Reflex effect on general terms and conditions of business under Dutch law

Share this article

WhatsAppLinkedIn

Published on · Last updated

The black and grey lists of unreasonably onerous clauses in Dutch general terms and conditions protect consumers only (Articles 6:236 and 6:237 Dutch Civil Code). Through the reflex effect (reflexwerking), a court can still take a listed clause into account when it tests whether that clause is unreasonably onerous for a small business under Article 6:233(a).

This page is for foreign companies that deal with a Dutch supplier or customer on Dutch general terms, or that use their own terms through a Dutch subsidiary. The first question is not the reflex effect itself but whether the Dutch rules on general terms apply at all. Between businesses that are not both established in the Netherlands, they do not (Article 6:247(2)). Our main page explains when general terms and conditions apply under Dutch law.

What is the reflex effect of the black and grey lists?

It is the indirect effect of the consumer lists in business contracts. A clause that appears on the black or grey list is not automatically void or voidable against a business, but the court can count the listing as one circumstance when it applies the open standard of Article 6:233(a).

The Dutch Civil Code has two lists for contracts with a consumer, meaning a natural person not acting in the course of a profession or business. A clause on the black list is deemed unreasonably onerous (Article 6:236), for example a clause that shortens a statutory limitation or expiry period to less than one year (point g). A clause on the grey list is presumed unreasonably onerous, so the user can rebut it (Article 6:237), for example a clause that wholly or partly releases the user from a statutory obligation to pay damages (point f).

For other counterparties only the open standard applies. A clause in general terms is voidable if it is unreasonably onerous for the other party, given the nature and content of the contract, the way the terms came about, the mutually recognisable interests of the parties and the other circumstances (Article 6:233(a)). The Dutch Supreme Court (Hoge Raad) explained in 2023 that the capacity of the parties, their social position, their relationship and their specific knowledge all count. Where a business is in a position very similar to that of a consumer, the fact that the clause is on one of the lists can be included in that assessment (HR 8 September 2023, ECLI:NL:HR:2023:1197, para. 3.2.2).

Can a foreign company rely on the reflex effect against a Dutch party?

As a rule, no. The Dutch rules on general terms, including Article 6:233 and the lists, do not apply to a contract between businesses that are not both established in the Netherlands, whatever law governs the contract (Article 6:247(2) Dutch Civil Code).

What counts is the place of business that performs. A party is established in the Netherlands if its principal place of business is there or, where the contract is to be performed by another establishment, that establishment is in the Netherlands (Article 6:247(3)). A Belgian company that buys services from a Dutch consultancy therefore cannot invoke Article 6:233 or the reflex effect. The same applies to a Dutch supplier facing the general terms of a German customer.

If Dutch law governs the contract, a clause in general terms can then mainly be challenged under the limiting effect of reasonableness and fairness: a contractual rule does not apply to the extent that applying it would be unacceptable by standards of reasonableness and fairness (Article 6:248(2)). That is a stricter test than “unreasonably onerous”. Contracts with consumers who have their habitual residence in the Netherlands are different: for them the Dutch rules apply regardless of the governing law (Article 6:247(4)).

Which businesses cannot invoke Article 6:233 at all?

Larger businesses and repeat users of the same terms. The reflex effect therefore matters mainly for small Dutch businesses, foundations and associations, and for contracts outside a party’s own line of business.

Under Article 6:235(1), a party cannot rely on the grounds for annulment of Articles 6:233 and 6:234 if, when the contract was concluded, it was a legal entity referred to in Article 2:360 that had last published its annual accounts or to which Article 2:403(1) had last been applied, or a party where fifty or more persons worked or where a filing in the trade register showed that fifty or more persons worked. A party that itself repeatedly uses the same or almost the same general terms in its contracts is also excluded (Article 6:235(3)). In practice, a Dutch subsidiary of a foreign group will often fall under one of these exceptions.

What did the Dutch Supreme Court decide in 2023?

The Hoge Raad confirmed that the reflex effect is not limited to small legal entities without a business. It can also apply where a business concludes a contract outside its actual business activities and is in a position very similar to that of a consumer.

A cheese and dairy company had engaged an adviser to obtain a subsidy and to advise on a loan it made to a company abroad and on the security for that loan. The adviser’s general terms required complaints within 8 days after a problem was found and at the latest within 14 days after completion of the work. The Arnhem-Leeuwarden Court of Appeal (ECLI:NL:GHARL:2022:3003) held that the dairy company had validly annulled that clause under Article 6:233(a). It took into account that the dairy company had no knowledge of or experience with this financial matter and had hired the adviser for exactly that reason.

