Published on
A trademark opposition at BOIP, the Benelux Office for Intellectual Property, must be filed within two months of publication of the application; at EUIPO the period is three months. The office, the earlier right and the goods you target decide the result. As a Dutch IP lawyer at MAAK Advocaten in Amsterdam, I advise brand owners abroad on that choice.
In short
- Oppositions rest on Article 2.2ter BCIP in the Benelux and Article 8 EUTMR in the EU; an EU trademark can stop a Benelux application.
- Success depends on your earlier right, the goods you target and, for a mark registered five years or more, proof of genuine use.
- Both offices open with a cooling-off period of two months for settlement.
- A Dutch IP lawyer should review the earlier right, goods list and use evidence before you pay the fee.
This article is part of our pages on intellectual property law in the Netherlands. It is written for brand owners and in-house counsel outside the Netherlands who have found a Benelux or EU trademark application that collides with their mark, and for applicants who have just received an opposition.
How long do you have to oppose a trademark application at BOIP or EUIPO?
At BOIP you have two months from publication of the Benelux application; at EUIPO, three months from publication of the EU application. An opposition counts only once you pay the fee (Article 2.14(4) BCIP; Article 46(3) EUTMR).
The period runs from publication, not from the day you learn of the application. For an international registration that designates the Benelux, the two months run from publication by the International Bureau (Article 2.18(1) BCIP).
| BOIP (Benelux) | EUIPO (EU) | |
|---|---|---|
| Period | Two months from publication (Art. 2.14(1)) | Three months from publication (Art. 46(1)) |
| Fee | EUR 1,045 basic fee (BOIP fees) | EUR 320 (fee annex to the EUTMR) |
| Cooling-off | Two months after notice of admissibility; extendable by mutual request (BOIP) | Two months; up to 24 months overall if both parties ask (Art. 6(1) Delegated Regulation 2018/625) |
| Proof of use | On request of the applicant (Art. 2.16bis) | On request of the applicant (Art. 47(2)-(3)) |
| Appeal | Benelux Court of Justice, two months from notification (Art. 1.15bis) | Board of Appeal; notice within two months, grounds within four (Art. 68(1)) |
After the deadline the opposition route is closed. After registration you can still seek a declaration of invalidity at BOIP (Article 2.30bis BCIP) or before the courts (Article 2.28 BCIP); see our pages on enforcing trademark rights in the Netherlands and trademark disputes in the Netherlands.
Which office do you have to oppose in?
The office where the application was filed. BOIP handles Benelux applications and international registrations that designate the Benelux; EUIPO handles EU trademark applications. Your own earlier right can sit in either register.
A Benelux registration counts as an earlier mark against an EU application (Article 8(2)(a)(ii) EUTMR), and an EU trademark counts as an earlier mark against a Benelux application (Article 2.2ter(2)(a)(ii) BCIP). A US or UK company with an EU trademark can therefore stop a Benelux filing, and a Benelux owner can stop an EU filing.
A company without a seat or establishment in the European Economic Area must be represented at EUIPO by an authorised representative in all proceedings other than the filing of an application (Article 119(2) EUTMR). Which of your registrations to invoke depends on what you hold, how old it is and what the applicant filed for.
On what grounds can you oppose a trademark application?
On relative grounds, mainly likelihood of confusion between identical or similar marks for identical or similar goods or services (Article 2.2ter(1)(b) BCIP; Article 8(1)(b) EUTMR). Reputation and agent filings are further grounds.
- Identical mark for identical goods or services (Article 2.2ter(1)(a); Article 8(1)(a)).
- A mark with a reputation, where the later mark takes unfair advantage of it or harms its character or repute, even for dissimilar goods (Article 2.2ter(3)(a); Article 8(5)).
- A filing in the agent’s own name without the proprietor’s authorisation, unless the agent justifies it (Article 2.2ter(3)(b); Article 8(3)).
- A well-known mark within the meaning of Article 6bis of the Paris Convention (Article 2.2ter(2)(d); Article 8(2)(c)), and protected geographical indications.
