Published on · Last updated
Legal protection against trade barriers works on two levels. In your contracts, Dutch law offers force majeure and unforeseen circumstances, which work best with clear clauses on tariffs and sanctions. Against the foreign measure itself, an EU company can ask the European Commission to act under the Trade Barriers Regulation (Regulation (EU) 2015/1843).
In short
- A foreign measure does not automatically change your contract: the contract and Dutch law decide who bears the cost (Articles 6:75, 6:258 and 6:265 DCC).
- A tariff that only makes performance more expensive is usually not force majeure under Article 6:75 DCC; a ban that makes delivery impossible can be.
- A Union enterprise or an association acting for one can complain; the Commission as a rule decides within 45 days, unless suspended, whether to open an examination (Article 5(4)).
- Have a Dutch contract lawyer review your clauses before you suspend deliveries or refuse a price increase.
This page is for importers, exporters and manufacturers dealing with tariffs, import bans, sanctions or other trade restrictions imposed by a non-EU country. You will read when a contract partner may invoke such a measure, which clauses help, and how the EU complaint procedure works. For pricing problems in general, see our page on price increases of raw materials under Dutch law.
What is a trade barrier under EU law?
Under the Trade Barriers Regulation, an obstacle to trade is a practice of a non-EU country that international trade rules prohibit or allow others to challenge (Article 2(1)(a) Regulation (EU) 2015/1843). The practice must be adopted or maintained by that country.
Those international trade rules are primarily the WTO agreements, but can also be other trade agreements to which the EU is a party (Article 2(1)(b)). Not every unwelcome measure qualifies. A tariff that a country may lawfully impose under its WTO commitments is a business risk, not an obstacle to trade in this sense; a ban that violates those commitments may be.
Who can ask the European Commission to act?
Two groups can file a written complaint with the Commission. Anyone acting on behalf of an EU industry that suffers injury on the EU market can complain (Article 3). A Union enterprise, or an association acting for one or more of them, that suffers adverse trade effects on a non-EU market can also complain (Article 4).
A Union enterprise is a company formed under the law of an EU Member State, with its registered office, central administration or principal place of business in the EU, that is directly concerned by the production of the goods or services subject to the obstacle (Article 2(1)(f)). A Dutch BV that produces the goods concerned and exports them to the country concerned can qualify; a pure trading company may not, because the definition requires direct involvement in the production of the goods or the provision of the services. A company established outside the EU is not itself a Union enterprise; its EU subsidiary may be, if it is directly concerned.
The adverse effects must have a material impact on the economy of the EU, a region of the EU or a sector; the fact that the complainant alone suffers is not enough on its own (Article 2(1)(d)). An association acting for one or more Union enterprises can file the complaint on their behalf (Article 4(1)). Member States can also ask the Commission to start the procedure (Article 6).
How does the complaint procedure work?
The complaint goes to the Commission, which sends a copy to the Member States and must decide within 45 days whether to open an examination procedure (Article 5). That period can be suspended at the complainant’s request or with its consent, to provide further information (Article 5(4)).
| Step | What happens | Article |
|---|---|---|
| Complaint | Written complaint with sufficient evidence of the obstacle and its effects | Articles 3, 4 and 11 |
| Decision to open | Within 45 days of the complaint | Article 5(4) |
| Examination | Notice in the Official Journal; contact with the country concerned; hearing of parties who request it in time | Article 9(1) and (5) |
| Report | To the Trade Barriers Committee within five months of the notice, or seven months in complex cases | Article 9(8) |
| Outcome | Termination, suspension (for example after satisfactory measures by the country concerned), international dispute settlement or commercial policy measures | Articles 12 to 14 |
Evidence of adverse trade effects is assessed on the basis of factors such as volumes, prices and their effect on production, sales and market share (Article 11). Business information can be submitted in confidence, but you must explain why, and add a non-confidential summary or a statement of why it cannot be summarised (Article 10(2)). If the EU acts, possible measures include suspending trade concessions, raising customs duties on imports from the country concerned, or quantitative restrictions (Article 13(3)).
Does an EU complaint help you with your contracts?
Not directly. A complaint is aimed at removing the foreign measure. After the examination is announced, the Commission reports to the Trade Barriers Committee within five months, or seven in complex cases (Article 9(8)). In the meantime, your contracts decide who bears the cost of a tariff, a ban or a sanction. That is a matter of contract law, and under Dutch law of three rules in particular (Articles 6:75, 6:258 and 6:265 DCC).
- Force majeure (overmacht): a failure in performance cannot be attributed to the debtor if it is not its fault and is not for its account by law, juridical act or generally accepted views (Article 6:75 DCC). A ban that makes delivery impossible can qualify; a tariff that only makes performance more expensive usually does not.
