Expert Witness Investigation in Dutch Civil Proceedings

Published on · Last updated

In Dutch civil proceedings, an expert investigation is ordered by the court, not by the parties. The court appoints an independent expert after consulting the parties and asks specific questions (Article 186 of the Dutch Code of Civil Procedure, Rv). Before a case starts, a party can request a preliminary expert report (Article 196 Rv). The claimant usually pays the advance.

This page is for foreign businesses involved in a technical dispute before a Dutch court, for example about machinery, software, construction or damaged goods. It explains when the court appoints an expert, how the investigation runs, what it costs and how you influence the outcome. For the general rules on evidence, see evidence in Dutch civil law and our overview of litigation in the Netherlands.

Is an expert witness the same in Dutch law as in common law?

No. In Dutch proceedings the key expert is appointed by the court and owes no duty to either party. The expert must carry out the task impartially and to the best of his knowledge (Article 190(1) Rv).

Each party may also submit a report from its own expert. Such a report is evidence like any other document and the court weighs it freely (Article 152 Rv). With the court’s permission, a party-appointed expert can also be heard at a hearing; the other party may then do the same (Article 192(1) and (3) Rv). A party expert can carry less weight than the court’s own expert, because the court did not choose him and the other side had no say in his questions.

When does a Dutch court appoint an expert?

The court can order a written report or an oral examination of experts at the request of a party or on its own initiative. The judgment states the questions on which the expert’s opinion is sought (Article 186(1) Rv).

Typical questions are whether a machine met the agreed specifications, what caused a defect in a building, whether software was delivered according to the functional design, or how much damage a party suffered. The court can order an investigation when the answer may decide the case and requires knowledge the court does not have.

How does the appointment of an expert work?

The court appoints one or more experts by judgment or later order after consulting the parties (Article 186(2) Rv). The court can ask the parties to propose an expert jointly and to submit draft questions.

  1. Consultation. The parties comment on the choice of expert and the questions. Use this moment: the questions determine the answer.
  2. Appointment. The court appoints the expert. There is no appeal against the appointment (Article 186(2) Rv).
  3. Advance. The court can ask the expert to estimate the costs and orders an advance, as a rule to be paid by the claimant (Article 187 Rv).
  4. Time limits. The court sets where and when the investigation takes place and by when the report must be filed (Article 189 Rv).
  5. Investigation. The expert works independently or under the court’s direction and must give both parties the opportunity to comment and make requests (Article 190(2) Rv).
  6. Report. The written report is reasoned and signed; the registrar sends a copy to the parties (Article 190(4) Rv).

If the appointed expert does not accept or cannot complete the task properly, the court can appoint another expert after consulting the parties (Article 186(4) Rv).

What are your rights and duties during the investigation?

The parties must cooperate with the investigation. If a party refuses, the court can draw the conclusions it sees fit (Article 190(3) Rv). That can mean that the court assumes the facts are as the other party says.

In return, both parties must be given the opportunity to comment and make requests, and the written report must show whether this happened (Article 190(2) Rv). An expert can send a draft report for this purpose. A party that sends written comments to the expert must send a copy to the other party at the same time.

  • Give the expert the documents and access to systems or sites he needs, on time.
  • Respond to the draft report with concrete, technical comments, if necessary supported by your own expert.
  • Point out where the expert goes beyond the questions or relies on facts that are disputed.

What can you do if you disagree with the expert report?

You can comment on the report in the proceedings, and the court decides how much weight to give it. The court is not bound by the expert’s opinion (Article 152(2) Rv), but a report that is well reasoned and resulted from a careful procedure carries considerable weight.

At the request of a party or on its own initiative, the court can order the expert to give a further oral or written explanation or a supplement. Only after the expert had that opportunity can the court appoint another expert, unless it considers a further explanation pointless (Article 186(5) Rv). A report from your own expert, or hearing that expert with the court’s permission (Article 192 Rv), can support your objections.

What is a preliminary expert report?

A preliminary expert report is an expert investigation ordered before the main case is on the cause list. It is one of the preliminary evidence measures that the court can order at the request of an interested party (Article 196(1) Rv).

