Published on · Last updated
Corporate litigation in the Netherlands covers disputes between shareholders, directors and the company. The main routes are the inquiry procedure (enquête, Article 2:345 Dutch Civil Code) and the statutory buy-out procedures (Articles 2:336a and 2:343) before the Enterprise Chamber in Amsterdam, director liability claims (Article 2:9) and actions to annul corporate resolutions (Article 2:15).
For the wider framework, see Dutch corporate law. Our Dutch corporate attorney explains the most important aspects below. Our team also advises on ultra vires Dutch corporate law.
Key Takeaways
- Corporate litigation in the Netherlands requires a sound understanding of Dutch corporate law (Book 2 of the Dutch Civil Code in particular) and Dutch procedural law (Wetboek van Burgerlijke Rechtsvordering).
- The Enterprise Chamber in Amsterdam decides inquiry proceedings (Article 2:345 DCC) and, since 1 January 2025, the statutory buy-out procedures between shareholders (Articles 2:336a and 2:343 DCC).
- Director’s liability under Dutch law towards the company requires that the director can be seriously blamed for improper management (Article 2:9(2) DCC).
- Legal advice under Dutch law before proceedings helps you choose the right route: inquiry, buy-out, a liability claim or annulment of a resolution.
- Resolutions of company bodies can be void (Article 2:14 DCC) or voidable (Article 2:15 DCC); the right to claim annulment lapses one year after the end of the day on which sufficient publicity was given to the resolution, or on which the interested party took note of it or was informed of it (Article 2:15(5)).
What is corporate litigation under Dutch law?
Corporate litigation in the Netherlands involves legal disputes arising within the area of company law and procedural law. These disputes in the Netherlands can range from post-M&A disagreements to joint venture conflicts, Dutch shareholder disputes, and director’s liability under Dutch law.
At its core, corporate litigation addresses conflicts about how a company is run and who controls it. In the Netherlands, legal representation is a fundamental aspect of corporate litigation. Parties can also agree to submit existing or future disputes to arbitration (Article 1020(1) Rv); the articles of association or an agreement can do this for the statutory buy-out disputes as well (Article 2:337(2) DCC). We regularly assist clients with Corporate Power of Attorney in the Netherlands.
How are commercial disputes addressed?
Commercial disputes are a prevalent issue in the business world, requiring swift and effective resolution. Our Dutch litigation attorneys at MAAK Advocaten specialize in handling a wide range of commercial litigation matters, ensuring that our clients receive detailed legal support suited to their specific needs.
Which role does procedural law play?
Procedural law in the Netherlands determines how a corporate dispute reaches the court. Proceedings before the Enterprise Chamber, such as an inquiry or a buy-out, start with a written petition (verzoekschrift) (Articles 2:345(1) and 2:336a(1) DCC). In an inquiry, the applicants and the company appear through a lawyer (Article 2:349a(1) DCC).
Other corporate disputes, such as an action to annul a resolution, are claims (vorderingen) before the district court (Article 2:15(3) DCC). In urgent cases, the preliminary relief judge can grant an immediate provisional measure (Article 254(1) Rv).
Which disputes does corporate litigation cover?
Often, corporate litigation under Dutch law encompasses a wide array of disputes, including directors’ liability issues, conflicts within groups, and disagreements over takeovers.
Many of these disputes concern directors. Every director must perform his or her duties properly towards the company (Article 2:9(1) DCC). A director is liable for improper management, unless, taking into account the duties assigned to others, he or she cannot be seriously blamed and was not negligent in taking measures to avert the consequences (Article 2:9(2) DCC). Whether a serious reproach can be made depends on all circumstances of the case (Supreme Court (Hoge Raad) 10 January 1997, ECLI:NL:HR:1997:ZC2243 (Staleman/Van de Ven), para. 3.3.1).
A special feature of the Dutch system is the Enterprise Chamber (Ondernemingskamer) of the Amsterdam Court of Appeal. It decides inquiry proceedings (Article 2:345 DCC) and the statutory buy-out procedures (Articles 2:336a and 2:343 DCC). Other corporate disputes, such as liability claims and actions to annul resolutions, go to the ordinary civil courts.