The EU grounds go one step further. An unregistered mark or other sign used in the course of trade of more than merely local importance can found an opposition at EUIPO (Article 8(4) EUTMR); Article 2.2ter BCIP lists no such ground. If your brand rests on use rather than registration, the choice of office matters.
Whether the signs and goods are similar enough is a judgment on the facts, and the opposition can be aimed at part or all of the application’s goods and services (Article 2.14(3) BCIP). BOIP advises opponents to be selective: the other side pays costs only if the opposition is justified for all goods and services targeted.
Important: the opposition counts only once the fee is paid, and at BOIP an opposition that succeeds only in part earns you no costs (Article 2.16(5) BCIP). Have a Dutch IP lawyer review your earlier rights and the goods you target before you file, while the period is still running.
Found a conflicting application? Send me the application number and your registrations, and I will tell you whether opposition is the right route, at which office and against which goods. Call +31 20 210 31 38 or use my page as Dutch intellectual property lawyer.
What happens after you file: cooling-off, arguments and proof of use?
Both offices open with a two-month cooling-off period for settlement. Then the opponent argues, and the applicant answers and may ask for proof of use of an earlier mark registered five years or more (BOIP; Article 6 Delegated Regulation 2018/625).
At BOIP the cooling-off period starts when BOIP informs both parties of the admissible opposition. If the parties settle, BOIP reimburses part of the fees. At EUIPO the opposition is closed within that period if the application is withdrawn or restricted to goods the opposition does not target, or if the parties report a settlement (Article 6(2)).
A BOIP opposition can be conducted in Dutch, French or English, and evidence may be filed in its original language if BOIP finds it sufficiently intelligible.
Proof of use is where many oppositions turn. If the earlier mark was registered five years or more before the later application was filed, the applicant can ask the opponent to prove genuine use for the goods relied on during the five years before that filing date (Article 2.16bis(1) BCIP; Article 47(2) and (3) EUTMR). Use on only some of the goods keeps only those goods in play. At BOIP the opponent then has two months to file proof, such as packaging, labels, price lists and invoices. My advice to a brand owner is to check, before paying the fee, that you can prove use of your own mark.
Important: without proof of genuine use for the goods you rely on, the opposition is closed at BOIP (Article 2.16(3)(e) BCIP) and rejected at EUIPO (Article 47(2) and (3) EUTMR). Collect your use evidence before you file, and have a Dutch IP lawyer review it against the goods you intend to oppose.
What do you do when someone opposes your trademark application?
Check the earlier right first, then choose: settle in the cooling-off period, narrow your goods and services, or defend. At BOIP, an applicant who does not react to the opposition loses the application (Article 2.16(3)(b) BCIP).
An EU applicant can withdraw or restrict the application at any time (Article 49(1) EUTMR). If the opponent’s mark is five years old or more, I ask for proof of use first, before I answer on the substance.
I look for the commercial solution first. In the cooling-off period a narrower goods list or a delimitation is often quicker and cheaper than a decision, and the relationship with the other side stays workable. I go on to a decision when the other side keeps infringing or you cannot expand in the Benelux without the mark.
Important: if you restrict your application to goods the opposition does not target, the EUIPO proceedings close (Article 6(2) Delegated Regulation 2018/625; Article 49(1) EUTMR), and the goods you give up are no longer covered by that application. Have a Dutch IP lawyer check which goods the brand needs before you agree to narrow the list or to a coexistence arrangement.
How does the office decide, who pays and can you appeal?
If the opposition is justified, BOIP refuses the application in whole or in part; otherwise it rejects the opposition (Article 2.16(4) BCIP). The loser pays the costs, unless the opposition succeeds only in part (Article 2.16(5)).
BOIP sets the costs at an amount equal to the basic opposition fee, currently EUR 1,045 (BOIP), and its cost decision is an enforceable order (Article 2.16(5)). A BOIP decision becomes final only when it can no longer be appealed. The appeal lies with the Benelux Court of Justice, within two months of notification (Article 1.15bis BCIP). At EUIPO the appeal lies with the Board of Appeal: notice within two months of notification of the decision and the statement of grounds within four months, and the appeal suspends the decision (Articles 66(1) and 68(1) EUTMR).
