Sander van Someren Gréve is a Dutch yachting lawyer at MAAK Advocaten in Amsterdam who acts in disputes over buying, building and refitting yachts, including claims against yards, sellers and brokers. He handles disputes over defects in newly built yachts, warranty claims against yacht builders and conflicts over construction and refit contracts. He does so in negotiation, at first instance, on appeal and in arbitration.
In a yacht dispute, time counts. The yacht is at the yard, the season is running and a deadline may already apply. Your goal comes first: the yacht back on the water, or the defect repaired. The legal route follows.
Which yacht disputes does Sander van Someren Gréve handle?
Disputes over the purchase, new build, refit and repair of yachts: defects, warranty, extra work, delay, a yard that keeps the yacht, and claims against brokers. He acts for buyers and owners, and for yards, sellers and brokers facing a claim.
Under Dutch law a yacht you buy must conform to the contract (Article 7:17(1) Dutch Civil Code). If the seller, the yard or the broker fails to perform, it must compensate the damage. The exception is a failure that cannot be attributed to it (Article 6:74(1) Dutch Civil Code). For an overview, see yachting lawyers in the Netherlands.
What can you do if a newly built yacht has defects?
Report the defect to the yard in writing within a reasonable time and give it the chance to repair. Unless you commissioned the yacht privately from a professional yard, the yard is not liable for defects you should reasonably have noticed at delivery.
The construction contract (aanneming van werk) is defined in Article 7:750(1); the delivery rule is in Article 7:758(3). You must protest within a reasonable time after you discovered the defect or should have discovered it (Article 6:89). In general you must also give the yard a reasonable term to remedy it (Article 7:759(1)). The claim is time-barred two years after your protest, or after the repair term you set (sooner if the yard refuses), and at the latest ten years after delivery (Article 7:761).
If a private individual commissions a new yacht from a professional yard, the contract is also a consumer sale (Article 7:5(4)). In a conflict, the sales rules prevail. That exception does not apply to a refit or repair. What to agree before the build starts is set out in a yacht building contract with a Dutch yard.
What if a defect appears after you bought a yacht?
Notify the seller within a reasonable time after you discovered the defect or should have discovered it. A private buyer from a professional seller is in any case in time within two months of discovery. The claim is time-barred two years after that notice.
Both rules are in Article 7:23(1) and (2) Dutch Civil Code. The yacht must have the properties you could expect under the contract (Article 7:17(2)). More on your rights for yacht defects after purchase.
Recognise your situation? Send Sander the contract, the correspondence and any survey report, and you will hear which step makes sense now. Contact MAAK about your yacht.
When is a yacht broker liable?
A broker who acts in a yacht sale must observe the care of a good service provider (goed opdrachtnemer). If it falls short, it can be liable for its principal’s loss. A broker acting for both sides may also lose its fee.
The duty of care is in Article 7:401 Dutch Civil Code. Acting for both buyer and seller is allowed only if the terms are so precisely fixed that a conflict of interests is excluded (Article 7:417(1)). Article 7:427 applies this rule to brokers. A private principal must also consent in writing (Article 7:417(2)). A broker who breaches these rules has no right to its fee from that principal (Article 7:417(3)).
What can you do if a Dutch yard keeps your yacht?
A yard with an unpaid claim that is due for work on your yacht may, under conditions, keep it until paid. Security does not always release the yacht, because the yard may also suspend performance under the same contract.
The right of retention (retentierecht) is in Article 3:290 Dutch Civil Code. Sufficient security in principle ends that right (Articles 6:55 and 6:57). That is different where the yard also suspends under Article 6:262 for an unpaid invoice from the same contract (Article 6:264). Suspension is allowed only as far as the failure justifies it (Article 6:262(2)). Read what to do when a yard keeps your yacht in the Netherlands.
Which law and which court apply to an international yacht dispute?
The contract may choose the governing law and the competent court. Against a private buyer or client from another EU Member State, those choices have limited effect, because EU rules protect the consumer.