What characterises the Dutch legal environment?
Understanding the Dutch legal environment, which includes civil, administrative, and criminal courts, is key to successfully managing corporate litigation in the Netherlands. This legal framework is varied, with each court playing a distinct role in corporate law enforcement.
Disputes between companies, shareholders and directors are civil cases for the civil courts. Administrative courts, such as the Trade and Industry Appeals Tribunal (College van Beroep voor het bedrijfsleven), decide appeals against decisions of public authorities, not civil disputes between companies.
Companies can also resolve disagreements through arbitration or mediation. Arbitration is regulated in Book 4 of the Dutch Code of Civil Procedure: parties can agree to submit disputes arising from a particular legal relationship to arbitration (Article 1020(1) and (2) Rv).
For international disputes, parties can agree to litigate in English before the Netherlands Commercial Court (NCC), the international commercial chamber of the Amsterdam District Court, or the Netherlands Commercial Court of Appeal. This requires that the Amsterdam District Court or the Amsterdam Court of Appeal has jurisdiction, that the dispute is international and arises from a particular legal relationship that is at the free disposal of the parties, and that the parties have expressly agreed to it; the agreement is proven by a document (geschrift). It does not apply to cases for the cantonal judge (Article 32a(1) Rv).
In essence, the Dutch legal environment is a complex and evolving system that offers multiple avenues for dispute resolution. Its understanding is crucial for any entity engaged in corporate litigation in the Netherlands.
Which parts of the Civil Code matter here?
Book 2 of the Dutch Civil Code (DCC) contains the rules that most corporate disputes turn on:
- Reasonableness and fairness: the company and those involved in its organisation must behave towards each other as reasonableness and fairness require (Article 2:8 DCC).
- Director liability: towards the company (Article 2:9 DCC) and, in bankruptcy, towards the estate (Article 2:248 DCC for the BV).
- Resolutions: void resolutions (Article 2:14 DCC) and voidable resolutions (Article 2:15 DCC).
- Dispute settlement: squeeze-out and exit of shareholders in a BV or NV (Articles 2:336-2:343c DCC).
- Inquiry: the right of inquiry before the Enterprise Chamber (Articles 2:344-2:359 DCC).
The dispute-settlement procedures were changed with effect from 1 January 2025 (Stb. 2024, 175): they now start with a petition to the Enterprise Chamber, which, if it grants the request, as a rule appoints experts to report on the price of the shares (Article 2:339(1) DCC).
Understanding the Dutch civil code is key to addressing the complexities of shareholder buy-out procedures. It provides the framework within which corporate disputes are managed and resolved, reinforcing the efficiency and fairness of Dutch corporate law. So, as you look further into this field, you’ll appreciate the critical role this code plays in structuring corporate litigation in the Netherlands.
What does the Enterprise Chamber do?
Diving into the heart of corporate litigation in Amsterdam, you’ll find the Enterprise Chamber in Amsterdam playing a central role, wielding exclusive jurisdiction over various corporate proceedings.
As a division of the Amsterdam Court of Appeal, it’s a key player in resolving corporate disputes, particularly in high-stakes and complex cases.
A Dutch corporate lawyer, especially from a specialist firm like MAAK Advocaten, is often involved, providing expert guidance and representation in such intricate corporate legal matters. These matters might involve a variety of disputes between corporations, shareholders, and corporate bodies, where the expertise of the Enterprise Chamber comes into play.
Among the key proceedings that the Enterprise Chamber handles are shareholder buy-out procedures. If it grants the request, it appoints one or more experts to report on the price (Article 2:339(1) DCC), unless the parties agree on the valuation of the shares, or the articles or an agreement contain a clear valuation standard from which it can readily set the price (Article 2:339(3) DCC); it then sets the price in the decision that grants the request (Article 2:340(2) DCC). Where experts were appointed, it sets the price of the shares after their report (Article 2:340(1) DCC). It does not apply valuation rules in the articles or an agreement to the extent that this would lead to a manifestly unreasonable price (Article 2:340(3) DCC). In inquiry proceedings, a cassation appeal to the Supreme Court is possible against its decisions (Article 2:359(1) DCC).
