Conflict of Interest Between a Manager and a Company in the Netherlands

Share this article

WhatsAppLinkedIn

Published on · Last updated

Under Dutch law, a director (bestuurder) of a BV or NV has a conflict of interest (tegenstrijdig belang) if he or she has a direct or indirect personal interest that conflicts with the interest of the company and its business. That director may not take part in the board’s deliberations and decision-making on the matter (Article 2:239(6) Dutch Civil Code for the BV; Article 2:129(6) for the NV).

In this article, “manager” means a statutory director. A manager who is an employee but not a director is not covered by the statutory rule; he or she must act as a good employee (Article 7:611 DCC) and follow the employer’s internal rules. Below we explain when a conflict exists, what the board must do and what happens if the rule is ignored. Our team also advises on Corporate law in the Netherlands.

What are the key takeaways?

  • Conflict definition: a director has a conflict of interest if he or she has a direct or indirect personal interest that conflicts with the interest of the company and its business (Article 2:239(6) DCC; Article 2:129(6) for the NV).
  • Identifying Conflicts: Early identification and management of conflicts are crucial to maintaining integrity and objectivity in decision-making processes.
  • Disclosure and abstention: the conflicted director may not take part in deliberations and decision-making (Article 2:239(6) DCC). The Civil Code has no explicit disclosure duty, but the director should inform the board so that the rule can be applied; the articles of association or board regulations may require this.
  • Impact on Work Environment: Untreated conflicts can create a toxic work environment, resulting in decreased morale and productivity and legal consequences for the manager.
  • Resolution and consequences: if no board resolution can be adopted because of the conflict, the supervisory board decides, or without one the general meeting, unless the articles provide otherwise. A resolution adopted in breach of the rule is voidable (Article 2:15 DCC), and a director who can be seriously blamed may be liable towards the company (Article 2:9 DCC).

What Is a Conflict of Interest under Dutch law?

Under Article 2:239(6) DCC, a director has a conflict of interest if he or she has a direct or indirect personal interest that conflicts with the interest of the company and its business. The statute does not define this further. Under the former rule, the Dutch Supreme Court held that it is not required that the company is actually harmed: it is enough that the director has such incompatible interests that it can reasonably be doubted whether he or she was guided solely by the interest of the company and its business, judged on all circumstances of the case (HR 29 June 2007, ECLI:NL:HR:2007:BA0033, Bruil, r.o. 3.4).

This situation can lead to influencing decisions that put the company’s needs on the back burner while favoring personal gains. It’s central to identify and manage such conflicts, as they can seriously undermine trust, integrity, and impartiality in managerial roles.

A manager’s personal interests can manifest in various ways, such as financial entanglements or personal relationships. These interests may subtly manifest in their decision-making processes, potentially leading to biased choices that benefit them rather than the company. To maintain a morally sound and responsible workplace, it’s imperative to recognize and address these conflicts early on.

A conflicted director must refrain from participating in deliberations and decisions on that matter; that duty is statutory (Article 2:239(6) DCC). The Civil Code does not contain an explicit duty to disclose conflicts of interest, but in practice the board can only apply the rule if the director reports the conflict. Doing so helps to maintain the integrity and objectivity of decision-making.

Can a conflict of interest damage the working environment?

By allowing personal interests to cloud their judgment, managers can inadvertently create a hostile work environment, which can have significant impacts on employees and the organization as a whole.

This toxic setting can lead to decreased employee morale and productivity, In the end, affecting the company’s overall performance.

When conflicts between managers and the company remain unresolved, they can manifest into a hostile work environment, causing substantial damage. The negative impact on mental health shouldn’t be underestimated, as employees may experience stress, anxiety, and burnout. Additionally, a hostile work environment can result in increased employee turnover rates and recruitment challenges.

There can also be legal implications. The employer must pursue a policy to prevent or limit psychosocial workload, which includes aggression, discrimination, bullying and sexual harassment (Article 3(2) Working Conditions Act, with the definition in Article 1(1)). A manager who harasses or treats employees unfairly can face consequences under employment law and contributes to a tarnished reputation of the company.

It’s essential for companies to take proactive measures to address and resolve conflicts between managers and the company to maintain a healthy work environment and secure long-term success.

Which ethical dilemmas arise?

Given your managerial position, you may encounter challenging decisions where your personal interests clash with those of the company, sparking ethical and moral dilemmas that require careful consideration. These dilemmas can create significant stress as you balance your personal values against the company’s expectations.

One important consideration is your fiduciary duty to the organization and its stakeholders. For example, your managerial duties may lead you to choose between recommending a supplier despite having a close personal friendship with its owner, or even selecting an investment option that vaguely benefits you or a family member.

Proper handling of these dilemmas is crucial. Developing a framework for ethical decision-making guarantees consistency and fairness in your choices. This can include consulting with colleagues, checking company policies, and utilizing established ethical guidelines to guide your actions. Transparency and accountability are also vital in effectively resolving ethical conflicts.

