English Terms and Conditions Under Dutch Law

Share this article

WhatsAppLinkedIn

Published on · Last updated

English general terms and conditions are lawful under Dutch law. Whether they bind your Dutch counterparty depends on whether it could reasonably understand your reference as a proposal to apply them (Article 3:35). Between a foreign and a Dutch business, the special Dutch rules on standard terms as a rule do not apply (Article 6:247(2) Dutch Civil Code).

In short

  • The standard terms rules of Articles 6:231 to 6:247 BW contain no language requirement; with consumers, terms must be clear and understandable (Article 6:238(2)).
  • Where the Dutch rules apply, a reasonable opportunity to read the terms is required (Article 6:234), but larger businesses cannot invoke its absence (Article 6:235).
  • The language of your terms does not determine the governing law; the choice of the parties does (Article 3(1) Rome I).
  • Have your English terms reviewed by a Dutch lawyer before first use with Dutch parties, and when a counterparty disputes that they apply.

Can you use English general terms and conditions under Dutch law?

Dutch law allows English general terms and conditions. The statutory rules on standard terms in Articles 6:231 to 6:247 of the Dutch Civil Code (BW) contain no language requirement. What matters is the opportunity to read the terms and, for consumers, whether they are clear.

The real question is whether you can prove that your terms became part of the contract. That starts with offer and acceptance (Article 6:217 BW). Did your offer clearly refer to your terms? And could you reasonably treat your counterparty’s response as agreement to them (Article 3:35 BW)? A reference in a language the other party does not read makes this harder to prove.

Where the Dutch standard terms rules apply, not knowing the content is not a way out in itself: under Article 6:232 BW, a counterparty is bound even if the user knew or should have known that it was unaware of the content. Language does matter for two other questions: was the reference understood, and did the other party have a reasonable opportunity to read the text? The full statutory text is available in Book 6 of the Dutch Civil Code on wetten.overheid.nl (in Dutch).

Do the Dutch standard terms rules apply to a foreign company?

Between businesses that are not both established in the Netherlands, Articles 6:231 to 6:247 BW do not apply. That remains so when Dutch law governs the contract (Article 6:247(2) BW). The rules on offer and acceptance then decide whether your terms apply.

The Article 6:234 route for offering the terms then falls away. The Dutch counterparty cannot rely on the grounds for annulment in Article 6:233 BW either. The question remains whether it could reasonably understand your reference as a proposal to apply your terms (Article 3:35 BW). The language of that reference counts. The limiting effect of reasonableness and fairness also continues to apply (Article 6:248(2) BW).

The position changes if a Dutch branch performs the contract. The test looks at the principal place of business, or at the branch that must carry out the performance under the contract (Article 6:247(3) BW). If both parties are then established in the Netherlands, the standard terms rules apply whatever law governs the contract (paragraph 1).

Important: Whether the Dutch standard terms rules apply is decided contract by contract. The place of the performing branch (Article 6:247(3)) and a consumer counterparty living in the Netherlands (Article 6:247(4)) can bring them back, so check both, with a Dutch lawyer, before you rely on the rule for foreign businesses.

If you choose Dutch law, a court will in principle assess whether the contract and a term exist under that law (Article 10(1) of Regulation (EC) No 593/2008, Rome I). Your counterparty may, however, rely on the law of its habitual residence to show that it did not consent. That route is open if it would not be reasonable to judge its conduct under the chosen law (Article 10(2)). In a sale governed by the CISG, however, the Convention itself decides whether a party consented to general terms (HR 28 January 2005, ECLI:NL:HR:2005:AR4837, para. 3.3.2). For cross-border sales of goods, there is also the question of a dispute over the CISG and general terms and conditions.

When did your counterparty have a reasonable opportunity to read the terms?

Where the Dutch rules apply, your counterparty had that opportunity if you handed over the terms before or at the conclusion of the contract (Article 6:234(1) BW). For an electronic contract, digital delivery in a form it can store and consult later is enough.

