Creditor protection under Dutch law

Share this article

WhatsAppLinkedIn

Published on · Last updated

Under Dutch law, a creditor can use the actio pauliana to annul a legal act that the debtor was not obliged to perform, if the debtor knew or ought to have known that it would prejudice creditors’ recourse (Article 3:45 Dutch Civil Code). In a bankruptcy, the trustee has a similar power (Article 42 Dutch Bankruptcy Act).

In short

  • A gift can be annulled on the debtor’s knowledge alone; for a sale, the buyer must also have known or ought to have known (Article 3:45(1), (2)).
  • Knowledge is presumed, but can be rebutted, for certain acts within one year, such as a deal that heavily favours the other side (Articles 3:46, 3:47).
  • In bankruptcy the trustee annuls for the estate (Article 42 Bankruptcy Act); a creditor’s own annulment works only for that creditor (Article 3:45(4)).
  • The one-year presumption periods and the three-year limit (Articles 3:46, 3:52) make the timing of any step a question for a Dutch lawyer.

Under the actio pauliana, any creditor whose recourse is prejudiced by the act can invoke the ground for annulment, whether its claim arose before or after the act (Article 3:45(1)). If the act was not gratuitous, the creditor must also show that the persons with whom the debtor performed the act knew or ought to have known of the prejudice (Article 3:45(2)). The annulment takes place by an extrajudicial declaration or by a court decision (Article 3:49). An act concerning registered property, such as real estate, that has led to an entry in the public registers can only be annulled by declaration if all parties accept the annulment (Article 3:50(2)); otherwise a court decision is needed.

Three conditions apply: the debtor was not obliged to perform the act, the act prejudices the recourse of one or more creditors, and the debtor knew or ought to have known this (Article 3:45(1)). If the act is gratuitous, such as a gift, the debtor’s knowledge is sufficient to annul it.

For example, if the debtor has given assets to a friend to put them beyond the reach of his creditors, it is not necessary that the friend knew that the gift would prejudice the creditors. A friend who neither knew nor ought to have known this is only protected to the extent that he shows that he was not enriched by the gift when the annulment was invoked (Article 3:45(3)). If the act was not gratuitous, for example a sale, the annulment only succeeds if the buyer also knew or ought to have known of the prejudice (Article 3:45(2)).

Important: Suppose a debtor sells an asset to a group company shortly before a creditor sues. Whether annulment succeeds depends on what each side knew, on the timing in relation to the one-year period (Article 3:46) and on the evidence. Have a Dutch lawyer review the transaction history before you invoke annulment or answer such a claim.

If you are weighing whether to challenge or defend a transaction, our litigation lawyers can review the facts and the periods that apply.

What are the effects of an annulment under the actio pauliana?

A creditor annuls the act only for its own benefit and only as far as needed to remove the prejudice it suffered (Article 3:45(4)). As a result, the act in principle remains valid in all other respects. Rights that third parties acquired in good faith and for value on the assets concerned are respected. A third party in good faith who acquired for free is protected only to the extent that he shows that he is not enriched by the act when the asset is claimed from him (Article 3:45(5)).

Who has to prove knowledge of the prejudice?

A creditor who invokes annulment bears, as a rule, the burden of proving the facts on which it relies (Article 150 Code of Civil Procedure): the debtor’s knowledge and, for an act that is not gratuitous, the knowledge of the other party. Because knowledge is not directly observable, the Civil Code presumes it for certain acts. The debtor or the other party can then try to rebut the presumption (Articles 3:46 and 3:47).

When does Dutch law presume knowledge of the prejudice?

The presumptions only apply to acts performed within one year before the annulment is invoked, and only if the debtor had not already committed itself to the act before that year began (Article 3:46(1)). Knowledge on both sides is then presumed for, among others:

  • contracts in which the debtor’s obligation considerably exceeds the value of the other party’s obligation;
  • payment of, or security for, a debt that is not yet due;
  • acts with the debtor’s partner or relatives up to the third degree, and acts between a company and its directors or commissioners, shareholders holding at least half of the issued capital, their relatives, or group companies (Article 3:46(1), items 3 to 6).

For a gratuitous act within one year before the annulment is invoked, the debtor’s knowledge is presumed (Article 3:47). The debtor or the other party can rebut these presumptions.

How does the actio pauliana work in a Dutch bankruptcy?