The Enterprise Chamber is not simply a legal entity. It’s a crucial component of the corporate litigation field in Amsterdam, ensuring that all legal proceedings are conducted in a fair, systematic, and precise manner.
How does the inquiry procedure (enquête) work?
In an inquiry, the Enterprise Chamber appoints one or more persons to investigate the policy and the conduct of affairs (beleid en gang van zaken) of a legal entity, in full or for a part or a specific period (Article 2:345(1) DCC). The procedure applies to the BV, the NV, the cooperative and the mutual insurance society, and to foundations and associations with full legal capacity that run an enterprise for which a works council must be set up (Article 2:344 DCC). The Enterprise Chamber only grants the request if there are well-founded reasons to doubt a correct policy or a correct conduct of affairs (Article 2:350(1) DCC).
For a BV or NV, the request can be made by shareholders or holders of depositary receipts who alone or together represent at least one tenth of the issued capital, or shares with a nominal value of € 225,000, if the issued capital is at most € 22.5 million; at least one hundredth if it is higher; and for listed companies at least one hundredth or a value of € 20 million at the closing price on the last trading day before the request. The articles can set lower thresholds. The company itself and persons to whom the articles or an agreement with the company grant this right can also file the request (Article 2:346(1) DCC), as can certain trade unions (Article 2:347 DCC) and the Advocate General for reasons of public interest (Article 2:345(2) DCC).
Before filing, the applicants must have made their objections to the policy or the conduct of affairs known in writing to the board and the supervisory board, and so much time must have passed that the company reasonably had the opportunity to investigate them and take measures (Article 2:349(1) DCC). This requirement does not apply if the company itself files the request. If immediate action is needed given the state of the company or in the interest of the investigation, the Enterprise Chamber can, at the request of the applicants, take an immediate measure at any stage, for at most the duration of the proceedings; if no inquiry has been ordered yet, only if there are, in its provisional view, well-founded reasons to doubt a correct policy (Article 2:349a(2) and (3) DCC).
These commercial or corporate inquiry cases can have far-reaching consequences. If the investigators’ report shows mismanagement (wanbeleid), the Enterprise Chamber can, on a request made within two months after the report was filed (Article 2:355 DCC), suspend or annul resolutions, suspend or dismiss directors or supervisory directors, temporarily appoint directors or supervisory directors, temporarily deviate from the articles, temporarily transfer shares for management purposes, or dissolve the legal entity (Article 2:356 DCC).
How does a shareholder buy-out work?
The statutory dispute-settlement rules apply to the BV and the NV, unless their shares or depositary receipts are admitted to trading on a regulated market or a multilateral trading facility (Article 2:336 DCC). They offer two routes:
- Squeeze-out (uitstoting): one or more shareholders who alone or together provide at least one third of the issued capital can ask the Enterprise Chamber to order a shareholder to transfer its shares, if that shareholder’s conduct has harmed the company’s interests to such an extent that its continued shareholding cannot reasonably be tolerated (Article 2:336a(1) DCC).
- Exit (uittreding): a shareholder whose rights or interests are harmed by the conduct of one or more fellow shareholders to such an extent that continuing as a shareholder can no longer reasonably be required, can ask the Enterprise Chamber to order them to take over its shares. The shareholder can also ask for an order that the company takes over the shares, except to the extent that the rules on the company acquiring its own shares stand in the way (Article 2:343(1) DCC).
Once the petition has been served, the defendant cannot transfer or pledge its shares or create a usufruct on them until the decision is final, unless the applicants consent; if they refuse, the Enterprise Chamber can, at the defendant’s request, grant permission if the defendant has a reasonable interest in the transaction (Article 2:338(1) DCC). In an exit case, the Enterprise Chamber can, on request, apply a fair increase to the price if it is plausible that conduct of the defendant or others reduced the value of the shares and that reduction should not, or not fully, be borne by the applicant (Article 2:343(3) DCC). A shareholders’ agreement or the articles can contain their own dispute-settlement rules, but a deviation cannot be relied on to the extent that it makes the transfer of shares impossible or extremely difficult (Article 2:337(1) DCC). Before 1 January 2025, these cases started with a writ of summons. The old rules continue to apply to cases in which the writ of summons was validly served before that date (Article III(1) of the Act of 5 June 2024, Stb. 2024, 174).