Article 6:234 BW sets out these routes:

  • You hand over the text on paper or as an attachment, before or when the contract is concluded (paragraph 1).
  • You make the text available electronically, so that your counterparty can store it and consult it later (paragraph 2).
  • If the contract is not concluded electronically, you need your counterparty’s express consent for that digital route (paragraph 3).
  • Only if handing over or making them available electronically is not reasonably possible may you announce in advance where the terms can be inspected or consulted electronically, or that they are filed with the Dutch Chamber of Commerce or a court registry. You must then send them promptly and at your own cost on request, or the terms remain voidable (paragraphs 1 and 2).

Article 6:234 BW says nothing about language. If the other party does not read English, whether an English text gave it a reasonable opportunity depends on the circumstances. Think of the language of the negotiations, the language of the quotation and order confirmation, and the language your counterparty uses in its own correspondence.

Not every counterparty can invoke this ground for annulment. Article 6:235(1) BW excludes larger businesses: a legal entity within the meaning of Article 2:360 BW that, when the contract was concluded, had most recently published its annual accounts (or to which Article 2:403(1) was last applied), and any other party at which fifty or more people worked at that time or for which the commercial register showed fifty or more. A party that itself repeatedly uses the same or nearly the same terms also lacks this protection (paragraph 3). For the general rules, see when general terms and conditions apply under Dutch law and how a battle of forms works under Dutch law.

What applies to English terms used with Dutch consumers?

With consumers, terms must be clear and understandable. Where the meaning of a term is in doubt, the interpretation most favourable to the consumer prevails (Article 6:238(2) BW). An English text a Dutch consumer cannot follow works against you.

If the consumer has their habitual residence in the Netherlands, the Dutch standard terms rules apply, whatever law governs the contract (Article 6:247(4) BW).

If you sell through a webshop, state before the order in which languages the contract can be concluded (Article 6:227b(1)(d) BW). A contract concluded under the influence of missing information on this point is voidable (paragraph 4). Businesses may agree to deviate from this information duty among themselves (paragraph 6).

If you direct your activities at consumers in the Netherlands, you may choose a law, for example your own. That choice does not deprive the consumer of the protection of the mandatory rules of their country of residence (Article 6(2) Rome I). Terms in a language the consumer reads also reduce the risk of a dispute.

Unsure whether your English terms will hold up against Dutch customers? A contract lawyer in the Netherlands can review them with you, including how you deliver the terms to the other party.

Which language version prevails if your terms exist in two languages?

The provisions discussed on this page do not say which language version prevails. You set this yourself in a precedence clause, for example that the English text decides in case of differences. Such a clause is itself one of your general terms within the meaning of Article 6:231(a) BW.

With consumers, a precedence clause offers less certainty. If a term is unclear in one of the versions, the interpretation most favourable to the consumer prevails where there is doubt (Article 6:238(2) BW). Do not count on a precedence clause to cure a careless translation.

Between businesses, a precedence clause works best if the governing version is in a language your counterparty reads. If a Dutch buyer only received the Dutch version, a clause stating that the English text prevails may do little for you.

Watch out for concepts that Dutch law fills in differently. Under Dutch property law, Article 3:92 BW sets out how retention of title works, known in Dutch as “eigendomsvoorbehoud“. Terms such as “consequential loss” or “best endeavours” come from English contract practice. A court reads them under the chosen law (Article 12(1)(a) Rome I), so define them in your terms if you use them. Background is available in our comparison of Dutch civil law and English contract law.

How does the language of your terms relate to the choice of law?

The language of your terms does not determine the governing law. Parties choose it, expressly or clearly demonstrated by the terms of the contract or the circumstances (Article 3(1) Rome I). English-language terms do not automatically turn your contract into one governed by English law.

Without a choice, Rome I determines the governing law. Include an express choice of law in your terms. The chosen law also governs the interpretation of the contract (Article 12(1)(a) Rome I). A court can then read English legal terms in the light of the chosen law, which is another reason to avoid or define them.

Combine the choice of law with a jurisdiction clause, so that it is also clear which court hears disputes. With consumers, further limits apply: Article 6:236(n) BW treats a term that sends a dispute to someone other than the competent court, for example an arbitrator, as unreasonably onerous unless the consumer has at least one month after the user invokes it to opt for the court. More on this in our articles on choice of law in contracts under Dutch law and on Dutch jurisdiction in international disputes.

How do you make sure your English terms apply to a Dutch counterparty?