In a bankruptcy, the trustee (curator) can annul, by an extrajudicial declaration and for the benefit of the estate, a legal act that the debtor performed before the bankruptcy order without being obliged to do so, if the debtor knew or ought to have known that it would prejudice the creditors (Article 42 Dutch Bankruptcy Act). If the act was not gratuitous, the other party must also have known or ought to have known this (Article 42(2)). The trustee’s declaration is not limited by the rule on registered property in Article 3:50(2) (Article 42(1)). Presumptions of knowledge apply to acts within one year before the bankruptcy order (Articles 43 and 45). Payment of a debt that was already due can be annulled only if the recipient knew that bankruptcy had already been applied for (and the application was not suspended), or if the payment resulted from collusion to favour that creditor (Article 47). Claims on these grounds are brought by the trustee (Article 49(1)). Creditors can, on the same grounds, contest the admission of a claim (Article 49(2)).

Important: Suppose a debtor pays one supplier in full shortly before its bankruptcy. Whether the trustee can annul the payment depends on whether the debt was due, on what the supplier knew and on whether the payment was agreed to favour that supplier (Articles 42 and 47 Bankruptcy Act). Have a Dutch lawyer review the payment history before you accept, return or contest a payment.

How else does Dutch law protect creditors?

A creditor can in principle recover its claim from all assets of its debtor, unless the law or an agreement provides otherwise (Article 3:276 Dutch Civil Code). Creditors share equally in the proceeds in proportion to their claims, subject to statutory grounds for priority (Article 3:277(1)). Before a judgment, a creditor can ask the preliminary relief judge (voorzieningenrechter), by petition, for leave to attach assets as a protective measure (conservatoir beslag); the judge decides after a summary examination. Unless proceedings on the merits are already pending, the creditor must start them within the period set by the judge, at least eight days after the attachment (Article 700(1)-(3) Code of Civil Procedure). Enforcing a judgment is covered in our page on enforcement of a judgment; liability of directors towards creditors rests on separate grounds, see director and supervisory board liability.

Frequently asked questions about creditor protection under Dutch law

What is the actio pauliana under Dutch law?

It allows a creditor to annul a legal act that the debtor was not obliged to perform, if the debtor knew or ought to have known that the act would prejudice its creditors (Article 3:45(1) Dutch Civil Code). For other acts, the other party must also have known or ought to have known this (Article 3:45(2)).

Does the recipient of a gift have to know about the prejudice?

No. For a gratuitous act, the debtor’s knowledge is enough. A recipient in good faith is only protected to the extent that he shows he was not enriched by the gift when the annulment was invoked (Article 3:45(3)).

How long does a creditor have to invoke the actio pauliana?

The claim for annulment becomes time-barred three years after the prejudice was discovered (Article 3:52(1)(c) Dutch Civil Code). After that, the act can no longer be annulled on the same ground by extrajudicial declaration either (Article 3:52(2)).

Can a creditor annul a transaction without going to court?

Yes, by an extrajudicial declaration to the parties to the act (Articles 3:49 and 3:50(1)). For an act concerning registered property, such as real estate, this only works if all parties accept the annulment (Article 3:50(2)); otherwise a court decision is needed.

Who can use the actio pauliana when the debtor is bankrupt?

In bankruptcy, the trustee annuls prejudicial acts for the benefit of the estate (Article 42 Dutch Bankruptcy Act) and brings claims on these grounds (Article 49(1)). Creditors can, on the same grounds, contest the admission of a claim (Article 49(2)).

When should you involve a Dutch lawyer in a creditor dispute?

Before you invoke annulment, answer an annulment claim or accept a payment from a debtor in financial difficulty. The knowledge of the parties, the one-year presumption periods and the three-year time limit decide the outcome (Articles 3:46 and 3:52), and an extrajudicial declaration about registered property needs the consent of all parties (Article 3:50(2)).

Primary sources

  • Dutch Civil Code (Burgerlijk Wetboek) Book 3: Articles 3:45, 3:46, 3:47, 3:49, 3:50, 3:52, 3:276 and 3:277
  • Dutch Bankruptcy Act (Faillissementswet): Articles 42, 43, 45, 47 and 49
  • Code of Civil Procedure (Wetboek van Burgerlijke Rechtsvordering): Articles 150 and 700

Discuss a creditor claim with a Dutch lawyer

Whether you want to challenge a transaction as a creditor or defend one as a debtor or recipient, the knowledge of the parties, the timing and the evidence decide the outcome. A Dutch lawyer can review the facts and the applicable periods with you. Contact Remko Roosjen to discuss your situation.

News & Insights
Which topics would you like to receive updates on?
Who are you?
Which industry or sector do you operate in? (Optional)