Management buy-out under Dutch law

Share this article

WhatsAppLinkedIn

Published on · Last updated

A management buy-out (MBO) under Dutch law is a takeover of a company in which its existing managers buy the business, usually through a new holding company and with external financing. Shares in a Dutch BV are transferred by notarial deed (Article 2:196 Dutch Civil Code, DCC), subject to any transfer restrictions in the articles of association (Article 2:195 DCC).

In an MBO, the buyers know the company well and usually already have a working relationship with the shareholders, staff, customers and financiers. That can make the transfer smoother than a sale to an outsider. Typical situations are:

  • a founder or family shareholder who wants to retire and has no successor within the family;
  • a group that wants to sell a business unit, which the local management then continues as an independent company;
  • a private equity investor that sells its stake and the management buys it out, often with a new investor.

The legal framework is mainly Book 2 of the Dutch Civil Code (Burgerlijk Wetboek) for the share transfer, the financing and the duties of the managers. For the wider context, see our page on Dutch corporate law.

How does a management buy-out work in the Netherlands?

Most MBOs are structured in one of two ways:

  • Share deal. The managers, usually through a newly incorporated holding company, buy the shares in the company that runs the business. The company itself stays the same legal entity, with its contracts, employees, assets and debts. Shares in a BV, and registered shares in an NV (other than shares in a securities giro system under Article 2:86c DCC), are transferred by a deed executed before a civil-law notary established in the Netherlands (Article 2:196(1) DCC; for an NV, Article 2:86(1) DCC). Unless the articles of association provide otherwise, a BV shareholder who wants to sell must first offer the shares to the co-shareholders (Article 2:195(1) DCC). The articles can also restrict the transfer in another way, for example by requiring approval (Article 2:195(4) DCC).
  • Asset deal. The buying company acquires the business itself: assets, contracts and, where agreed, liabilities. Each asset is transferred under its own rules, and a party can only transfer its contract position by a deed between it and the third party, with the cooperation of the counterparty (Article 6:159(1) DCC). If the transaction is a transfer of an economic entity that retains its identity, the employment contracts transfer by operation of law to the buyer (Article 7:662(1) and 7:663 DCC). The seller remains jointly and severally liable for one year for obligations from those contracts that arose before the transfer (Article 7:663 DCC). These rules do not apply if the employer has been declared bankrupt and the business belongs to the bankruptcy estate (Article 7:666(a) DCC).

The purchase price is usually financed by a combination of the managers’ own funds, a bank loan to the holding company, an investor that takes a stake, and sometimes a vendor loan, where the seller leaves part of the price outstanding. Whether the target company itself may contribute to that financing is restricted by law; see the next sections. Tax aspects, such as the structuring of the holding company and the treatment of the managers’ investment, are outside the scope of this page and require separate tax advice.

What is the difference between a management buy-out and a management buy-in?

In a management buy-out, the company is bought by its current managers. In a management buy-in (MBI), external managers buy the company and take over its management. A combination of both is sometimes called a BIMBO (buy-in management buy-out).

Financiers and investors often value an MBO because the buyers know the business. An MBI can bring new expertise, but the buyers depend more on due diligence and on information from the seller. In both cases, the buyer acquires an existing business and avoids the start-up phase of a new company. That is usually reflected in the price: the seller, who often built up the business, expects to be paid for it. There is also a risk that customers, suppliers or partners do not want to continue with the new owner, for example because a contract allows termination on a change of control. Raise these points early in the negotiations, and check key contracts for change-of-control clauses.

Can the company itself help finance a management buy-out?

Lenders often want the target company to provide security for the acquisition loan, or want its cash flow to repay that loan. Dutch law limits this, and the rules differ for an NV and a BV.

NV (public limited company). An NV may not provide security, give a price guarantee, otherwise guarantee performance or bind itself jointly and severally or otherwise alongside or for others, with a view to the subscription for or acquisition by others of shares in its capital or depositary receipts for them. This prohibition also applies to its subsidiaries (Article 2:98c(1) DCC). Loans for that purpose are only allowed if the management board decides so and the conditions of Article 2:98c(2) DCC are met: fair market terms, equity which, after deducting the loan, is not less than the paid-up and called-up capital plus the reserves required by law or the articles, a careful examination of the creditworthiness of the counterparty and, in certain cases, a fair price for the shares. The NV must keep a non-distributable reserve equal to the loans (Article 2:98c(4) DCC), and the board resolution requires the prior approval of the general meeting (Article 2:98c(5) DCC). Paragraphs 1 to 7 do not apply when shares are acquired by or for employees of the company or of a group company (Article 2:98c(8) DCC); whether that exception covers a particular MBO depends on who acquires the shares.

BV (private limited company). The specific prohibition for the BV (Article 2:207c DCC) was repealed with effect from 1 October 2012. A BV may therefore in principle provide security or financing for the acquisition of its own shares. Other rules still apply:

  • A distribution to shareholders, for example a dividend to the buying holding company to repay acquisition debt, has no effect as long as the management board has not approved it. The board only refuses approval if it knows or should reasonably foresee that the company will not be able to continue paying its due and payable debts after the distribution (Article 2:216(2) DCC). Directors who knew or should reasonably have foreseen this are jointly and severally liable to the company for the resulting shortfall, and a recipient of the distribution who knew or should reasonably have foreseen this must compensate the shortfall up to the amount or value received (Article 2:216(3) DCC).
  • If the BV buys back its own shares from the seller as part of the deal, it may not acquire fully paid-up shares other than for no consideration if its equity minus the price is less than the reserves required by law or the articles, or if the board knows or should reasonably foresee that the company will then be unable to continue paying its due debts (Article 2:207(2) DCC). Directors, and a seller who knew or should reasonably have foreseen this, can be liable for the shortfall (Article 2:207(3) DCC).
  • In every case, the directors must act in the interest of the company and its business (Article 2:239(5) DCC), and each director must perform his duties properly towards the company (Article 2:9(1) DCC).