The Hoge Raad dismissed the appeal (HR 8 September 2023, ECLI:NL:HR:2023:1197, paras. 3.2.2-3.2.3). It did correct one point: in a consumer contract this clause would fall under the grey list (Article 6:237(h)), not under the black list (Article 6:236(g)), because the statutory duty to complain “within a reasonable time” of Article 6:89 has no fixed period (paras. 3.3.2-3.3.4). That error did not change the outcome, since the court of appeal had not treated the difference as decisive (para. 3.3.5).

What does this mean for your general terms in the Netherlands?

Check first whether the Dutch rules on general terms apply to the contract. If they do, draft clauses that would survive the grey list test whenever your customers include small businesses, especially for complaint periods, liability and termination.

  • Map where each contracting party is established and which establishment performs (Article 6:247(3)). For cross-border B2B contracts the reflex effect is in principle not relevant.
  • If you contract through a Dutch entity with small Dutch businesses, review clauses that appear on the black or grey list. Common examples are short complaint periods (Article 6:237(h)), broad exclusions of liability (Article 6:237(f)) and limits on the right to terminate.
  • Look at the subject of the contract. A clause that is acceptable for a customer’s core activity can be unreasonably onerous where the contract falls outside that activity, as in the 2023 case.
  • Keep in mind that a court weighs all circumstances. A listed clause in a contract with a business is not void by definition, and a clause that is not listed can still be unreasonably onerous.

Which clauses are on the lists and how a court tests them is explained on our page on forbidden terms and conditions in Dutch contracts. For liability clauses specifically, see excluding liability in general terms and conditions under Dutch law. If you want your terms checked before a dispute arises, a Dutch lawyer can review your general terms and conditions against these rules.

Frequently asked questions about the reflex effect under Dutch law

What does reflexwerking mean in Dutch contract law?

Reflexwerking is the indirect effect of the consumer black and grey lists (Articles 6:236 and 6:237 Dutch Civil Code) in contracts with a business. A court may count the fact that a clause appears on a list when it tests whether the clause is unreasonably onerous under Article 6:233(a) for a business whose position is very similar to that of a consumer.

Can a foreign company invoke the Dutch grey list against a Dutch supplier?

In principle not. The Dutch rules on general terms do not apply to contracts between businesses that are not both established in the Netherlands, whatever law governs the contract (Article 6:247(2)). If Dutch law applies, the foreign company can rely on Article 6:248(2): a clause does not apply as far as that would be unacceptable by standards of reasonableness and fairness.

Is a clause on the grey list void in a contract between two Dutch businesses?

No. The lists only apply directly to consumer contracts. Between businesses, a clause in general terms is voidable if it is unreasonably onerous under Article 6:233(a), and, where the business is in a position very similar to that of a consumer, the listing is one of the circumstances the court can take into account. The outcome depends on the facts of the case.

Which companies cannot rely on Article 6:233 of the Dutch Civil Code?

Legal entities referred to in Article 2:360 that had last published their annual accounts when the contract was concluded or to which Article 2:403(1) had last been applied, parties where fifty or more persons worked at that time, and parties that themselves repeatedly use the same or almost the same general terms (Article 6:235(1) and (3)).

Is a short complaint period in general terms valid against a business?

It can be, but not always. The statutory rule requires a complaint within a reasonable time after the defect was or should have been discovered (Article 6:89), without a fixed period. In 2023 the Hoge Raad upheld the annulment of an 8-day and 14-day complaint period for a dairy company that had hired an adviser for matters outside its business (ECLI:NL:HR:2023:1197).

Primary sources

Dutch statutes are only officially available in Dutch, on wetten.overheid.nl. Judgments can be found on rechtspraak.nl by their ECLI number.

Do you want to know whether a clause in Dutch general terms will hold?

Whether you are facing a clause in the general terms of a Dutch counterparty or want your own terms to work in the Netherlands, our Dutch law firm can assess the clause in the light of Articles 6:233, 6:247 and 6:248 Dutch Civil Code. Read more about our work as a contract lawyer in the Netherlands for international companies.

News & Insights
Which topics would you like to receive updates on?
Who are you?
Which industry or sector do you operate in? (Optional)