Understanding the dynamics of shareholder buy-outs is vital. They can drastically impact the balance of power within a firm, and therefore, the strategic direction it may take. As a majority or minority shareholder, being knowledgeable about your rights and the procedures involved is essential. MAAK lawyers, with their in-depth knowledge of the Dutch Civil Code, provide crucial guidance in these complex legal matters, offering expert representation to work through the labyrinth of shareholder buy-outs under Dutch law.
Which legal entities can you choose?
When setting up a business in the Netherlands, you’ll encounter various legal entities such as private limited companies (BV), public limited companies (NV), partnerships (VOF), and branches of foreign companies, each offering unique advantages and considerations.
The BV and the NV have legal personality (Article 2:3 DCC). In both, a shareholder is not personally liable for what is done in the company’s name and does not have to contribute to losses beyond what must be paid up on its shares (Article 2:175(1) and Article 2:64(1) DCC). For the BV, this is without prejudice to obligations that the articles can attach to shareholdership under Article 2:192 DCC (Article 2:175(1) DCC). The shares of a BV are registered shares (Article 2:175(1) DCC).
In a general partnership (VOF), each partner is jointly and severally liable for the partnership’s obligations (Article 18 Dutch Commercial Code). For litigation, the legal form matters: the statutory buy-out rules only apply to unlisted BVs and NVs (Article 2:336 DCC), and the inquiry procedure applies to the entities listed in Article 2:344 DCC.
Lastly, branches of foreign companies operate in the Netherlands as extensions of their parent companies, subject to Dutch laws and regulations. Legal services are often required to handle these complexities. Understanding these business structures and their legal implications is crucial for making informed decisions about your business setup in the Netherlands.
How does Dutch corporate governance work?
Corporate governance in the Netherlands is rooted in Book 2 of the Dutch Civil Code. For listed companies, the Dutch Corporate Governance Code adds principles and best practices.
Within the company, a general standard applies: the company and everyone involved in its organisation under the law and the articles must behave towards each other as reasonableness and fairness require. A rule that applies between them does not apply to the extent that this would be unacceptable in the circumstances by standards of reasonableness and fairness (Article 2:8 DCC). Many governance disputes go to the ordinary courts; the Enterprise Chamber decides inquiry and buy-out cases.
Legal updates are regularly made to keep the system solid and relevant. These amendments reflect the fast-changing nature of corporate governance, continually adjusting to the evolving business framework. You, as a shareholder, have rights and obligations defined both by law and by your company’s statutes.
If you find yourself needing legal assistance, firms like MAAK Advocaten can guide you through the complexities of Dutch corporate governance. Their expertise in corporate litigation can provide essential support during legal challenges, making them a reliable choice in this sphere. So, in the Netherlands, corporate governance covers both managing companies and ensuring fairness and accountability.
When is a director liable?
Under Dutch law, as a director, you can be held personally liable as a director in three main situations:
- Towards the company: for improper management, unless you cannot be seriously blamed and were not negligent in taking measures to avert the consequences (Article 2:9(2) DCC; Supreme Court (Hoge Raad) 10 January 1997, ECLI:NL:HR:1997:ZC2243 (Staleman/Van de Ven), para. 3.3.1).
- In bankruptcy of a BV: towards the estate for the deficit, if the board manifestly performed its duties improperly and it is plausible that this was an important cause of the bankruptcy (Article 2:248(1) DCC).
- Towards third parties: under tort law (Article 6:162 DCC), but only if the director can personally be seriously blamed for the harm; the threshold is higher than usual (Supreme Court 5 September 2014, ECLI:NL:HR:2014:2627, para. 4.2).
