Published on
A preliminary injunction for IP infringement in the Netherlands is obtained in kort geding (summary proceedings). The preliminary relief judge can order an infringer to stop within weeks, in urgent cases even before the other side is heard. As a Dutch IP lawyer at MAAK Advocaten, I advise rights holders on whether to apply, and companies that are served on how to respond.
This article is part of our pages on intellectual property law in the Netherlands. For the general procedure, see summary proceedings in the Netherlands.
When does a Dutch judge grant a preliminary injunction for IP infringement?
When the infringement is highly likely to be confirmed in proceedings on the merits and the matter is urgent. Urgency exists in principle for as long as the infringement continues, unless you have acted too slowly.
The preliminary relief judge (voorzieningenrechter) can give an immediate provision in any urgent case in which the interests of the parties require it (Article 254(1) Dutch Code of Civil Procedure, Rv). Slow action can count against you, but the Hague court looks at the circumstances of the case (Hague District Court, 22 March 2019, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2019:2820). On the merits, the judge must find it so highly likely that your claims would succeed that the outcome can be anticipated. In another trade mark case, the claims failed on that point (Hague District Court, 1 March 2019, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2019:1845).
Articles 1019 to 1019i Rv cover enforcement of, among others, copyright, patents, Benelux trade marks and designs, database rights and trade names. See also enforcing trademark rights and patent infringement.
Every week the infringement continues costs you sales and your customers’ trust. I work in three steps. First the evidence: a sample bought with an invoice, date-stamped screenshots, the date you found out. Second your right: does it apply in the Netherlands, to exactly these products? Third the route: kort geding, or first a letter. Send me those documents and I will tell you quickly whether a preliminary injunction is realistic.
How fast can you get a preliminary injunction in the Netherlands?
The law sets no fixed number of days. The judge fixes the hearing according to the urgency, if necessary on a day and hour of his choosing, a Sunday included, and can shorten the summons period (Article 254(2) Rv and Article 117 Rv).
Speed depends on how complete your file is. In an undefended 2017 case, the summons was dated 14 July, the hearing took place on 15 August and the judgment followed on 22 August (Hague District Court, 22 August 2017, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2017:9497). In a defended case, the hearing was on 4 January 2019 and the judgment on 1 March 2019 (Hague District Court, 1 March 2019, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2019:1845).
You can do much of the groundwork yourself before anyone writes to the infringer:
- buy a sample with an invoice and keep the packaging;
- save date-stamped screenshots of listings, websites and adverts;
- note when you first learned of the infringement and what you did next;
- collect your registration certificates and proof of ownership.
Important: If you wait months after discovering the infringement, the other side will argue that your interest does not need an interim measure, and a slow reaction can count against you. In a 2019 case, claimants who explained a months-long delay kept their urgency (Hague District Court, 22 March 2019, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2019:2820). Have a Dutch IP lawyer review your timeline before you send a cease-and-desist letter.
Is a Dutch party infringing your IP right and does every week count? Send me the registration details and your evidence through my page as Dutch intellectual property lawyer, and I will tell you whether a preliminary injunction is realistic.
Can you get a preliminary injunction without the other side being heard?
Yes, in urgent cases, in particular where delay would cause irreparable harm to the rights holder. On a request, the preliminary relief judge can issue an order without summoning the alleged infringer, to prevent an imminent infringement (Article 1019e(1) Rv).
The judge can require security (Article 1019e(2)) and the order can be reviewed on request (Article 1019e(3); Article 9(4) Directive 2004/48/EC). The text speaks of an imminent infringement; how far it reaches once the infringement has started, we assess per case.
The risk sits with you, with or without a hearing. If a measure should not have been taken, or there was no infringement, the court can order you, on the defendant’s claim, to compensate the damage (Article 1019g Rv; compare Article 9(7) of the Directive). An order without a hearing makes that risk bigger.
A ban without hearing sounds attractive: fast, and the other side cannot prepare. I use it deliberately: it fits when every hour counts and the infringement is obvious, for example a copy on a trade fair stand. Otherwise I recommend kort geding with a hearing, which gives a more durable ban.
Important: Before you ask for an order without a hearing, have a Dutch IP lawyer test your evidence the way the other side will. A measure that proves unjustified can leave you paying the damage it caused, and the judge can review it on request.