The choice of law follows from Article 3(1) Rome I Regulation. A consumer in principle keeps the mandatory protection of the law of his habitual residence (Article 6(1) and (2) Rome I). Conditions: the professional seller or yard pursues or directs its activities to that country, and the contract falls within them. Article 6(4) contains exceptions, such as services supplied exclusively outside that country. In general you sue the other party in the Member State where it is domiciled (Article 4(1) Brussels I bis Regulation). If the seller or yard directs its activities to the consumer’s country, a court clause agreed before the dispute generally does not work to his detriment. He can then be sued only where he is domiciled (Articles 17(1)(c), 18(2), 19 and 25(4) Brussels I bis). See which law applies to a yacht purchase in the Netherlands.
Sander has also litigated jurisdiction questions. On appeal he represented a German GmbH in a dispute over the jurisdiction of the Dutch courts. The court held that the Dutch courts lacked jurisdiction under Article 7(1) or Article 25(1) Brussels I bis. It upheld the district court’s judgment (Court of Appeal of ‘s-Hertogenbosch 11 June 2024, ECLI:NL:GHSHE:2024:1911). That was not a yacht case, but the same regulation.
How is a yacht dispute resolved: court, summary proceedings or arbitration?
Before the Dutch courts, in summary proceedings (kort geding) if urgent, or in arbitration if the parties agreed to it. An appeal must be lodged within three months of the judgment, or four weeks after summary proceedings.
The appeal terms are in Article 339(1) and (2) Dutch Code of Civil Procedure. In urgent cases the preliminary relief judge can grant an immediate provisional measure (Article 254(1)). Arbitration requires an agreement, either an arbitration clause or a submission after the dispute arose (Article 1020(1) and (2)). To secure a claim, a creditor can arrest a yacht with leave of the preliminary relief judge (Article 700(1)); see yacht arrest in the Netherlands.
Sander litigates at first instance and on appeal, and acts in arbitration. Which route fits depends on the contract and the amount at stake.
When do you need a Dutch lawyer for a yacht dispute?
Instruct a lawyer once a deadline runs, the other party ignores your notice, the yard keeps your yacht or you consider proceedings. Before a Dutch district court, a lawyer is mandatory in proceedings on the merits, except before the sub-district court.
That obligation follows from Article 79 Dutch Code of Civil Procedure. After a prejudgment arrest of a yacht, proceedings on the claim must start within the term set by the preliminary relief judge. That term is at least eight days after the arrest (Article 700(3)).
Who is Sander van Someren Gréve?
Sander van Someren Gréve is a partner at MAAK Advocaten in Amsterdam. He has been a lawyer since 14 January 2015, is registered in the district of Amsterdam and is named in judgments as mr. A.P. van Someren Gréve.
In the register of legal practice areas of the Netherlands Bar Association (rechtsgebiedenregister), he is listed with the principal area civil procedural law and the sub-areas arbitration, attachment and enforcement law, and litigation. More about his practice is on his profile as a litigation and arbitration lawyer.
Further reading on yachts under Dutch law
- Yachting lawyers in the Netherlands
- Buying a yacht under Dutch law
- Which law applies to a yacht purchase in the Netherlands
- Yacht building contract with a Dutch yard
- Yacht defects after purchase: your rights under Dutch law
- Yacht disputes in the Netherlands
- When a yard keeps your yacht
- Arresting or releasing a yacht in the Netherlands
Do you have a dispute with a yard, a seller or a broker over your yacht? Send Sander your contract and the latest correspondence, and he will discuss the next step with you. Contact MAAK Advocaten in Amsterdam.
Sander van Someren Gréve has registered the following principal (and secondary) legal practice areas in the Netherlands Bar Association’s register of legal practice areas (rechtsgebiedenregister):
– Civil procedural law (arbitration, pre-judgment attachments, enforcement law and litigation)
Based on this registration, he is required to obtain ten training credits per calendar year in each registered principal legal practice area in accordance with the standards set by the Netherlands Bar Association.