What are the duties of a manager who is also the buyer?

In an MBO, the managers sit on both sides: they run the company and want to buy it. They remain bound by their duties as directors until the transfer. In the performance of their duties, the directors must act in the interest of the company and its business (Article 2:239(5) DCC for a BV; Article 2:129(5) DCC for an NV). A director does not take part in the deliberation and decision-making if he has a direct or indirect personal interest that conflicts with that interest. If no board resolution can be taken as a result, the supervisory board decides; if there is none, the general meeting decides, unless the articles of association provide otherwise (Article 2:239(6) DCC; Article 2:129(6) DCC for an NV). This can matter, for example, when the company is asked to provide security or information for the buyers’ financing.

Because the managers know the business from the inside, the seller may argue that it should give fewer warranties than in a sale to an outsider. Agree in the share purchase agreement which warranties are given and how the managers’ own knowledge affects claims under them. Also agree in advance how confidential company information may be shared with banks and investors.

Does the works council have to be consulted?

An entrepreneur (ondernemer) with a business in which as a rule at least 50 persons work must set up a works council (Article 2(1) Works Councils Act, WOR). The entrepreneur must give the works council the opportunity to advise on any proposed decision to transfer control of the business or a part of it (Article 25(1)(a) WOR). The advice must be requested at a time when it can still have a material influence on the decision (Article 25(2) WOR). Unless the decision follows the advice, the entrepreneur must suspend its implementation for one month after informing the works council, unless the works council indicates that this is not necessary (Article 25(6) WOR). Whether the advice right applies in a specific MBO depends on which entity takes the decision and on the structure of the deal.

What are the steps in a management buy-out under Dutch law?

A typical MBO under Dutch law follows these steps:

  1. Preparation. Discuss the intention with the shareholders, agree on confidentiality and check the articles of association and any shareholders’ agreement for transfer restrictions.
  2. Valuation and due diligence. Value the business and investigate its legal, financial and tax position, even though the managers know it well.
  3. Financing. Arrange the bank loan, investor and any vendor loan, and check the statutory limits on financing by the company itself (Articles 2:98c, 2:207 and 2:216 DCC).
  4. Letter of intent. Record the main terms in a letter of intent or memorandum of understanding, and state which provisions are binding.
  5. Works council. Where Article 25 WOR applies, request advice in time.
  6. Share purchase agreement. Negotiate the price, warranties, conditions and any earn-out.
  7. Closing. Execute the notarial deed of transfer (Article 2:196 DCC), pay the price and update the shareholders’ register.

Frequently asked questions about a management buy-out under Dutch law

What is a management buy-out in the Netherlands?

A takeover in which the existing managers buy the company or a part of it, usually through a holding company and with external financing. In a share deal, the BV shares are transferred by notarial deed (Article 2:196 DCC), subject to the transfer restrictions in the articles of association (Article 2:195 DCC).

What is the difference between a management buy-out and a management buy-in?

In a management buy-out, the current managers buy the company. In a management buy-in, external managers buy it and take over its management. The legal steps are largely the same; the difference is mainly in the buyers’ knowledge of the business and in the due diligence.

What rules apply to a management buyout under Dutch company law?

The main rules are the notarial transfer of shares (Article 2:196 DCC), the transfer restrictions (Article 2:195 DCC), the limits on financing by the company (Article 2:98c DCC for an NV; Articles 2:207 and 2:216 DCC for a BV) and the conflict-of-interest rule for directors (Article 2:239(6) DCC; for an NV Article 2:129(6) DCC).

Can a Dutch BV provide security for the financing of its own management buy-out?

The specific prohibition for the BV (Article 2:207c DCC) was repealed with effect from 1 October 2012. The directors must still act in the interest of the company (Article 2:239(5) DCC), and distributions to repay acquisition debt are subject to the distribution test of Article 2:216(2) DCC. For an NV, Article 2:98c DCC still prohibits such security.

What should a management buy-out checklist include?

At least: transfer restrictions in the articles and shareholders’ agreement, valuation and due diligence, financing and the statutory limits on financing by the company, change-of-control clauses in key contracts, conflicts of interest of the managers, the works council’s advice right where it applies (Article 25(1)(a) WOR), the share purchase agreement and the notarial deed of transfer.

Primary sources

When should you involve a Dutch corporate lawyer in a management buy-out?

Involve a lawyer before you sign a letter of intent, so that the structure, financing and conditions are set up correctly from the start. The corporate lawyers of MAAK Advocaten advise managers, sellers and investors on management buy-outs and other company law matters in the Netherlands, from the first negotiations to the notarial transfer. Do you have a question about a management buy-out or buy-in in the Netherlands? Please contact us.

News & Insights
Which topics would you like to receive updates on?
Who are you?
Which industry or sector do you operate in? (Optional)