What can the court order, and how far does it reach?
Typically a ban on further infringing acts, backed by a penalty payment, and sometimes delivery up of stock. How far it reaches depends on the right and on where the defendant is based.
A penalty payment (dwangsom) cannot be forfeited before the judgment has been served (Article 611a(3) Rv). In a 2019 case, the judge ordered an infringer to stop within two working days and to hand over its stock within five working days. The penalty was EUR 5,000 per day, up to EUR 250,000 (Hague District Court, 22 March 2019, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2019:2820).
I make sure the ban names exactly which products, sales channels and domain names it covers. A ban that is too wide gets cut back, and a vague one leads to enforcement disputes.
For an EU trade mark, the EU Trade Mark Regulation (EUTMR, Regulation (EU) 2017/1001) decides. A court whose jurisdiction rests on the defendant’s domicile or establishment can rule on acts committed or threatened in any Member State. A court that is only the place of infringement can rule only on acts in its own territory (Articles 125 and 126 EUTMR). Provisional measures from the first kind of court apply in any Member State, subject to recognition and enforcement under Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012 (Article 131(2) EUTMR). For patents, designs and copyright, other rules decide the reach; we assess that per case.
| Situation | Reach of the court’s jurisdiction | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Dutch defendant, EU trade mark | Acts in any EU Member State | Articles 125(1), 126(1) EUTMR; Hague court, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2017:9497 |
| Dutch defendant, Benelux trade mark | The Benelux | Hague court, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2017:9497 |
| Danish defendant, EU trade mark, interim measure sought in the Netherlands | The Netherlands only (the court’s own holding) | Articles 126(2), 131 EUTMR; Hague court, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2019:1845 |
What happens after the injunction: must you start proceedings on the merits?
Yes. The judge sets a period for starting the merits case. If you miss it, the injunction loses effect once the defendant files a declaration with the court registry (Article 1019i Rv).
Without a period set by the judge, the declaration is possible after at least 31 days without a merits case, of which at least 20 are working days (Article 1019i(2); compare Article 9(5) of the Directive). In the two judgments cited here in which an injunction was granted, the judge set six months from the judgment (Hague District Court, 22 August 2017, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2017:9497; Hague District Court, 22 March 2019, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2019:2820).
With the judgment, the commercial goal is usually reached: the sales have stopped. I tell clients to use the period for a conversation, because a written undertaking with a penalty is often better than a long trial; we discuss the terms per case. If the infringer keeps going, or the damage is large, we start the merits case in time.
Important: If you let the period for the merits case expire, the other side can end your injunction with a declaration at the court registry. Put the date in your calendar on the day of judgment. Decide with a Dutch IP lawyer beforehand whether you want a merits case or a settlement.
What does a preliminary injunction cost, and who pays?
You pay your own lawyer and the court fee up front. The loser can be ordered to pay the winner’s reasonable and proportionate costs, unless fairness stands in the way, so the cost risk runs both ways (Article 1019h Rv; Article 14 of the Directive).
In 2017, the Hague court saw a simple case. It awarded EUR 6,000 in attorney’s fees, plus court fee and bailiff costs, where EUR 15,228.24 in costs had been claimed (Hague District Court, 22 August 2017, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2017:9497). In 2019, a claimant that lost had to pay the defendant’s costs. They were capped at EUR 6,000 under the indicative rate for a simple kort geding, plus the court fee (Hague District Court, 1 March 2019, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2019:1845). The indicative rates carry a version date, so treat these figures as an illustration, not a forecast.
Before the first step, I tell you how strong your position is and what the cost risk is on both sides. Your own costs depend on the evidence needed, whether the other side defends and whether a merits case follows; we discuss that before we start.
You were served with a Dutch kort geding summons or order: what now?
Comply with any order from service and have a Dutch lawyer assess the claim at once. Penalty payments only run after service (Article 611a(3) Rv), and the four weeks to appeal a kort geding judgment run from the day of the judgment (Article 339(1)-(2) Rv).
As defendant in kort geding you may appear in person, but not through a representative who is not a lawyer (Article 255(1) Rv). For the appeal, see appealing a Dutch kort geding judgment.
That is a shock, especially when the order lands on your trade fair stand. Staying calm and acting fast go together. First, follow the order from service. Second, send me the papers so that we see the deadlines. Third, we check whether the claimant really holds a right in the Netherlands and whether your product infringes it.
