Published on · Last updated
Under Dutch law, a buyer or other creditor loses its rights for a defect if it does not complain to the other party within a reasonable time after it discovered the defect or reasonably should have discovered it (Article 6:89 Dutch Civil Code; for sales Article 7:23). Between businesses there is no fixed period: the court weighs all circumstances. Under the CISG, the outer limit is two years.
This page is for foreign businesses that buy goods or services from a Dutch party, or that sell to one and face a late complaint. It explains when a complaint is required, how quickly, what it must contain and who must prove what. For the remedies after a timely complaint, see our page on non-conformity in Dutch contract law. The wider framework is on our overview of litigation in the Netherlands.
When is a complaint required under Dutch law?
A complaint is required whenever you want to rely on a defect in a performance. The general rule applies to all obligations, including services and works: the creditor can no longer invoke a defect if it did not protest to the debtor within a reasonable time after discovering it or after it reasonably should have discovered it (Article 6:89 Dutch Civil Code).
For the sale of goods, Article 7:23(1) Dutch Civil Code contains a specific rule. The buyer can no longer invoke the fact that the goods do not conform to the contract if it did not notify the seller within a reasonable time after it discovered, or reasonably should have discovered, the lack of conformity. In Dutch this duty is called the klachtplicht (duty to complain).
The consequence is severe: the buyer loses all its rights based on that defect, including repair, replacement, price reduction, damages and termination of the contract.
How quickly must you complain about a defect in the Netherlands?
Between businesses, there is no fixed period. Whether a complaint was made within a reasonable time is assessed by weighing all interests and circumstances, including whether the seller suffered a disadvantage from the delay. A fixed period cannot be used, not even as a starting point (Hoge Raad 12 December 2014, ECLI:NL:HR:2014:3593, ground 5.6.1).
The Hoge Raad (Supreme Court of the Netherlands) also held in that judgment that the buyer must carry out the inspection that can reasonably be expected of it in the circumstances. The reasonable time starts when the buyer discovered the defect, or should have discovered it through such an inspection. The time that passed is an important factor, but not decisive. The court weighs it against the seller’s concrete interests, such as a weaker evidential position or lost chances to limit the damage.
| Situation | Time limit for the complaint | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Sale between businesses, Dutch law | within a reasonable time after discovery or after the defect should have been discovered; no fixed period | Art. 7:23(1) DCC; ECLI:NL:HR:2014:3593 |
| Goods lack a quality the seller said they had, or the defect concerns facts the seller knew or ought to have known but did not disclose | within a reasonable time after actual discovery | Art. 7:23(1), second sentence |
| Consumer sale | within a reasonable time after discovery; two months after discovery is always in time | Art. 7:23(1), third sentence |
| Services and other obligations | within a reasonable time after discovery or after the defect should have been discovered | Art. 6:89 DCC |
| International sale under the CISG | within a reasonable time, specifying the nature of the defect; at the latest two years after the goods were handed over | Art. 39 CISG |
Does the duty to complain apply to international sales?
Yes, but often under the CISG instead of the Dutch Civil Code. The United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods applies to sales of goods between parties established in different contracting states, or where the rules of private international law lead to the law of a contracting state (Article 1 CISG). The Netherlands is a contracting state, so a choice of Dutch law in an international sales contract usually brings the CISG with it, unless the parties excluded it (Article 6 CISG).
Under the CISG, the buyer must examine the goods within as short a period as is practicable in the circumstances (Article 38 CISG). It must give notice within a reasonable time, specifying the nature of the lack of conformity, and in any event within two years after the goods were actually handed over, unless a contractual guarantee period differs (Article 39 CISG). The seller cannot rely on a late notice if the lack of conformity relates to facts it knew or could not have been unaware of and did not disclose (Article 40 CISG). A buyer with a reasonable excuse for failing to give notice within a reasonable time keeps a limited right to a price reduction or to damages other than loss of profit; this does not apply after the two-year limit (Article 44 CISG). More detail is on our page on the notice of non-conformity under the CISG.
What applies to defects in construction and other works?
For a contract for work (aanneming van werk), the general rule of Article 6:89 Dutch Civil Code applies to defects that appear after completion. The contractor is in principle released from liability for defects that the client reasonably should have discovered at delivery, but for buildings the contractor remains liable for defects not discovered at delivery, unless they cannot be attributed to the contractor (Article 7:758(3) and (4) Dutch Civil Code).
If the work shows defects after delivery for which the contractor is liable, the client must in principle give the contractor the opportunity to remedy them within a reasonable time (Article 7:759(1) Dutch Civil Code). A claim for a defect in the work becomes time-barred two years after the client protested. If the client gave the contractor a period to remedy the defect, the two years only start at the end of that period, or earlier if the contractor stated that it will not repair. In any event, the claim is time-barred twenty years after delivery for buildings and ten years after delivery for other works (Article 7:761(1) and (2) Dutch Civil Code). That is why the date of your complaint matters twice: for the duty to complain and for the limitation period.
What must a complaint contain?
Dutch law does not prescribe a form. The complaint must make clear to the seller that the buyer considers the performance defective, so that the seller can investigate and respond. Under the CISG, the notice must specify the nature of the lack of conformity (Article 39(1) CISG).
