Commercial Litigation in the Netherlands

Published on · Last updated

Commercial litigation in the Netherlands is the resolution of business disputes by the Dutch civil courts: the district court (rechtbank), the court of appeal (gerechtshof) and the Supreme Court (Hoge Raad). The Dutch Code of Civil Procedure applies. Outside the subdistrict court (kantonrechter), you can in principle only litigate through a Dutch lawyer (advocaat) (Article 79(2) Rv). Our team also advises on Top Litigation Lawyers in Amsterdam.

Key Takeaways

Which commercial disputes arise most often?

We regularly assist clients with the following types litigation in the Netherlands:

When significant interests are at stake, a deep understanding of legal rules is essential. Commercial litigation demands in-depth expertise in procedural law. At MAAK Advocaten, we represent our clients in court proceedings in the Netherlands before the district courts and the courts of appeal. We handle main proceedings, summary proceedings, and international arbitration, including enforcement of arbitral awards.

How is the Dutch court system structured?

Traversing the complexities of commercial disputes in the Netherlands requires a deep understanding of the country’s court structure. You’ll need to work with various courts, each with its own jurisdiction and procedures.

For commercial disputes, the Dutch court system has three levels: eleven district courts, four courts of appeal (Articles 1 and 2 Judicial Division Act) and the Supreme Court. Within each district court, the subdistrict judge hears, among other things, claims of up to €25,000, unless the legal basis of the claim exceeds that amount and is disputed, and, regardless of the amount, cases about employment, commercial agency, lease and consumer sale contracts (Article 93 Rv). Other commercial cases start before the district court. You can appeal to the court of appeal, unless the claim does not exceed €1,750 (Article 332(1) Rv), and then lodge an appeal in cassation with the Supreme Court, which only reviews points of law. In cassation, a lawyer admitted to the Supreme Court (advocaat bij de Hoge Raad) must sign the originating document (Article 407(1) Rv).

Familiarity with the procedural law is essential for successful litigation. You’ll need to understand the rules and procedures governing each court to guarantee your case is handled efficiently and effectively. A solid grasp of the court structure will help you make informed decisions and achieve a favorable outcome.

Best For: The Netherlands Commercial Court (NCC) is a chamber of the Amsterdam District Court where parties can litigate in English; appeals go to the Netherlands Commercial Court of Appeal at the Amsterdam Court of Appeal. It is open if the Amsterdam court has jurisdiction over an international commercial dispute about a legal relationship at the parties’ free disposal, and the parties have expressly agreed to litigate there. The agreement is proven by a document; a clause in general terms and conditions only suffices if the other party expressly accepted that specific clause (Article 32a(1) Rv).

Pros:

  • Proceedings are conducted in English, eliminating language barriers and facilitating international dispute resolution.
  • The NCC offers a flexible process with a focus on early risk assessment and clear planning, enabling clients to maintain control over the litigation process.
  • The court provides a viable alternative to international arbitration and litigation, with experienced commercial dispute judges handling cases.

Cons:

  • The NCC may not be suitable for small businesses or individuals due to the complexity and costs associated with international commercial disputes.
  • The NCC is only available for international disputes about legal relationships at the parties’ free disposal, if the parties expressly agreed to it, and not for cases within the jurisdiction of the subdistrict court (Article 32a(1) Rv).
  • The NCC’s procedures and rules may be unfamiliar to companies or individuals without prior experience with international commercial litigation in the Netherlands.

How does commercial litigation work?

The Netherlands’ commercial litigation procedure is marked by a structured framework that governs the handling of commercial disputes. When you engage in commercial litigation in the Netherlands, you’ll find that the process is characterized by a clear set of rules and timelines.

Most claims for performance of a contract or for damages become time-barred after five years (Articles 3:307 and 3:310 DCC); other claims have different periods. Before proceedings, a party to a legal relationship with sufficient interest can claim access to, or a copy of, specific data about that relationship from the party that holds it (Article 194(1) Rv). Our Dutch litigation attorneys in the Netherlands would be happy to be of assistance.

