. In the Bruil case, the director was director and major shareholder of both the buying and the selling company; the Supreme Court held that a conflict can exist in such a case, depending on the circumstances.

How can a company prevent conflicts of interest?

Identify possible conflicts early, ask directors to report them, and record the conflict and the abstention in the board minutes. If there is no supervisory board, the articles of association can provide that someone other than the general meeting decides when the board cannot (Article 2:239(6) DCC). For a BV with a sole director, the decision moves to the supervisory board or, without one, the general meeting, unless the articles provide otherwise.

Does the conflict-of-interest rule apply to shareholders?

No. The rule applies to directors (Articles 2:129(6) and 2:239(6) DCC) and supervisory directors (Articles 2:140(5) and 2:250(5)). Book 2 of the Dutch Civil Code has no comparable rule for shareholders voting at the general meeting. Shareholders and the company must, however, behave towards each other as required by reasonableness and fairness (Article 2:8 DCC).

Primary sources

Dutch law firm specialized in conflicts of interest

For any legal inquiries or support in the Netherlands regarding a conflict of interest under Dutch law, please feel free to contact our adept team at MAAK Advocaten.

News & Insights
Which topics would you like to receive updates on?
Who are you?
Which industry or sector do you operate in? (Optional)