- Unforeseen circumstances: on a party’s claim, the court can amend the effects of a contract, or dissolve it in whole or in part, if unforeseen circumstances are such that the other party may not expect the contract to be maintained unchanged (Article 6:258 DCC). No amendment or dissolution is ordered to the extent the circumstances are for the account of the party invoking them, by the nature of the contract or by generally accepted views (Article 6:258(2)).
- Dissolution (ontbinding): any failure to perform gives the other party the right to dissolve the contract in whole or in part, unless the failure is too minor to justify it (Article 6:265(1) DCC). Where performance is not permanently or temporarily impossible, that right arises only once the debtor is in default (Article 6:265(2)). A failure that cannot be attributed to the debtor still allows dissolution, but gives no right to damages (Article 6:74(1) DCC).
More on these rules is on our pages on force majeure in the Netherlands and on unforeseen circumstances under Dutch law.
Important: Do not suspend deliveries or refuse a price increase on a new tariff alone. A tariff that only raises cost is usually not force majeure, and a court does not amend a contract to the extent the risk is for your account (Article 6:258(2) DCC). Have a Dutch contract lawyer assess your position and your clauses first.
Is a new tariff, import ban or sanction affecting a contract with a Dutch partner? Have a Dutch contract lawyer assess your position before you suspend deliveries or refuse a price increase.
Which clauses protect you against trade barriers?
Clauses that name the risk and its consequences leave less room for argument. A general force majeure clause leaves room for argument about whether a tariff or a sanction is covered; a specific clause decides it in advance and avoids reliance on Articles 6:75 and 6:258 DCC.
- Force majeure and sanctions
- Price and customs duties
- Suspension and termination
- Alternative sourcing or delivery routes
- Choice of law and forum
If these clauses are in general terms and conditions used between a Dutch and a foreign business, the Dutch rules on unreasonably onerous clauses do not apply, because the parties are not both established in the Netherlands (Article 6:247(2) DCC). Only the general test of reasonableness and fairness remains (Article 6:248(2) DCC). The clauses must therefore be clear on their own. See also our page on choosing Dutch law in international contracts.
Important: Clauses in general terms and conditions between a Dutch and a foreign business are outside the Dutch rules on unreasonably onerous terms, but not outside the test of reasonableness and fairness (Article 6:248(2) DCC). A Dutch contract lawyer can check whether your wording holds up before you rely on it.
Example: a Dutch exporter facing an import ban
Suppose a Dutch manufacturer of machine parts supplies a buyer in a non-EU country under a three-year supply agreement governed by Dutch law. The country introduces an import ban on the parts, which the manufacturer and its trade association consider contrary to that country’s WTO commitments.
Under its contract, the manufacturer checks whether the ban is listed as force majeure and whether it may suspend deliveries. If the contract is silent, it relies on Article 6:75 DCC for the deliveries that have become impossible. At the same time, its trade association collects data on lost exports from several EU producers and files a complaint with the Commission under Article 4 of the Trade Barriers Regulation. The two routes run separately: the complaint may remove the ban in the longer term, while the contract determines the losses in the meantime.
Our international trade law page gives an overview of the topic, and our page on exporting goods to the EU covers the import side.
Frequently asked questions about trade barriers
Can a non-EU company file a complaint under the Trade Barriers Regulation?
Not under Article 4 as such, which requires a Union enterprise or an association acting for Union enterprises (Article 2(1)(f) Regulation (EU) 2015/1843). An EU subsidiary directly concerned may qualify, and Article 3 lets a person act for a Union industry injured on the EU market.
How quickly does the Commission decide on a complaint?
It decides within 45 days of the complaint whether to open an examination procedure; that period may be suspended at the complainant’s request or with its agreement, to provide further information (Article 5(4) Regulation (EU) 2015/1843). If an examination is opened, the Commission reports within five months of the announcement, or seven in complex cases (Article 9(8)).
Is a new import tariff force majeure under Dutch law?
Usually not. A tariff makes performance more expensive, not impossible. It is force majeure if the contract says so, or if the failure is not due to your fault and is not for your account by law, juridical act or generally accepted views (Article 6:75 DCC).
Can a Dutch court change my price because of new tariffs?
Only if the conditions of Article 6:258 DCC are met: the circumstances must be unforeseen and of such a kind that the other party may not, by standards of reasonableness and fairness, expect the contract to be maintained unchanged. No amendment follows to the extent the risk is for your account (Article 6:258(2)). A price review clause is more reliable.
Does an EU complaint suspend my contractual obligations?
No. A complaint concerns the measure of the foreign country, not your contract. Your contract and Dutch contract law continue to determine what you owe your contract partner, so check your force majeure, price and sanctions clauses while the Commission examines the measure.
Primary sources
Dutch statutes are published in Dutch on wetten.overheid.nl. Judgments can be found on rechtspraak.nl by their ECLI number.
- Regulation (EU) 2015/1843 (Trade Barriers Regulation): Articles 1-6 and 9-13
- Dutch Civil Code Book 6: Article 6:74, Article 6:75, Article 6:247, Article 6:248, Article 6:258, Article 6:265