Example: an EU trademark owner finds a Benelux application
Illustration, not a real case: a US footwear brand holds an EU trademark registered six years ago for shoes. A Dutch distributor files a Benelux application for a similar sign for footwear, and BOIP publishes it. The brand has two months.
It can oppose at BOIP on its EU trademark (Article 2.2ter(2)(a)(ii) BCIP). Because the EU trademark is older than five years, the applicant can ask for proof of use, and genuine use is then judged under Article 18 EUTMR (Article 2.16bis(3) BCIP). The brand must be able to show use of the mark in the Union for shoes in the five years before the Benelux filing date. Whether filing is worth it depends on the goods list, the use evidence and the chance of a settlement.
When do you need a Dutch lawyer for a trademark opposition?
As soon as you see the application and before you pay the fee, because the office, the earlier right, the goods and the evidence are fixed at filing. A party outside the EEA must be represented at EUIPO (Article 119(2) EUTMR).
- You spot a Benelux or EU application that resembles your brand and the period is running.
- You receive an opposition, or the other side asks for proof of use of your mark.
- A coexistence or settlement proposal arrives, or a decision has been issued and the appeal period has started.
For brand strategy before a Benelux launch, see brand protection under Dutch law and trademark protection in the Netherlands.
How does MAAK Advocaten handle trademark oppositions?
I advise on the choice of office, the earlier right and the evidence, and I negotiate with the other side. If a dispute needs more than an opposition, I act before the Dutch courts, in first instance and on appeal.
In the first days I confirm the publication date and the deadline, check your registrations and assess your use evidence. Then we decide whether to file, write to the applicant first, or leave the application alone. I advise opponents and applicants.
Frequently asked questions
How long do I have to file a trademark opposition at BOIP?
Two months from publication of the application (Article 2.14(1) BCIP). For an international registration designating the Benelux, the period runs from publication by the International Bureau (Article 2.18(1)). The opposition counts as filed only when the fees are paid (Article 2.14(4)).
How much does a trademark opposition cost at BOIP and EUIPO?
BOIP charges a basic fee of EUR 1,045 (BOIP fees), which is also the amount of costs the losing party is ordered to pay. EUIPO charges EUR 320 (fee annex to the EUTMR). These are official fees; lawyer’s fees come on top and depend on the file.
Can I oppose a Benelux application with my EU trademark?
Yes. EU trademarks are earlier marks under Article 2.2ter(2)(a) BCIP. If the EU trademark was registered five years or more before the Benelux filing, the applicant can ask for proof of genuine use, assessed under Article 18 EUTMR (Article 2.16bis(3)).
Can a trademark opposition be settled?
Yes. Both offices open with a cooling-off period of two months. At BOIP it can be extended by mutual request and part of the fees is reimbursed if the parties settle; at EUIPO it can run to 24 months overall if both parties ask (BOIP procedure; Article 6(1) Delegated Regulation 2018/625).
When should I involve a Dutch lawyer in a trademark opposition?
Before you pay the fee, and again when a proof-of-use request or a settlement offer arrives. The office, the earlier right and the goods you target are fixed at filing. MAAK Advocaten in Amsterdam reviews those points and advises opponents and applicants in English.
Primary sources
- Benelux Convention on Intellectual Property (BCIP), Dutch text on wetten.overheid.nl, with the BOIP English text: Articles 1.15bis, 2.2ter, 2.14, 2.16, 2.16bis, 2.18, 2.28 and 2.30bis
- Regulation (EU) 2017/1001 on the European Union trade mark: Articles 8, 46, 47, 49, 66, 68 and 119, and the fee annex
- Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2018/625: Article 6, commencement of the adversarial part and cooling-off
- BOIP: opposition, filing an opposition, the opposition procedure and fees
Is a conflicting trademark application about to reach the end of its opposition period, or has your own application been opposed? Put your situation to me: call +31 20 210 31 38 or send the application number and your registrations through my page as Dutch intellectual property lawyer. — Arnout Gieske