As you work through the litigation process, you must comply with the procedural rules and deadlines. The period for appeal is three months from the date of the judgment, and four weeks for a judgment in summary proceedings (Article 339(1) and (2) Rv). An appeal in cassation to the Supreme Court must as a rule be lodged within three months (Article 402(1) Rv); where the appeal period is shorter, the cassation period is twice that period (Article 402(2)). The Supreme Court assesses whether the law was correctly interpreted and applied.

When engaging in commercial litigation in the Netherlands, you’ll need to ponder how to effectively present your case in court.

Before the subdistrict judge, you may act in person (Article 79(1) Rv). In other cases before the district court, you need a Dutch litigation attorney (Article 79(2) Rv), and the same applies in appeal (Article 353(1) Rv). In summary proceedings, a defendant may appear in person (Article 255(1) Rv). A lawyer from another EU or EEA state or Switzerland who provides services here without being registered in the Netherlands must work together with a lawyer registered in the Netherlands where Dutch law requires representation by a lawyer (Article 16e(1) Dutch Lawyers Act).

The judge may allow such a visiting lawyer to use a language other than Dutch if this does not harm the proper administration of justice, and may require an interpreter to be used (Article 16e(6) Dutch Lawyers Act). Your Dutch attorney and you agree on the fee arrangement, such as hourly rates or fixed/flat fees, within the professional conduct rules. You can also combine fee methods to suit your case.

When it comes to legal costs and fees in the Netherlands for commercial litigation, you have several things to keep in mind. Attorneys in the Netherlands have the discretion to determine their fee structures, as long as they comply with professional conduct rules.

You can expect hourly rates or fixed/flat fees. A lawyer may not agree that a fee is only charged if a certain result is achieved (“no cure no pay”), or that the fee is a proportion of the value of the result (Article 7.7(1) Bar Regulation, Verordening op de advocatuur). Exceptions apply to a customary collection tariff for debt collection (Article 7.8) and, under conditions, to personal injury and death cases (Articles 7.9-7.13).

You’ll find that there are no fixed legal fees established by law, allowing for flexibility in fee agreements. This means you can negotiate a fee arrangement that suits your specific case. Attorneys may also combine different fee methods to create a hybrid approach. For instance, they might charge an hourly rate for certain tasks and a fixed fee for others.

This flexibility enables you to shape your fee arrangement to your needs and budget. When engaging a lawyer, be sure to discuss and agree on a fee arrangement that aligns with your expectations and provides transparency on costs. By doing so, you’ll be better equipped to manage your expenses and work through Dutch commercial litigation.

Which limitation periods apply?

Under Dutch law, a claim becomes time-barred after twenty years unless the law provides otherwise (Article 3:306 DCC). For most commercial claims a shorter limitation period in the Netherlands applies: a claim for performance of a contract becomes time-barred five years after the day following the day on which it became due (Article 3:307(1)), and a claim for damages five years after the day following the day on which the injured party became aware of both the damage and the liable person, and in any case twenty years after the event that caused the damage (Article 3:310(1)). Exceptions apply: a claim for damages for personal injury or death becomes time-barred only five years after the injured party became aware of both the damage and the liable person (Article 3:310(5)), and for damage caused by, among other things, pollution of air, water or soil, the long-stop period is thirty years (Article 3:310(2)).

Once the claim is time-barred, you can no longer enforce it in court. The right itself does not disappear: it becomes an obligation that cannot be enforced (a natural obligation, Article 6:3(2)(a) DCC).