Refer to your terms before you conclude the contract, in the language of the negotiations, and hand over the text or make it available digitally. That meets Article 6:234 BW where it applies, and your counterparty can understand the reference.

  • Refer to your terms in the language of the negotiations in your quotation and order confirmation.
  • Attach the full text, or send a link to a version your counterparty can download and store.
  • Use the same version on your website, quotations and invoices, with a date or version number.
  • Record when and how you sent the terms, so you can prove it later.
  • If you have several language versions, at least provide the version in your counterparty’s language and add a precedence clause.

What goes wrong with a reference your Dutch counterparty cannot read?

A reference your counterparty cannot read may mean your terms do not apply. Between businesses not both established in the Netherlands, a court applying Dutch law uses the general rules on offer and acceptance (Article 6:217 BW) rather than Article 6:234 BW.

Suppose (illustration) a Polish maintenance-services supplier signs a framework agreement with a Dutch distributor that chooses Dutch law. This is a services contract. For a sale of goods between parties in two CISG states, the CISG would decide first whether the terms were agreed, and Dutch law only what the CISG does not regulate (see the CISG and general terms and conditions). The negotiations take place in English. The order confirmations, however, refer to the supplier’s terms only in Polish, without an attachment. After a delivery, a dispute arises about the limitation of liability in those terms.

The supplier is not established in the Netherlands, so Articles 6:233 and 6:234 BW do not apply (Article 6:247(2) BW). The dispute then turns on whether the distributor should have understood the Polish line as a proposal to apply the terms. An English reference with the text attached could have avoided that discussion.

When should you have English terms reviewed by a Dutch lawyer?

Have your English general terms reviewed before you first use them with Dutch customers or suppliers. The same applies if you add a translation next to an existing version, or if a counterparty disputes that the terms apply. Check the choice of law and jurisdiction clause too.

Timing matters too where the Dutch standard terms rules apply. The limitation period for annulling a term only starts on the day after the user has invoked that term (Article 6:235(4) BW). The period therefore does not run from the conclusion of the contract.

If a counterparty disputes that your English terms apply, Remko Roosjen can assess the position under Dutch law. See also our page on having your general terms reviewed by a Dutch lawyer and our overview of general terms and conditions in the Netherlands.

Frequently asked questions about English general terms and conditions under Dutch law

Do general terms and conditions have to be in Dutch?

As a rule, a Dutch version is not required: Articles 6:231 to 6:247 BW contain no language requirement. What matters is whether your counterparty could understand the reference to your terms and, where those rules apply, had a reasonable opportunity to read them (Articles 6:233(b) and 6:234). With consumers, terms must also be clear (Article 6:238(2)).

Does Article 6:234 BW apply if my company is based outside the Netherlands?

In dealings with a Dutch business, as a rule it does not. If the parties are not both established in the Netherlands, the standard terms rules of the BW do not apply, even if Dutch law governs the contract (Article 6:247(2) BW). With consumers resident in the Netherlands, they apply (paragraph 4).

Is a counterparty bound by English terms it has not read?

Possibly, if your reference was clear enough to count as a proposal to apply the terms. Where the Dutch standard terms rules apply, Article 6:232 BW binds a counterparty that accepted the terms even if the user understood that it did not know their content, subject to annulment (Article 6:233(b)). Otherwise, offer and acceptance decide (Articles 3:35 and 6:217).

Which text applies if the Dutch and English versions differ?

A precedence clause in your terms decides this; the provisions discussed here do not. With consumers, the interpretation most favourable to them prevails where the meaning of a term is in doubt (Article 6:238(2) BW). Do not rely on a precedence clause to correct an unclear translation in your favour.

Do English terms mean English law applies?

English terms do not by themselves lead to English law. The governing law follows from the parties’ choice (Article 3(1) Rome I) and, without a choice, from the other rules of the Rome I Regulation. Include an express choice of Dutch law if that is the law you want to apply.

Primary sources

Dutch statutes are officially published in Dutch, on wetten.overheid.nl. Judgments can be found on rechtspraak.nl by their ECLI number.

News & Insights
Which topics would you like to receive updates on?
Who are you?
Which industry or sector do you operate in? (Optional)