If you’re torn between your personal values and the organizational expectations, don’t hesitate to seek guidance from those you trust or, if necessary, to escalate the matter to higher management. By following these principles, you can strengthen your professional integrity and make informed decisions that align with both your personal values and the company’s best interests.

What is the impact on morale and productivity?

Conflicts of interest between managers and companies markedly diminish employee morale due to perceived favoritism or biased decision-making. This type of conflict creates distrust among team members, who feel that the manager is prioritizing personal interests over the company’s goals.

Such biases can lead to decreased productivity as employees become disillusioned with the workings of the organization.

IssueEffect on MoraleImpact on Productivity
Biased Decision MakingEmployees feel treated unfairlyDisapproving attitudes towards decision makers
Personal Interest Over Company GoalsEmployees feel management is ineffectiveLack of commitment to achieving objectives
Favoritism Among EmployeesPromotions not based on meritDemotivation due to unequal opportunities

Implementing clear policies and procedures to handle conflicts of interest is essential to limit these negative effects. Open communication about conflict resolution processes helps to create a sense of fairness and trust among employees. By addressing these conflicts promptly, you can maintain a positive work environment and enhance team productivity. By doing so, the organization can focus on achieving its primary objectives without disruptions.

Can a conflict of interest create an unfair advantage?

The actions of managers creating unfair competitive advantages by breaching fiduciary duties can be detrimental to a company’s overall performance.

When you exploit your position for personal gain, you act against your statutory duty as a director to be guided by the interest of the company and its business (Article 2:239(5) DCC; Article 2:129(5) for the NV).

Moreover, using company resources or opportunities to advance your personal interests creates an unfair edge and erodes trust among colleagues. Engaging in activities that compromise the company’s competitiveness can lead to serious legal and professional consequences. Violating ethical standards by prioritizing personal interests over the company’s welfare must be addressed through consistent ethical messages and proactive training.

In the long run, amoral management can perpetuate unethical behavior, further undermining the company’s foundations. It’s imperative for managers to recognize their responsibilities and set the right ethical example for employees, supporting a culture where everyone adheres to and respects the company’s best interests.

How does it affect trust?

When managers fail to address conflicts of interest, it can significantly erode trust between you and your employer. This occurs when a manager’s personal interests clash with their ability to make decisions solely in the company’s best interests.

Subsequently, it leads to ethical dilemmas, breach of fiduciary duties, and potential legal consequences. Transparency and proper handling of conflicts of interest are vital to maintaining trust and integrity within the organization.

Effects of Conflicts of InterestImpact on Employer-Employee Relationship
Erosion of TrustEmployees become suspicious of the manager’s motives
Breach of LoyaltyThe manager is seen as more loyal to their personal interests than to the company
Decreased CollaborationEmployees are less likely to work with the manager or share valuable information

Clear policies and procedures for addressing conflicts of interest can help reduce these risks and uphold ethical standards in the workplace. When conflicts are handled openly and effectively, trust can be preserved, and a more harmonious work environment can be maintained.

The legal consequences follow from Book 2 of the Dutch Civil Code: they concern the validity of the resolution and the liability of the director.

A board resolution adopted with the participation of a conflicted director is voidable, as a breach of a statutory provision on how resolutions are adopted (Article 2:15(1)(a) DCC). Annulment is pronounced by the district court on a claim by someone with a reasonable interest in compliance, or by the company itself, and the right to claim lapses one year after the resolution was sufficiently made known or the interested party became aware of it (Article 2:15(3) and (5)). A voidable resolution can be confirmed by a new resolution (Article 2:15(6)). Separately, a director may be liable towards the company for improper performance of duties, but only if he or she can be seriously blamed (Article 2:9 DCC; HR 10 January 1997, ECLI:NL:HR:1997:ZC2243, r.o. 3.3.1). Whether the company is bound towards a third party is a different question: the board’s power of representation is unlimited and unconditional, except where the law provides otherwise (Article 2:240(3) DCC; Article 2:130(3) for the NV).

Violations of fiduciary duties typically result in financial repercussions for the company and potentially for the manager involved. These breaches undermine the trust placed in management and can have lasting impacts on the company’s reputation and standings.

To avoid these consequences, a director must comply with the statutory rule: stay out of deliberations and decision-making when a conflict exists, and report the conflict so that the board can apply the rule.

Strict adherence to codes of conduct and ethical guidelines is essential to ensure that managerial decisions align with company interests, preventing legal repercussions and preserving the trust bestowed upon management. By doing so, managers can uphold their contractual obligations and protect the company from detrimental actions stemming from conflicts of interest.

How do you deal with a conflict of interest?

The steps below follow the statutory rule for directors (Article 2:239(6) DCC) and good practice.

Dealing With Conflicting Situations

To maintain transparency and the integrity of a company’s decision-making processes, prompt and clear disclosure of conflicts of interest by managers is essential in dealing with conflicting situations effectively.