You should be aware of the following key points regarding time limits for commercial disputes under Dutch law:

  1. Limitation periods: five years for most claims for performance and damages, twenty years where the law sets no other period (Articles 3:306, 3:307 and 3:310 DCC).
  2. Limitation period doesn’t extinguish the right: It only affects your capacity to seek legal protection.
  3. Objection required: the court may not apply limitation of its own motion; the debtor must invoke it (Article 3:322(1) DCC).
  4. Interrupting the limitation period: bringing a claim or another act of legal proceedings interrupts it (Article 3:316(1) DCC), but if the claim is not granted, only if a new claim is brought within six months after the proceedings ended and is then granted (Article 3:316(2)). For a claim for performance, a written demand is enough (Article 3:317(1)); for other claims, a written demand only interrupts if it is followed within six months by an act under Article 3:316 (Article 3:317(2)).

It is essential to be mindful of these time limits to safeguard you don’t miss the opportunity to pursue a valid claim. If you’re unsure about the applicable limitation period or the best course of action, it’s recommended that you consult with a qualified lawyer.

How do you obtain documents before proceedings?

Dutch law has no general pre-trial discovery as in common law systems. Instead, specific discovery procedures in the Netherlands exist. A party to a legal relationship can claim access to, a copy of or an extract from specific data about that relationship, before or during proceedings (Article 194(1) Rv).

Before proceedings, the court can also order preliminary evidence measures (voorlopige bewijsverrichtingen), such as a witness examination or an expert report. It grants the request unless, for example, the information is not sufficiently specified, the applicant has insufficient interest or the request is an abuse of power (Article 196 Rv). To prevent evidence from disappearing, you can ask the preliminary relief judge for leave to attach it (bewijsbeslag, Article 205 Rv).

When you request access under Article 194 Rv, you must specify the data and show that you have sufficient interest. The holder can refuse if it has a right of non-disclosure (verschoningsrecht) or if important reasons oppose disclosure (Article 194(2)). You bear the costs of providing the data (Article 194(1)).

Which role does mediation play?

Frequently, mediation plays a central role in resolving commercial disputes in the Netherlands, offering a viable alternative to lengthy and costly court proceedings. As a party involved in a commercial dispute, you can opt for mediation to resolve your dispute efficiently.

Mediation is voluntary. The parties choose a mediator together, often a registered mediator, who helps them reach an agreement but does not decide the dispute.

You’ll find that mediation offers several advantages, including:

  1. Confidentiality: the parties usually agree in the mediation agreement that what is discussed remains confidential.
  2. Flexibility: Mediation allows for flexible scheduling and can be conducted in a shorter timeframe compared to court proceedings.
  3. Business relationship preservation: Mediation helps preserve business relationships, which can be damaged by lengthy and contentious court proceedings.
  4. Cost-effectiveness: Mediation can be more cost-effective than court litigation, as it eliminates the need for extensive documentation and court appearances.

Attorneys in the Netherlands can provide guidance and representation in mediation proceedings, ensuring that your interests are protected throughout the process. By opting for mediation, you can resolve your commercial dispute efficiently and effectively.

How do you start a commercial claim?

When mediation isn’t viable or hasn’t resolved your commercial dispute, you can initiate a claim under Dutch law. As a rule, a bailiff serves a writ of summons (dagvaarding) on the defendant, stating the claim and its grounds (Article 111 Rv). The ordinary summons period is at least one week (Article 114 Rv). The defendant files a reasoned statement of defence on the first docket date or on a later date set by the court (Article 128(2) Rv).

Before initiating a claim, check the limitation period that applies to your claim: five years for most claims for performance and damages, but other periods apply to other claims (Articles 3:306-3:310 DCC).

You may also want to request access to documents first (Article 194 Rv). After the statement of defence, the court as a rule orders an oral hearing (mondelinge behandeling), unless it considers the case unsuitable for one (Article 131 Rv). How long it takes until the hearing and the judgment varies by court and by case.

If your case is urgent, you can start summary proceedings (kort geding): the preliminary relief judge can grant an immediate provisional measure in all urgent cases where the interests of the parties require it (Article 254(1) Rv). For a money claim, the judge also considers how likely it is that the claim will succeed in main proceedings and the risk that the money cannot be recovered if it does not.