Keep this in mind:
- Legal expertise: A sound understanding of the Netherlands’ corporate laws is mandatory. You should be aware of your responsibilities and liabilities as a director.
- Legal support: You can protect yourself from potential liabilities by seeking support from legal professionals. They can guide you through complex legal landscapes, ensuring compliance with Dutch law.
- Which court: liability claims against directors are decided by the civil courts. An inquiry before the Enterprise Chamber is a separate procedure; it can lead to measures such as the suspension or dismissal of directors (Article 2:356 DCC), but not to an order to pay damages.
- Mismanagement: not every mistake leads to personal liability. The thresholds are high: a serious reproach towards the company or third parties, and manifestly improper performance in bankruptcy (Article 2:248(1) DCC). In bankruptcy, however, the board has performed its duties improperly, and this is presumed to be an important cause of the bankruptcy, if it did not comply with its bookkeeping obligations (Article 2:10 DCC) or its obligation to publish the annual accounts (Article 2:394 DCC); an unimportant failure is disregarded (Article 2:248(2) DCC). Document your decisions and how you reached them.
How can you challenge a corporate resolution?
A resolution of a company body that conflicts with the law or the articles of association is void (nietig), unless the law provides otherwise (Article 2:14(1) DCC). A resolution is voidable (vernietigbaar) if it conflicts with the statutory or articles provisions on how resolutions are adopted, with the reasonableness and fairness required by Article 2:8, or with internal regulations (Article 2:15(1) DCC).
Annulment is pronounced by the district court of the place where the company is domiciled, on a claim against the company by someone with a reasonable interest in compliance with the obligation that was not met, or on a claim of the company itself against a person appointed by the preliminary relief judge (Article 2:15(3) DCC). The right to claim annulment lapses one year after the end of the day on which sufficient publicity was given to the resolution, or on which the interested party took note of it or was informed of it (Article 2:15(5) DCC). In inquiry proceedings, the Enterprise Chamber can also suspend or annul a resolution as a measure (Article 2:356(a) DCC).
Which court decides which corporate dispute?
Which court decides depends on the type of dispute:
- Enterprise Chamber: inquiry proceedings (Article 2:345 DCC), squeeze-out and exit (Articles 2:336a and 2:343 DCC), and a request to set the price of shares where the parties have agreed on a transfer (Article 2:343c DCC).
- District court: actions to annul resolutions (Article 2:15(3) DCC) and, as a rule, other civil claims, such as liability claims against directors. Outside cases for the cantonal judge, you need a lawyer (Article 79(2) Rv); in summary proceedings, the defendant can also act in person (Article 255(1) Rv).
- Preliminary relief judge: urgent provisional measures in summary proceedings (kort geding) (Article 254(1) Rv).
- Netherlands Commercial Court: international disputes in English, if the parties have expressly agreed to this (Article 32a Rv).
- Arbitration: if the parties have agreed to it (Article 1020 Rv), including for the statutory buy-out disputes (Article 2:337(2) DCC).
Choosing the wrong route costs time and money, so assess the route before you start.
Legal Advice and Consultancy Services in the Netherlands
When you’re dealing with corporate litigation in the Netherlands, it’s crucial to have expert legal advice and consultancy services on your side, like offered by our Dutch law firm.
Our Dutch corporate attorneys have a keen understanding of the intricate corporate law environment and can provide you with the necessary support and guidance.
Frequently asked questions about corporate litigation in the Netherlands
What does the Enterprise Chamber in Amsterdam decide?
The Enterprise Chamber (Ondernemingskamer) of the Amsterdam Court of Appeal decides, among other things, inquiry proceedings into the policy and conduct of affairs of a legal entity (Article 2:345 DCC) and the statutory buy-out procedures between shareholders of unlisted BVs and NVs (Articles 2:336-2:343c DCC). Liability claims and actions to annul resolutions go to the ordinary courts.
Who can request an inquiry (enquête) in the Netherlands?