Practical example: a UK brand against a Dutch webshop
Suppose a UK sports equipment brand with an EU trade mark finds a Dutch webshop selling copies before the winter season. This is an illustration, not a real case. The brand secures its evidence and summons the webshop in kort geding within days. Because the webshop is based in the Netherlands, the court can rule on acts in all EU Member States (Articles 125(1) and 126(1) EUTMR).
I have appeared in this type of case. In 2017, I presented the oral argument for the Israeli company Sabon, together with its Haarlem lawyer, before the Hague preliminary relief judge. Its opponent, Orion Retail BV, did not appear. The judge granted a ban covering the EU and Benelux trade marks (Hague District Court, 22 August 2017, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2017:9497).
When do you need a Dutch lawyer for a preliminary injunction?
Before you send a cease-and-desist letter or start any filing. A company cannot bring a claim before the district court in person; it needs a lawyer (Article 79(2) Rv).
The choices that decide the result are legal: which right and defendants to use, which territories to ask for, whether to apply without a hearing, and how to meet a defence that your right is invalid. We assess those per case.
How does MAAK Advocaten handle IP preliminary injunctions?
We assess your right and your evidence first. Then we apply for the injunction or prepare your defence, before the Dutch courts at first instance and on appeal, for rights holders and for defendants.
In the first days we review the documents and secure the deadlines. We decide between a letter, a kort geding summons and an application without hearing, and prepare the request or the defence. We work in English and take the court papers off your hands.
Frequently asked questions
Can a Dutch court order a preliminary injunction against a company outside the Netherlands?
Yes, if it has jurisdiction. For an EU trade mark, a Dutch court can grant provisional measures under Article 131 EUTMR. Against a Danish company, the Hague court held that its jurisdiction was limited to the Netherlands and then dismissed the claims (Hague District Court, 1 March 2019, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2019:1845). Whether a Dutch court is the right forum is decided per case.
How long does a Dutch preliminary injunction take?
There is no fixed period. The judge sets the hearing date according to the urgency and can shorten the summons period (Article 254(2) and 117 Rv). In an undefended 2017 case, just over five weeks passed between the summons and the judgment (Hague District Court, 22 August 2017, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2017:9497). A defended case takes longer.
Is a Dutch preliminary injunction final?
No. It is a provisional decision, and in IP cases the judge sets a period to start proceedings on the merits. If you miss it, the defendant can end the injunction with a declaration at the court registry (Article 1019i Rv).
Do I need a Dutch lawyer to apply for a preliminary injunction?
Yes, as a claimant: before the district court you cannot litigate in person (Article 79(2) Rv). A defendant may appear in person in kort geding but not through a non-lawyer representative. MAAK Advocaten in Amsterdam acts for rights holders and defendants in IP kort geding, in English.
Who pays the costs of a preliminary injunction in an IP case?
As a general rule, the losing party pays the winner’s reasonable and proportionate costs, unless fairness stands in the way (Article 1019h Rv). The court reviews what is reasonable: in a 2017 case, it allowed EUR 6,000 in attorney’s fees where EUR 15,228.24 in costs had been claimed (Hague District Court, 22 August 2017, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2017:9497).
Primary sources
- Articles 1019 to 1019i Rv (1019e, 1019g, 1019h, 1019i): scope, order without hearing, damages, costs and the period for the merits case
- Articles 254, 117 and 255 Rv: urgent provisions, summons period, defendant appearing in person
- Article 79 Rv: representation by a lawyer; Article 339 Rv: four weeks for appeal in kort geding; Article 611a Rv: penalty payment
- Directive 2004/48/EC on the enforcement of intellectual property rights: Articles 9 and 14
- Regulation (EU) 2017/1001 on the European Union trade mark (EUTMR): Articles 125, 126 and 131
- Hague District Court, kort geding: 22 August 2017, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2017:9497 (Sabon v Orion Retail), 1 March 2019, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2019:1845 (De Bondt v Hobbii) and 22 March 2019, ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2019:2820 (Solatube)
Do you need to stop an infringement in the Netherlands, or have you been served with a kort geding summons? Put your situation to me: call +31 20 210 31 38 or send the details through my page as Dutch intellectual property lawyer. — Arnout Gieske