Which interim relief and evidence rules apply in the Netherlands?

Understanding the rules governing interim reliefs and evidence requirements in the Netherlands is essential to presenting a strong case. Evidence can be provided by any means, and the court is free to assess it, unless the law provides otherwise (Article 152 Rv). Facts that the other party does not dispute, or does not dispute sufficiently, must as a rule be taken as established (Article 149(1) Rv).

You can obtain interim measures, such as preliminary injunctions in the Netherlands in summary proceedings, if the case is urgent (Article 254(1) Rv). For Dutch freezing orders (conservatoir beslag), you need leave from the preliminary relief judge, who decides after a summary examination; unless the main proceedings are already pending, you must start them within the period the judge sets, of at least eight days after the attachment (Article 700(2) and (3) Rv). The burden of proof lies with the party that relies on the legal consequences of the facts it asserts, unless a special rule or reasonableness and fairness lead to a different allocation (Article 150 Rv).

The following are key considerations for interim reliefs and evidence requirements in the Netherlands:

  1. Interim measures: a preliminary injunction requires urgency (Article 254(1) Rv); a pre-judgment attachment requires leave from the preliminary relief judge (Article 700 Rv).
  2. Evidence: Dutch courts examine all evidence, including recordings, witness testimony, and expert reports.
  3. Burden of proof: the party relying on the legal consequences of the facts it asserts must prove them (Article 150 Rv), by any means of evidence (Article 152(1) Rv).
  4. Costs: the losing party pays the costs of the proceedings, with lawyer’s fees on a fixed scale (Article 237(1) Rv); in intellectual property enforcement cases, reasonable and proportionate costs can be awarded (Article 1019h Rv).

How do Dutch courts assess evidence and expert opinions?

In Dutch civil proceedings, evaluating evidence and expert opinions in the Netherlands requires careful consideration to build a strong case. You must assess the relevance and reliability of the evidence presented, as well as the credibility of expert witnesses.

The court assesses the evidence freely, unless the law provides otherwise (Article 152(2) Rv).

Expert opinions, in particular, play a central role in complex commercial disputes, providing objective insight and specialized knowledge. When evaluating expert opinions, you should consider the expert’s qualifications, experience, and methodology. The court also examines the expert’s independence and potential biases. You must guarantee that the expert’s opinion is based on a thorough analysis of the facts and evidence.

Effective evaluation of evidence and expert opinions enables you to present a strong case and increase the likelihood of a favorable outcome. By carefully assessing the evidence and expert opinions, you can build a strong foundation for your argument and work through the complexities of commercial litigation in the Netherlands.

Can you recover your costs and enforce a Dutch judgment?

In Dutch commercial litigation, recovering costs and enforcing judgments are essential aspects of the litigation process. As a party involved in a commercial dispute, you’ll want to understand the rules governing cost recovery and enforcement of judgments in the Netherlands.

The party that loses is ordered to pay the costs of the proceedings (Article 237(1) Rv), including court fees and a contribution to lawyer’s fees on a fixed scale applied by the courts (liquidatietarief), not the actual costs. If both parties lose on some points, the court can set off the costs. In intellectual property enforcement cases, the losing party can be ordered to pay the reasonable and proportionate costs of the winning party (Article 1019h Rv).

Here are key aspects of cost recovery and enforcement of judgments in the Netherlands to ponder:

  1. Recoverable costs: you can recover part of your legal costs, as a rule on the fixed scale applied by the courts (Article 237(1) Rv).
  2. Enforcement: a bailiff can enforce a Dutch judgment throughout the Netherlands, but only after it has been served on the losing party (Article 430(1) and (3) Rv).
  3. Pre-judgment attachment: with leave from the preliminary relief judge, you can attach assets to secure a future judgment (Article 700 Rv).
  4. Enforceability during appeal: an appeal suspends enforcement, unless the court declared the judgment provisionally enforceable (uitvoerbaar bij voorraad) (Article 350(1) and Article 233(1) Rv).