For a BV or NV with issued capital of at most € 22.5 million: shareholders or holders of depositary receipts with at least one tenth of the issued capital or a nominal value of € 225,000; above € 22.5 million: one hundredth; for listed companies: one hundredth or € 20 million in market value, or lower if the articles say so. The company itself, persons granted the right by the articles or an agreement with the company, certain trade unions and the Advocate General can also file (Articles 2:345-2:347 DCC). Written objections must be raised first (Article 2:349(1)).
How can a shareholder be forced out of a Dutch company?
Shareholders who together provide at least one third of the issued capital can ask the Enterprise Chamber to order a shareholder to transfer its shares, if that shareholder’s conduct has harmed the company so much that its continued shareholding cannot reasonably be tolerated (Article 2:336a(1) DCC). This applies to BVs and NVs whose shares are not listed (Article 2:336).
When is a director personally liable under Dutch law?
Towards the company, for improper management if the director can be seriously blamed (Article 2:9(2) DCC). In bankruptcy of a BV, towards the estate if the board manifestly performed its duties improperly and this is plausibly an important cause of the bankruptcy (Article 2:248(1)). Towards third parties, only if the director can personally be seriously blamed (HR 5 September 2014, ECLI:NL:HR:2014:2627, para. 4.2).
How long do you have to challenge a shareholders’ resolution?
An action to annul a voidable resolution must be brought within one year after the end of the day on which sufficient publicity was given to the resolution, or on which you took note of it or were informed of it (Article 2:15(5) DCC). A resolution that conflicts with the law or the articles is void, unless the law provides otherwise (Article 2:14(1) DCC); the one-year period of Article 2:15(5) applies to annulment of voidable resolutions.
Primary sources
- Dutch Civil Code (Burgerlijk Wetboek), Book 2: Articles 2:3, 2:8, 2:9, 2:10, 2:14, 2:15, 2:64, 2:175, 2:192, 2:248, 2:336, 2:336a, 2:337, 2:338, 2:339, 2:340, 2:343, 2:343c, 2:344, 2:345, 2:346, 2:347, 2:349, 2:349a, 2:350, 2:355, 2:356, 2:359 and 2:394
- Dutch Civil Code, Book 6: Article 6:162
- Dutch Code of Civil Procedure (Wetboek van Burgerlijke Rechtsvordering): Articles 32a, 79, 254, 255 and 1020
- Dutch Commercial Code (Wetboek van Koophandel): Article 18
- Act of 5 June 2024 amending the dispute-settlement rules (Wet aanpassing geschillenregeling en verduidelijking ontvankelijkheidseisen enquêteprocedure): Stb. 2024, 174 (transitional law: Article III); entry into force 1 January 2025: Stb. 2024, 175
- Supreme Court (Hoge Raad) 10 January 1997, ECLI:NL:HR:1997:ZC2243 (Staleman/Van de Ven) (serious reproach, para. 3.3.1)
- Supreme Court 5 September 2014, ECLI:NL:HR:2014:2627 (director liability towards third parties, para. 4.2)
Dutch corporate law firm
Specializing in corporate litigation, MAAK Advocaten, a distinguished Dutch corporate law firm, stands out for its extensive experience and successful track record in representing corporations, management, and shareholders in a variety of legal matters.
They expertly manage the Dutch legal system, applying complex legal concepts to help their clients execute sound legal transactions. They’re adept at using legal instruments to protect your interests, from corporate inquiry cases to shareholder buy-outs. Their proficiency in these legal concepts has led to numerous victories in the Enterprise Chamber, which decides inquiry and buy-out proceedings in the Netherlands. MAAK Advocaten is not just a law firm; it’s a partner that ensures your corporate affairs are managed with precision and care. Here’s a look at their key services:
| Services | Description | Impact |
|---|---|---|
| Corporate Litigation in the Netherlands | Expert legal representation in corporate disputes governed by Dutch law | Reducing risk and uncertainty |
| Shareholder Buy-outs under Dutch law | Efficient execution of complex transactions | Protecting shareholder rights |
| Enterprise Chamber Proceedings (“Ondernemingskamer”) | Expert litigation representation in the Netherlands (Amsterdam) | Our office is located around the corner |