The petition must state the questions for the expert and the names and qualifications of one or more experts you propose (Article 197(3) Rv). The court grants the request unless the information is not sufficiently specified, there is insufficient interest, the request conflicts with due process, there is abuse of power or other weighty reasons oppose it (Article 196(2) Rv). If granted, the court appoints the expert after consulting the parties, and the rules on experts apply accordingly (Article 202(1) Rv).

A preliminary report is useful when the situation will change: a building that must be repaired, goods that will be destroyed or software that will be replaced. An arbitration agreement does not prevent the request (Article 1022b Rv). You can combine it with a preliminary witness examination.

What does an expert investigation cost and who pays?

The expert is entitled to compensation for expenses and a fee, which the court assesses (Article 191(1) Rv). The registrar pays the expert from the advance; if the advance is insufficient, the remainder can be recovered from the party or parties designated to pay it (Article 191(2) Rv).

The advance is paid by the claimant, unless the court designates the other party or both parties, for example because the defendant bears the burden of proof on the expert’s questions (Article 187 Rv). If a party does not pay within the time limit, the court can draw the conclusions it sees fit (Article 188(2) Rv). At the end of the case, the losing party is as a rule ordered to pay the costs of the proceedings, which can include the expert’s costs (Article 237 Rv).

The amount depends on the expert’s hourly rate, the scope of the questions and the need for tests or site visits. Ask the court to have the expert estimate the costs before the investigation starts.

The court has ordered an expert investigation: what should you do now?

Act within the period the court sets. The first weeks determine who the expert is, what he will answer and whether you can afford the advance.

  1. Check the questions in the judgment and propose additions or corrections in the consultation round.
  2. Assess the proposed expert for independence and expertise.
  3. Arrange payment of the advance on time if you are designated to pay.
  4. Prepare your documents and, if useful, appoint your own expert to follow the investigation.

Practical example: a dispute about a defective production line

Suppose an Italian manufacturer delivers a bottling line to a Dutch brewery. The brewery claims damages because the line stops several times a day. The manufacturer says the brewery’s staff operate it incorrectly. The court orders an expert investigation and asks whether the line meets the agreed specifications and what causes the stoppages.

The manufacturer proposes questions about the operating instructions and the maintenance history, so that the expert also investigates the brewery’s role. Its own engineer attends the inspection and comments on the draft report. The final report attributes part of the stoppages to operator errors, which limits the damages.

When should you involve a Dutch lawyer?

Involve a Dutch lawyer when a technical dispute is likely to end in court, and in any event before the court consults the parties on the expert and the questions. That is when you have the most influence.

MAAK Advocaten in Amsterdam assists foreign and Dutch businesses in technical and commercial disputes before the Dutch courts, in first instance and on appeal. We draft the questions, request preliminary expert reports and work with party experts. Read more about our work as a litigation attorney in the Netherlands.

Frequently asked questions about expert investigations in Dutch civil proceedings

Who appoints the expert in Dutch civil proceedings?

The court. It orders an expert report at a party’s request or on its own initiative and appoints the expert after consulting the parties (Article 186 Dutch Code of Civil Procedure). Parties may also submit reports from their own experts, which the court weighs freely.

Who pays for a court-appointed expert in the Netherlands?

As a rule, the claimant pays the advance set by the court, unless the court designates the other party or both parties (Article 187 Dutch Code of Civil Procedure). The losing party is ordered to pay the costs of the proceedings at the end of the case.

Is the Dutch court bound by the expert report?

No. The court weighs the report freely. It can ask the expert for a further explanation or supplement and only after that appoint another expert, unless it considers further explanation pointless (Article 186(5) Dutch Code of Civil Procedure).

Can I request an expert report before starting proceedings in the Netherlands?

Yes. Before a case is on the cause list, an interested party can ask the court for a preliminary expert report (Articles 196 and 202 Dutch Code of Civil Procedure). The petition must state the questions and the proposed experts.

Do parties have to cooperate with a court-appointed expert?

Yes. Parties must cooperate with the investigation, and if a party does not, the court can draw the conclusions it sees fit (Article 190(3) Dutch Code of Civil Procedure). The expert must give both parties the opportunity to comment and make requests.

Primary sources

Dutch statutes are only officially available in Dutch, on wetten.overheid.nl. Judgments can be found on rechtspraak.nl by their ECLI number.

News & Insights
Which topics would you like to receive updates on?
Who are you?
Which industry or sector do you operate in? (Optional)