- Put the complaint in writing, by e-mail or letter, and keep proof of sending and receipt.
- Describe the defect as specifically as you can: which delivery, which products, which deviation from the contract.
- State when and how you discovered the defect.
- Add photos, test reports or inspection results if you have them.
- Reserve all rights, and invite the seller to inspect the goods.
A complaint is not the same as a notice of default (ingebrekestelling). If you want to claim damages or terminate the contract, you may also need to give the seller a reasonable period to perform (Article 6:82 Dutch Civil Code). Both can be combined in one letter.
Who has to prove that the complaint was late?
The court only applies the duty to complain if the seller raises the defence that the complaint was late. If the seller does not raise it, the court may not apply Article 7:23 on its own initiative (Hoge Raad 22 April 2022, ECLI:NL:HR:2022:582, ground 3.2-3.3).
If the seller does raise the defence, the buyer must state, and if necessary prove, that it complained and when. The seller bears the burden of stating and proving the facts from which it follows when the buyer discovered or should have discovered the defect, and that the complaint came too late (ECLI:NL:HR:2014:3593, grounds 5.6.2 and 5.6.3). A dated e-mail with a clear description is therefore worth a great deal.
What happens after a timely complaint?
A timely complaint preserves your rights, but it starts a new clock. For the sale of goods under Dutch law, claims and defences based on a lack of conformity become time-barred two years after the complaint (Article 7:23(2) Dutch Civil Code). The buyer can still raise a price reduction or damages as a defence against a claim for payment of the price. The period does not run as long as the buyer cannot exercise its rights because of the seller’s intent (Article 7:23(3)).
Do not let the complaint be the end of the matter. Interrupt the limitation period in time or start proceedings. See our page on the limitation period under Dutch law.
Practical example: a late complaint about steel parts
Suppose a French machine builder buys steel parts from a Dutch supplier under Dutch law. The parts are delivered in March. The French company assembles them in June and discovers in September that they bend under load. It complains in January.
The supplier claims the complaint was late. As both parties are established in contracting states, the CISG applies unless the contract excludes it (Article 1(1)(a) CISG). The court will then look at whether the buyer examined the parts within as short a period as was practicable (Article 38 CISG), when that examination would have revealed the defect, whether the defect was visible or only appeared under load, and whether the notice in January, specifying the defect, was given within a reasonable time (Article 39(1) CISG). The two-year outer limit of Article 39(2) CISG is not an issue here. A complaint sent in September, with photos and a test report, would have avoided most of this discussion.
When should you involve a Dutch lawyer?
Involve a Dutch lawyer when you discover a defect and the amount at stake is significant, or when a seller argues that your complaint was too late. The wording of the complaint, the combination with a notice of default and the protection against limitation are decided in the first weeks.
MAAK Advocaten in Amsterdam advises foreign and Dutch businesses on defective goods and services under Dutch law and the CISG, and litigates before the Dutch courts in first instance and on appeal. Read more about our work as a litigation attorney in the Netherlands.
Frequently asked questions about the time limit for complaints in the Netherlands
When is a complaint required under Dutch law?
Whenever you want to rely on a defect in a performance. Under Article 6:89 of the Dutch Civil Code, and for sales Article 7:23, you lose your rights if you do not complain within a reasonable time after you discovered the defect or reasonably should have discovered it.
Is there a fixed period for complaints between businesses in the Netherlands?
No. The Hoge Raad held that a fixed period cannot be used, not even as a starting point. The court weighs all circumstances, including the inspection that could be expected of the buyer and whether the seller was harmed by the delay (ECLI:NL:HR:2014:3593).
Does the two-month period apply to business buyers?
No. The rule that a notice within two months after discovery is always in time applies to consumer sales only (Article 7:23(1) Dutch Civil Code). Business buyers must complain within a reasonable time, which can be shorter or longer depending on the circumstances.
What is the time limit for a notice of non-conformity under the CISG?
The buyer must give notice within a reasonable time after it discovered or should have discovered the lack of conformity, specifying its nature, and at the latest within two years after the goods were actually handed over, unless a contractual guarantee period differs (Article 39 CISG).
Can a Dutch court apply the duty to complain on its own initiative?
No. The duty to complain is only applied if the seller argues that the complaint was late. If the seller does not raise that defence, the court may not apply Article 7:23 of the Dutch Civil Code (Hoge Raad 22 April 2022, ECLI:NL:HR:2022:582).
Primary sources
Dutch statutes are only officially available in Dutch, on wetten.overheid.nl. Judgments can be found on rechtspraak.nl by their ECLI number.
- Dutch Civil Code (Burgerlijk Wetboek) Book 6: Article 6:82, Article 6:89
- Dutch Civil Code Book 7: Article 7:23, Article 7:758, Article 7:759, Article 7:761
- United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG): Article 1, Article 6, Article 38, Article 39, Article 40, Article 44
- Hoge Raad 12 December 2014, ECLI:NL:HR:2014:3593 (grounds 5.6.1-5.6.3)
- Hoge Raad 22 April 2022, ECLI:NL:HR:2022:582 (grounds 3.2-3.3)