Are foreign judgments recognised in the Netherlands?

Under Netherlands law, you can have a foreign judgment recognized and enforced, provided certain requirements are met. If the judgment originates from an EU member state, you can enforce the judgment in the Netherlands without needing a further declaration.

For judgments from outside the EU, you need leave (exequatur) from the district court if a treaty or Dutch law provides for enforcement; the court does not re-examine the case itself (Article 985 Rv). If there is no such treaty or statute, the foreign judgment cannot be enforced as such, and the case must be brought again before the Dutch court (Article 431 Rv).

In such new proceedings, the Dutch court in principle recognises the foreign judgment if (i) the foreign court based its jurisdiction on a ground that is generally acceptable by international standards, (ii) the proceedings met the requirements of due process, (iii) recognition is not contrary to Dutch public policy, and (iv) the judgment is not irreconcilable with a Dutch judgment between the same parties or with an earlier foreign judgment between the same parties in a dispute on the same subject and based on the same cause, provided that earlier judgment can be recognised in the Netherlands. A claim for the same order is then in principle granted; it may fail if, under the law of the country of origin, the judgment is not, not yet or no longer enforceable (Supreme Court 26 September 2014, ECLI:NL:HR:2014:2838, paras. 3.6.4-3.6.6).

Origin of JudgmentEnforceability in the Netherlands
EU member stateEnforceable without further declaration
Country with a treaty, or where Dutch law provides for enforcementLeave (exequatur) from the district court (Article 985 Rv)
Country without such a treaty or statuteNew proceedings; the foreign judgment is in principle recognised if four conditions are met (Article 431 Rv; ECLI:NL:HR:2014:2838)

The recognition and enforcement of foreign judgments in the Netherlands are governed by EU regulations, international treaties and the Dutch Code of Civil Procedure.

Frequently asked questions about commercial litigation in the Netherlands

What is commercial litigation in the Netherlands?

It is the resolution of disputes between businesses by the Dutch civil courts under the Dutch Code of Civil Procedure. A case usually starts with a writ of summons (Article 111 Rv). After the statement of defence, the court as a rule holds an oral hearing (Article 131 Rv) and then gives judgment.

Which court hears commercial disputes in the Netherlands?

Claims of up to €25,000 (unless the legal basis exceeds that amount and is disputed) and, regardless of the amount, cases about employment, commercial agency, lease and consumer sale go to the subdistrict judge; other commercial cases go to the district court (Article 93 Rv). Appeal lies to one of the four courts of appeal, then to the Supreme Court.

Do you need a Dutch lawyer for commercial litigation in the Netherlands?

Yes, outside the subdistrict court (Article 79(2) Rv) and in appeal (Article 353(1) Rv); a defendant in summary proceedings may appear in person (Article 255(1) Rv). In cassation, a lawyer admitted to the Supreme Court is required (Article 407(1) Rv). A visiting lawyer from another EU or EEA state or Switzerland must work together with a lawyer registered in the Netherlands where representation by a lawyer is required (Article 16e(1) Dutch Lawyers Act).

Can you litigate in English in the Netherlands?

Yes, before the Netherlands Commercial Court in Amsterdam, if the dispute is international, concerns a legal relationship at the parties’ free disposal and the parties have expressly agreed to it. A clause in general terms only suffices if the other party expressly accepted that specific clause (Article 32a(1) Rv). Appeals go to the Netherlands Commercial Court of Appeal.

Does an appeal suspend enforcement of a Dutch judgment?

Yes, unless the court declared the judgment provisionally enforceable (uitvoerbaar bij voorraad) (Articles 350(1) and 233(1) Rv). The appeal period is three months, and four weeks in summary proceedings (Article 339 Rv).

Primary sources

News & Insights
Which topics would you like to receive updates on?
Who are you?
Which industry or sector do you operate in? (Optional)