When a conflict of interest arises, effective management is important. Here are key strategies to handle such situations:

  1. Recognize and Disclose: Managers should acknowledge and report conflicts of interest to the board, ensuring transparency and accountability.
  2. Recusal: The conflicted manager must refrain from decision-making in situations where their personal interests clash with the company’s.
  3. Independent decision-making: the other directors decide without the conflicted director. If no board resolution can be adopted as a result, for example because there is a sole director, the supervisory board decides; without a supervisory board, the general meeting decides, unless the articles of association provide otherwise (Article 2:239(6) DCC).
  4. Establish Clear Policies: Companies should have well-defined policies and procedures for managing conflicts of interest, outlining consequences for non-compliance.

When is disclosure not enough?

Reporting a conflict is not enough on its own: the statute requires the conflicted director to stay out of the decision.

You must recognize that full transparency arises from not just disclosing conflicts but also from ensuring that the disclosed conflicts are effectively managed and prominently addressed. While simply disclosing a conflict may seem like a necessary step, it’s only the beginning. The key is to actively work towards resolving and reducing the impacts of these conflicts. Mere disclosure without meaningful action can lead to escalating conflicts and the perception of hidden agendas.

If a director has a direct or indirect personal interest that conflicts with the interest of the company and its business, he or she does not take part in the deliberations and decision-making on that matter (Article 2:239(6) DCC; Article 2:129(6) for the NV). The same applies to supervisory directors (Article 2:250(5) DCC; Article 2:140(5) for the NV). Following the rule helps prevent legal challenges and safeguards the credibility of the management team.

Proper conflict management covers both compliance and ensuring that the company’s objectives are pursued without compromising loyalty and trust.

How is a conflict resolved?

If the conflict of interest is not handled correctly, a resolution adopted with the conflicted director’s participation can be annulled by the court (Article 2:15 DCC), and the director may be personally liable towards the company if he or she can be seriously blamed (Article 2:9 DCC). This highlights the importance of effective resolution strategies.

To protect yourself and the company, consider the following steps:

  1. Shift decision-making authority:

If, because of the conflict, the board cannot adopt a resolution, the decision moves to the supervisory board; if there is none, to the general meeting, unless the articles of association provide otherwise (Article 2:239(6) DCC).

  1. Document everything:

Maintain detailed records of conflict disclosures, the resolution process, and the actions taken to limit potential biases.

  1. Seek external guidance:

Consult legal or professional experts to make certain compliance with statutory regulations and best practices in conflict resolution.

  1. Establish clear policies:

Develop and implement broad policies on conflicts of interest to provide clear guidelines for directors and employees.

Frequently asked questions about conflicts of interest between a manager and a company

What is a conflict of interest?

In Dutch company law, a director has a conflict of interest (tegenstrijdig belang) if he or she has a direct or indirect personal interest that conflicts with the interest of the company and its business (Article 2:239(6) DCC for the BV; Article 2:129(6) for the NV). Under the former rule, the Supreme Court held that it is enough that it can reasonably be doubted whether the director was guided solely by the company’s interest (HR 29 June 2007, Bruil, r.o. 3.4).

What are examples of a conflict of interest in business?

Typical examples are a contract between the company and the director personally, a contract with another company in which the director has a significant stake, or a decision that benefits a close family member of the director. Whether a conflict exists always depends on all circumstances of the case (Bruil, r.o. 3.4-3.5).

What are the consequences of a breach of the conflict-of-interest rule?

A board resolution adopted with the participation of a conflicted director is voidable; the court annuls it on a claim brought within one year (Article 2:15(1)(a), (3) and (5) DCC). The director may be liable towards the company if he or she can be seriously blamed (Article 2:9 DCC). The board’s power to represent the company towards third parties remains unlimited and unconditional, except where the law provides otherwise (Article 2:240(3)); the articles of association can, however, provide that a director may only represent the company jointly with one or more others (Article 2:240(2)).

What about conflicts of interest between shareholders and managers?

Directors must be guided by the interest of the company and its business, not only by the interest of the shareholders (Article 2:239(5) DCC). The statutory conflict rule applies to directors and supervisory directors, not to shareholders voting at the general meeting. Shareholders and the company must, however, behave towards each other as required by reasonableness and fairness (Article 2:8 DCC).

Does the rule apply to managers who are employees?

The rule in Article 2:239(6) DCC applies to statutory directors. A manager who is only an employee must act as a good employee (Article 7:611 DCC) and follow the employer’s rules, such as a code of conduct or a conflict-of-interest policy.

Primary sources

Conclusion

When facing conflicts of interest, remember: disclosure isn’t enough. Identify the conflict, inform your co-directors (and, where relevant, the supervisory board), and stay out of the deliberations and decision-making on that matter (Article 2:239(6) DCC).

When in doubt, ask, and don’t risk your colleagues’ trust or the company’s reputation. Be proactive.

Dutch law firm specialized in conflicts of interest

For any legal inquiries or support in the Netherlands about a conflict of interest between a manager and a company, please feel free to contact our adept team at MAAK Advocaten.

News & Insights
Which topics would you like to receive updates on?
Who are you?
Which industry or sector do you operate in? (Optional)